Fermion mass relations in one-parameter modular models
Salvador Centelles Chuliá, Xueqi Li, Xiang-Gan Liu, Omar Medina, J. T. Penedo · 2026
Read Fermion mass relations in one-parameter modular models by Salvador Centelles Chuliá, Xueqi Li, Xiang-Gan Liu, Omar Medina, J. T. Penedo (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-25027.txt.
Introduction
Salvador Centelles and four colleagues push modular flavour symmetry to its limit: models where a number fixes every fermion mass matrix. They replace the arbitrary Yukawa couplings with modular forms controlled by a complex modulus. In the one parameter version, each mass matrix is set by a single modular invariant contraction. The team develops a systematic way to build such models. The requirement proves highly constraining: only certain fermion hierarchies can arise.
In a realisation, the charged lepton and down quark sectors share the modulus. Exact relations link the masses at the flavour scale: strange, down, and bottom quark masses obey one relation, electron, muon, and tau masses another. Renormalisation group running would normally spoil such relations by low energies. With selective supersymmetric threshold effects included, the team shows they survive into agreement with data. The result is a proof of principle for a route into the flavour puzzle.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Salvador Centelles Chuliá, Xueqi Li, Xiang-Gan Liu, Omar Medina, J. T. Penedo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC0 |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.25027
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Fermion mass relations in one-parameter modular models Salvador Centelles Chuliá, Xueqi Li, Xiang-Gan Liu, Omar Medina, J. T. Penedo Abstract Modular flavour symmetries provide a possible organizing principle for the Standard Model Yukawa sector, by replacing generic couplings with a potentially small number of modular forms controlled by a single complex modulus. We study the extreme limit of this idea: one-parameter modular models, in which each charged-fermion mass matrix is fixed by a single modular invariant contraction. We develop a systematic method to construct such models, showing that the one-parameter modular model requirement is already highly constraining at the level of possible fermion hierarchies. In a concrete realization, the charged-lepton and down-quark sectors are controlled by the common modulus, leading to exact mass relations at the flavour scale, m s 5 = 2 2 m d 3 m b 2 , m μ 3 = 2 m e m τ 2 , m s 2 m τ = 2 m e m b 2 . m_{s}^{5}=2\sqrt{2}\,m_{d}^{3}m_{b}^{2},\qquad m_{\mu}^{3}=\sqrt{2}\,m_{e}m_{\tau}^{2},\qquad m_{s}^{2}m_{\tau}=\sqrt{2}\,m_{e}m_{b}^{2}. We show that, once renormalization-group evolution and selective supersymmetric threshold effects are included, these high-scale relations can be made compatible with low-energy charged-fermion data. Our results provide a working proof of principle for one-parameter modular models and point towards a possible route to the flavour puzzle through highly constrained constructions. I Introduction The Standard Model (SM) allows for an extraordinarily economical description of fundamental interactions, based on the gauge symmetry principle. However, this economy is lost in its Yukawa sector, which encodes fermion masses, mixing and CP violation (CPV), and where most of the theory’s free parameters reside. Explaining the peculiarities of the observed flavour structures, namely the marked mass hierarchies and contrasting mixing patterns (i.e. large for leptons and small for quarks), constitutes the flavour puzzle and remains an open challenge in theoretical particle physics. An organizing principle in the flavour sector is desired: it would work orthogonally to the gauge principle, unifying different particle generations into multiplets. Non-Abelian flavour (or horizontal) symmetries provide such a framework, postulating the invariance of the action under the transformations of a symmetry group G_{f} , suitably broken by the vacuum expectation values of scalar fields, known as flavons (see e.g. Altarelli:2010gt ; Ishimori:2010au ; King:2014nza ; Petcov:2017ggy ; Feruglio:2019ybq ; Ding:2024ozt for reviews). The modular invariance generalization of the traditional flavour approach Feruglio:2017spp (see Kobayashi:2023zzc ; Ding:2023htn for reviews) focuses instead on a minimal symmetry-breaking sector, described by a single complex field : the modulus \tau , with \im\tau>0 . Within this string-inspired, supersymmetric framework, modular forms Y(\tau) play the role of Yukawa couplings which are significantly constrained. In particular, the holomorphicity of the superpotential restricts the space of available forms, making this setup potentially very predictive. 1 1 1 We work with the minimal modular-invariant Kähler potential. As usual in modular flavour models, non-minimal Kähler corrections are allowed by the symmetry and may reduce predictivity by introducing additional parameters Chen:2019ewa . We regard the minimal choice as part of the definition of the framework. Moreover, model-independent mass relations may emerge from the symmetry structure of the flavour group and of the modular forms in modular-invariant models containing a small number of parameters, see e.g. Chen:2023mwt . Taken to the extreme, one could in principle build a modular model where each Yukawa matrix results from a single invariant contraction . Within such an one-parameter modular model, each fermion mass matrix is thus fully determined by \tau and an overall coefficient. In this work, we investigate the conditions under which one-parameter modular models may be viable. A first step towards building an one-parameter modular model involves accounting for the hierarchical fermion spectrum, which already places significant constraints on the possible values of the modulus vacuum expectation value. Note that a generic vacuum expectation value of \tau fully breaks the non-linearly realized modular invariance. Instead, at the special values \tau_{\text{sym}}=i,\,\omega=e^{2\pi i/3},\,i\infty some residual \mathbb{Z}_{n} ( n\geq 2 ) symmetry is preserved and can be exploited. Indeed, in the vicinity of these fixed points, the residual symmetry is slightly broken (but linearly realized) and Yukawa couplings can be expanded as power series in \epsilon\sim|\tau-\tau_{\text{sym}}| , providing a natural origin of the fermion mass hierarchies Feruglio:2021dte ; Novichkov:2021evw . This mechanism, which has recently Carducci:2026shs been dubbed modular proximity-induced hierarchies , has been used to derive “golden”-type mass relations in models relying on a limited number of parameters in Ref. Chen:2023mwt . Finally, we stress that the number of possible one-parameter modular models one can construct may be limited, due to the structure of the modular group \mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb{Z}) . As a result, obtaining the observed charged-fermion mass hierarchies from an one-parameter modular model is highly non-trivial. This paper is organized as follows. In Section II we introduce the modular-invariant framework and the conditions under which a single invariant contraction gives rise to an one-parameter modular model Yukawa sector with suitable mass hierarchies. In Section III we use these criteria to search for possible one-parameter modular models. This search first singles out \Delta(96) and the related group \Delta(384) , where four inequivalent hierarchy patterns H 2 – H 5 are obtained. Two of these hierarchies, H 2 and H 5 , are naturally close to the observed charged-lepton and down-quark spectra. Assigning them to the corresponding sectors in an explicit double one-parameter modular model then fixes the high-scale mass relations studied in the rest of the paper. In Section IV we confront these relations with low-energy data, through renormalization-group running and finite threshold corrections. In Section V we discuss hints on how this framework may provide a solution of the quark flavour puzzle and we conclude in Section VI . II Framework We consider a simple setup in flavour modular symmetry. We work in global \mathcal{N}=1 supersymmetry, with matter chiral superfields \psi^{i} acquiring their masses from the Yukawa interactions in the superpotential, characterized by cubic terms of the type \mathcal{W}\,\supset\,Y_{ijk}(\tau)\,\psi_{i}\psi_{j}\psi_{k}\,, (1) where the Y_{ijk} are the components of a vector-valued modular form (or modular form multiplet). These are holomorphic functions that transform under the modular group \mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb{Z}) as Y^{(k_{Y})}(\tau)\,\,\xmapsto{\gamma}\,\,Y^{(k_{Y})}(\gamma\tau)\,=\,(c\,\tau+d)^{k_{Y}}\rho(\gamma)\,Y^{(k_{Y})}(\tau)\,,\qquad\text{with }\gamma=\begin{pmatrix}a&b\\ c&d\end{pmatrix}\in\mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb{Z})\,, (2) where \rho is a representation of \mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb{Z}) , k_{Y} is known as the weight of the modular form, and \tau is the modulus, which transforms as \tau\,\,\xmapsto{\gamma}\,\,\gamma\tau\,=\,\frac{a\,\tau+b}{c\,\tau+d}\,. (3) Recall that \mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb{Z}) is generated by the matrices S=\left(\begin{smallmatrix}0&1\\ -1&0\end{smallmatrix}\right) and T=\left(\begin{smallmatrix}1&1\\ 0&1\end{smallmatrix}\right) . We focus on the case where the representation \rho has finite image; in such a case, the vector-valued modular forms are those of the finite modular group \mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb{Z})/\ker\rho . A matter field transforms under the modular group as \psi\,\,\xmapsto{\gamma}\,\,(c\,\tau+d)^{-k_{\psi}}\rho_{\psi}(\gamma)\,\psi\,, (4) where k_{\psi} is the modular weight of the matter field \psi and \rho_{\psi} is a (unitary) representation of the finite modular group. In global supersymmetry, the superpotential is invariant under modular transformations. Then, together with eq. 2 , one finds that, in each superpotential term, the sum of the matter field modular weights must equal the weight of the modular form, k_{Y}=k_{\psi_{i}}+k_{\psi_{j}}+k_{\psi_{k}} . For relatively low weights, there are only a few, or even a single, modular form(s) available, strongly constraining flavour structures and observables. In building modular-invariant flavour models, we consider a minimal form for the