Self-testing Quantum Supermaps
Victor Barizien, Cyril Branciard, Alastair A. Abbott, Jean-Daniel Bancal, Pavel Sekatski · 2026
Read Self-testing Quantum Supermaps by Victor Barizien, Cyril Branciard, Alastair A. Abbott, Jean-Daniel Bancal, Pavel Sekatski (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-25124.txt.
Introduction
Self testing certifies a quantum object from measurement statistics alone, with no assumptions about how the devices work inside. Victor Barizien and four colleagues extend the method from states, measurements, and channels to quantum supermaps. These are operations that act on channels themselves, and can combine them in a fixed or even an indefinite causal order.
Two levels of certification emerge, set by the experiment's network structure. When each slot of the supermap takes a single uncharacterised black box, the supermap is identified up to local embedding combs. When several boxes sit inside each slot, identification sharpens to local extracting and injecting maps. Four worked examples include the identity comb, an error correcting comb, and the comb behind Grover's algorithm. The quantum switch example gives the first self test of a causally indefinite process, a new device independent way to certify causal indefiniteness.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Victor Barizien, Cyril Branciard, Alastair A. Abbott, Jean-Daniel Bancal, Pavel Sekatski |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 110 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.25124
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Self-testing Quantum Supermaps Victor Barizien, Cyril Branciard, Alastair A. Abbott, Jean-Daniel Bancal, Pavel Sekatski Abstract By certifying quantum operations from measurement statistics directly, without any assumption on the internal workings of the devices involved, self-testing enables a uniquely reliable identification of quantum objects. While such device-independent characterization has been shown to be possible for states, measurements and channels, it has so far not been extended to quantum supermaps – operations that act on quantum channels themselves and can combine them in either a well-defined causal order or also, remarkably, in an indefinite causal order. Here we show that quantum supermaps can be identified device-independently. Specifically, we obtain two levels of certification, depending on the network structure of the experiment: when each slot of the supermap accepts a single uncharacterized black box, identification up to local embedding combs is obtained; when several black boxes are inserted within each slot, identification up to local extracting and injecting maps is achieved. We illustrate our approach on four examples – the identity comb, a bit-flip error-correcting comb, the comb describing Grover’s algorithm, and the quantum switch – providing in particular the first self-test of both a quantum algorithmic comb and a causally indefinite quantum process. Notably, in the latter case, this provides a new way to certify causal indefiniteness in a device-independent manner. I Introduction The characterization and certification of quantum resources is a central problem in quantum information science. Using one of the preeminent features of quantum theory, namely its ability to generate non-classical correlations, has become a powerful tool for obtaining such characterization. One of the starkest examples of this is the concept of self-testing 27 ; 55 . Self-testing exploits quantum correlations – typically the maximal violation of a Bell inequality – to provide the most complete quantum description of a system under study that is achievable in a black-box setting, i.e. in a situation where neither an internal description of the system is available, nor of the additional devices used to analyse it. The canonical example of this is in self-testing states, where the maximal violation of the CHSH inequality 22 can be used to certify the fact that a device prepares a state that is, up to local transformations, equivalent to the maximally entangled Bell state 38 . As a result, self-testing is sometimes considered the strongest form of certification of a quantum resource: it maximally characterises the resource in a device-independent setting, directly from observable correlations. Self-testing has been demonstrated for several key quantum resources, including quantum states 23 ; 5 and measurements 17 ; 53 , as well as quantum channels 40 ; 50 and instruments 61 . Here, we extend the self-testing framework to the so-called higher-order quantum operations, also known as quantum supermaps or processes 18 . Quantum supermaps are general operations that map completely positive (CP) maps to CP maps. Prominent examples of quantum supermaps are so-called quantum combs, which can be realized as quantum circuits which apply the input CP maps in a fixed order. Quantum algorithms based on oracles 28 can for instance be described as quantum combs, such as Grover’s algorithm 33 , which can be viewed as a quantum comb operating on M copies of an unknown unitary channel to produce a classical guess. Particular interest has also been sparked by the fact that some supermaps cannot be described as combs, but may combine operations in a dynamically established order or even without any well-defined causal order 43 ; 26 . The archetypal supermap of this kind is the quantum switch 20 , which uses a qubit to control the order in which two parties’ quantum operations are performed. Supermaps have found numerous applications in computation 3 ; 1 , communication 34 , or describing strategies in channel discrimination 19 and quantum metrology 39 ; 12 ; see Ref. 56 for a review. In this contribution, after reviewing the necessary background on self-testing of states, measurements and channels (Sec. II ), we propose a formal definition of self-testing for quantum supermaps. Considering first supermaps acting on quantum channels consisting of single black boxes, we show that they can be identified only up to local quantum combs, or “ embedding combs ” (Sec. III.1 ). However, we argue that network connectivity assumptions make it possible to place several (uncharacterized) separate black boxes within each slot of a supermap, and in particular access the input and output systems of a slot independently. This allows the identification of supermaps with more precision, namely up to local maps at the input and output of each slot (Sec. III.2 ), similar to the injection and extraction maps used in the self-testing of quantum channels 50 . In practice, our method relies on the certification of the reference quantum channel obtained by plugging a swap gate into each slot of the target quantum process. We illustrate the difference between the certifications obtained with different network connectivity assumptions on several examples (Sec. IV ). We show that our framework allows for general self-testing of a variety of quantum processes by providing explicit self-tests for the identity comb, the bit-flip error-correcting comb, the comb describing Grover’s algorithm, and the quantum switch. These provide in particular the first self-test of an algorithmic comb and of a causally indefinite quantum process. We finish by discussing several open questions regarding the extent to which the assumptions of our approach can further be relaxed or simplified, and its generalizability to other supermaps beyond the quantum switch (Sec. V ). II Self-testing quantum operations Generally speaking, self-testing refers to the possibility of identifying the quantum model of different elements of an experimental setup as precisely as possible given only the knowledge of observed correlations and general assumptions on the network structure describing the experiment. Both questions of what it means to identify precisely a physical model and to assume a network structure require some clarification, which is easier to vehicle through concrete examples as we do below. In the following, we also distinguish self-testing from rigidity statements. Specifically, we refer to self-testing as the fact that certain sets of conditions on the experimental statistics obtained in given network structures imply a rigidity statement, i.e. a characterization of part (or all) of the physical devices used in the experiment. II.1 Self-testing states and measurements First, consider the example of self-testing in bipartite Bell scenarios. Here, a common source prepares two physical systems and distributes them to two parties, Alice and Bob. Upon receiving their systems, Alice and Bob each choose a random measurement, labeled with x and y , and perform it on their respective system to obtain an output, labeled a and b , respectively. Upon identically repeating the described procedure many times Alice and Bob estimate the conditional probability distributions – or correlations – P(a,b|x,y) associated to the experiment. In quantum physics these correlations are given by the Born rule P(a,b|x,y)={\rm Tr}\left(\rho\,(A_{a|x}\otimes B_{b|y})\right), (1a) for some, a priori unknown, bipartite state \rho and measurements A_{a|x} , B_{b|y} , referred to as a realization . 1 1 1 Throughout the paper (including in the diagrams) we use the “mixed state picture”, with quantum states represented as density matrices, measurements as Positive Operator-Valued Measures