Gravitational ultra-relativistic freeze-out during general reheating
Mathieu Gross, Stephen E. Henrich, Fotis Koutroulis · 2026
Read Gravitational ultra-relativistic freeze-out during general reheating by Mathieu Gross, Stephen E. Henrich, Fotis Koutroulis (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-25033.txt.
Introduction
Mathieu Gross, Stephen Henrich, and Fotis Koutroulis generalise ultrarelativistic freeze out, a dark matter mechanism, to general reheating histories. Standard WIMP dark matter only dilutes after it freezes out. Ultrarelativistic freeze out is stranger: after the freeze out, the particles can pass through freeze in phases, driven by how the temperature evolves as the universe reheats. The authors rewrite it for a temperature profile, making the ultraviolet and infrared regimes explicit.
A scenario follows. Gravitational particle production at the start of reheating seeds an early radiation bath. That bath reshapes the freeze out parameter space, an effect named GUFO. For a quadratic interaction, matter like reheating accommodates dark matter masses up to ten million GeV, since thermalisation demands become less stringent. Radiation like reheating also stays compatible with the mechanism. The early universe's thermal history decides which masses and couplings can yield the observed dark matter.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mathieu Gross, Stephen E. Henrich, Fotis Koutroulis |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 71 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.25033
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Gravitational ultra-relativistic freeze-out during general reheating Mathieu Gross, Stephen E. Henrich, Fotis Koutroulis Abstract We investigate ultrarelativistic freeze-out (UFO) in the context of generic reheating scenarios. While the standard WIMP dark matter paradigm has been extensively studied, UFO has so far only been analyzed within the specific reheating channel ϕ → f f ¯ \phi\rightarrow f\bar{f} . Unlike in the standard WIMP mechanism, where dark matter can only be diluted after freeze-out at T FO ∼ m χ / 𝒪 ( 10 ) T_{\mathrm{FO}}\sim m_{\chi}/\mathcal{O}(10) , UFO dark matter can undergo freeze-in like phases following the initial freeze-out, driven by the non-trivial temperature evolution. The exact temperature evolution then needs to be accounted for, as a change in the temperature scaling can modify the IR/UV nature of UFO, impacting the relic abundance. We first generalize UFO to an arbitrary temperature profile T ∼ a − ξ T\sim a^{-\xi} , making explicit the UV and IR regimes for a thermally averaged cross section ⟨ σ v ⟩ ∼ T n / Λ n + 2 \langle\sigma v\rangle\sim T^{n}/\Lambda^{n+2} . Then, as a concrete example, we consider the minimal scenario in which gravitational particle production at the onset of reheating sources an initial radiation abundance, and show that this early hot bath changes the UFO parameter space. We refer to this effect as GUFO. Specializing to n = 2 n=2 , we find that matter-like reheating ( V ∼ ϕ 2 V\sim\phi^{2} ) accommodates dark matter masses up to 10 7 GeV 10^{7}\penalty\ \mathrm{GeV} for Λ ≲ 10 9 GeV \Lambda\lesssim 10^{9}\penalty\ \mathrm{GeV} as thermalization becomes less stringent, while radiation-like reheating ( V ∼ ϕ 4 V\sim\phi^{4} ) is compatible with GUFO across all reheating channels only if gravitational processes are taken into account. Dark matter is one of the cornerstones of modern cosmology, as it is required to explain several observables, such as structure formation and the cosmic microwave background. The main effort now concerns both its nature, either as a particle 18 ; 6 ; 11 or wave-like condensation within galactic scales 27 or as primordial black holes 16 , and its proper production mechanism. From a particle physics perspective, significant theoretical and experimental efforts in recent years have been devoted to understand and constrain possible production scenarios. The main paradigms are then separated depending on the strength of the interaction. For strongly coupled scenarios, the particle is believed to reach thermal equilibrium in the early universe, leading to the standard WIMP scenario 6 . For feebly interacting models (small couplings and/or large mediators), the dark matter remains out-of-equilibrium and its abundance gradually accumulates over time to reach the measured relic abundance today \Omega_{\chi}h^{2}\simeq 0.12 11 ; 3 . This mechanism is called freeze-in, and the associated particles are commonly called FIMPs. These paradigms have driven experimental searches for many years and continue to do so today 2 ; 5 ; 4 ; 1 ; 50 ; 31 . However, the lack of experimental evidence now motivates a revisit and extension of these scenarios to other cosmological contexts such as pure gravitational interaction 20 ; 19 ; 9 ; 44 ; 40 ; 45 ; 46 ; 25 ; 52 or reheating-era production 12 ; 10 ; 34 ; 36 ; 37 ; 21 ; 26 ; 8 ; 35 . In the latter context a new way to produce dark matter through ultra relativistic freeze-out (UFO) was noticed 34 ; 36 ; 37 . This scenario, first introduced with neutrinos, is normally forbidden in radiation domination due to structure formation constraints. During reheating, however, it becomes allowed as the continuous entropy injection dilutes and cools the otherwise warm and overproduced dark matter. In this work, we generalize the UFO mechanism to generic reheating scenarios and we investigate the effects of gravitationally produced radiation. In addition to evading warmness constraints, UFO during reheating exhibits several other attractive features. First, the fact that UFO dark matter equilibrates erases any initial abundance that may have been produced gravitationally during inflation or immediately after. This relaxes the constraints on the reheating temperature ( T_{\rm{RH}} ) that would otherwise apply to freeze-in dark matter. Second, after (ultra)relativistic decoupling but prior to the completion of reheating, there may be significant out-of-equilibrium freeze-in like production as well as entropy dilution, which together open a vast parameter space in ( m_{\rm DM},T_{\rm RH},\Lambda ), with \Lambda parametrically related to the mass of a heavy mediator in the UV theory, compared to conventional freeze-in and freeze-out. Third, because UFO dark matter is allowed to thermalize, this mechanism is generally compatible with stronger interactions (lower \Lambda in effective field theory) compared to standard freeze-in, which renders UFO more accessible to detection efforts than FIMPs 38 . Finally, while UFO has the advantage of equilibrating, similar to WIMPs, it also exhibits UV or IR sensitivity depending on the specifics of the interaction and the cosmological history. This endows UFO with rich phenomenology in a similar manner to UV and IR freeze-in. We start by considering a generic beyond the Standard Model (BSM) interaction between dark matter particles \chi and Standard Model particles involving the exchange of a heavy mediator of mass M . We typically have in mind 2\rightarrow 2 annihilations between Standard Model fermions (or the Higgs) and dark matter. In the relativistic regime where T\gg m_{\chi},m_{f} , the thermally averaged cross section can be parametrized as \langle\sigma v\rangle\sim\frac{g^{4}\mu^{2-n}T^{n}}{(T^{2}+M^{2})^{2}} (1) where \mu is a dimensionful coupling, g is the vertex coupling and T is the temperature of the thermal bath. This cross section will then change its temperature-dependence based upon whether the temperature is higher or lower than the mediator mass. In each case, the expression reduces to \langle\sigma v\rangle\sim T^{n}/\Lambda^{n+2} where the n parameter will change between the high ( n_{h} ) and low ( n_{l} ) energy regimes, which are linked by the relation n_{l}=n_{h}+4 . This change of behavior will then allow a relativistic candidate to enter thermal equilibrium while n=n_{h} and later on to exit equilibrium when n=n_{l} . We will now put this subtlety aside and refer to the low energy index as n . We note that the parametrization in Eq. ( 1 ) breaks down when the Standard Model bath temperature drops to approximately max( m_{\chi},m_{f} ). At these low temperatures, there will typically be terms in the thermally averaged cross section proportional to powers of m_{\chi} and m_{f} , such that the relativistic parametrization above is no longer appropriate. This is important when determining the boundary between relativistic and non-relativistic freeze-out, which has been explored in detail in 37 ; 38 . For this paper, we focus on dark matter decoupling and production in the relativistic regime. In effective field theory, there is a straightforward relationship between the operator dimension and n . Specifically, for an effective d -dimensional operator \mathcal{O}_{d} with \mathcal{L}_{\rm eff}\supset\frac{\mathcal{O}_{d}}{\Lambda^{d-4}} , the thermally averaged cross section in the relativistic regime scales as \langle\sigma v\rangle\propto\frac{T^{2d-10}}{\Lambda^{2d-8}} . This implies that n=2d-10 . For instance, an effective 4-Fermi interaction with operator dimension 6 corresponds to n=2 . For standard freeze-in during radiation domination, UV vs. IR-dominated production is distinguished by a critical value of n_{c}=-1