TRACER: Training-Free Closed-Loop Structured Inference for Traffic Accident Reconstruction
Yanchen Guan, Chengyue Wang, Bin Rao, Haicheng Liao, State Key Laboratory of Internet of Things for Smart City · 2026
Read TRACER: Training-Free Closed-Loop Structured Inference for Traffic Accident Reconstruction by Yanchen Guan, Chengyue Wang, Bin Rao, Haicheng Liao, State Key Laboratory of Internet of Things for Smart City (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-25002.txt.
Introduction
Yanchen Guan, Chengyue Wang, Bin Rao, and Haicheng Liao present TRACER, a training free system for reconstructing traffic accidents from evidence. Reconstruction is a forensic inverse problem: recover the motion from accounts, vehicle details, road geometry, sketches, and partial collision cues. Learning based rivals mostly optimise for semantic plausibility or visual realism. TRACER instead treats the task as closed loop structured inference. It builds event anchored motion hypotheses, then refines them under geometric, kinematic, and interaction constraints.
Case memory guides the search, and consistency driven diagnosis flags where a hypothesis disagrees with the record. Corrections stay stepwise and interpretable, like a human expert's. On real world accident data, TRACER improves geometric fidelity, speed consistency, and collision accuracy across both data driven and physics based methods. For forensic use, an answer must not only look right but measure right against the physical record of a crash.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yanchen Guan, Chengyue Wang, Bin Rao, Haicheng Liao, State Key Laboratory of Internet of Things for Smart City |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.25002
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
TRACER: Training-Free Closed-Loop Structured Inference for Traffic Accident Reconstruction Yanchen Guan, Chengyue Wang, Bin Rao, Haicheng Liao, State Key Laboratory of Internet of Things for Smart City Abstract Traffic accident reconstruction is a forensic inverse problem that requires recovering physically consistent motion from sparse and heterogeneous evidence. Existing learning-based approaches predominantly optimize for semantic plausibility or visual realism, rather than quantitative agreement with measurable geometry and dynamics. Here, we present TRACER, a training-free framework that formulates reconstruction as a closed-loop structured inference process. Instead of directly generating dense trajectories, our framework constructs and iteratively refines event-anchored motion hypotheses under geometric, kinematic, and interaction constraints, guided by structured case memory and consistency-driven diagnosis. This design enables incremental, interpretable corrections when evidence is insufficient, making the accident reconstruction process more aligned with the workflow of human experts. Experiments on real-world accident data show that TRACER achieves improved geometric fidelity, velocity consistency, and collision accuracy over both data-driven and physics-based baselines. 1 Introduction Accident reconstruction aims to recover the pre-impact motion process that led to an observed crash from partial post-hoc evidence davis2003bayesian . This evidence is often sparse, noisy, and heterogeneous, including textual narratives, vehicle attributes, road geometry, scene sketches, and partial collision cues wach2016calculation . The task therefore requires more than generating plausible trajectories: the recovered motion must remain consistent with the accident description, road topology, vehicle kinematics, multi-agent interaction, and final impact configuration gao2020vectornet . This setting poses a structured inverse inference problem: several motion histories may explain the same report, especially when the evidence only specifies high-level actions such as turning, braking, yielding, stopping, or running a red light arora2021survey . Under such ambiguity, once the generated dense trajectory becomes inconsistent, the source of the error is difficult to localize, making it unclear which stage of the motion evolution process is responsible for the failure. Consequently, direct dense trajectory generation is not well suited for interpretable diagnosis and localized refinement ivanovic2021mats . In contrast, accident reasoning is naturally organized around event-level stages, including upstream approach, maneuver onset, conflict entry, evasive response, and final collision approach menzel2018scenarios . These stages provide a compact interface between sparse evidence and metric trajectory recovery. Existing accident reconstruction approaches have used accident reports, scene layouts, or simulators to synthesize accident-related trajectories and visualizations guo2024sovar ; li2025avd2 . However, many reconstructed results remain vulnerable to structured inconsistencies. A trajectory may match the narrative but violate lane topology, reach the accident point while implying an unrealistic speed profile, or approach the collision from a direction incompatible with the reported impact side. These failure modes indicate that the central challenge of accident reconstruction is not merely generating a seemingly plausible trajectory, but rather constructing a structured motion hypothesis that remains diagnosable, localizable, and repairable under incomplete evidence. We propose TRACER, a closed-loop framework for physically constrained inverse motion reconstruction. TRACER represents each vehicle’s pre-impact motion as an event-anchored hypothesis composed of sparse control points, segment relations, speed stages, and collision-approach constraints. A structured case memory provides weak priors over route extent, maneuver style, speed tendency, and approach configuration. Large language models are integrated as structured reasoning components across the inference loop: they propose event-level hypotheses, assess semantic and action-level consistency, and generate localized refinements conditioned on checker diagnostics. Deterministic modules handle dense trajectory realization, numerical consistency checking, and edit acceptance, keeping the final reconstruction auditable and physically constrained. Our contributions are threefold. First, we introduce an event-anchored motion representation that aligns with the granularity of accident evidence and supports interpretable diagnosis and localized repair. Second, we develop a closed-loop structured consistency minimization framework that couples LLM-assisted planning, hybrid checking, LLM-guided refinement, and deterministic dense realization. Third, we incorporate structured case memory as a weak prior mechanism that regularizes underdetermined reconstruction and provides pattern references. Experiments on real-world accident reconstruction data show that TRACER improves geometric accuracy, speed consistency, and collision-level fidelity over representative trajectory-generation baselines. 2 Related Work Traffic accident reconstruction is a forensic inverse problem that recovers the causal and kinematic process of a crash from heterogeneous evidence, including measurements, sketches, vehicle damage, and witness or driver statements zheng2020determinants ; struble2020automotive ; fernandes2018application ; ryan2024accident . Conventional reconstruction relies on trained investigators to integrate physical evidence into structured reports for legal, engineering, and safety analyses rivers2010technical ; rivers2006evidence . Although evidentially rigorous, this process requires substantial expertise, specialized equipment, and prolonged on-site operations carper2000forensic ; raviv2017analyzing ; faizan2021forensic ; smith1957physical , limiting its scalability. Recent learning-based methods seek to automate reconstruction by using accident reports as semantic inputs chen2025transforming ; jiao2018virtual ; li2024steering . Existing approaches include language-conditioned simulation, such as SoVAR guo2024sovar ; text-conditioned visual generation, such as AVD2 li2025avd2 ; and LLM-assisted simulation pipelines, such as AccidentSim zhang2025accidentsim . These methods improve semantic controllability or visual plausibility, but often leave key physical states, geometric consistency, and quantitative trajectory fidelity insufficiently constrained. Guan et al. guan2026learningphysicallygroundedtraffic move toward evidence-grounded reconstruction by coupling textual cues with scene geometry and motion constraints, yet existing methods still largely rely on one-shot generation without a structured intermediate representation that can be validated and revised. This limitation is critical under sparse, noisy, and heterogeneous evidence, where multiple motion histories may appear plausible. Human experts typically resolve such ambiguity through iterative hypothesis construction and refinement, reconciling semantic, geometric, and physical constraints. Motivated by this process, we formulate accident reconstruction as structured closed-loop inference with explicit intermediate hypotheses, retrieval-based priors, and consistency-guided refinement. 3 Methodology Given an accident case, our goal is to recover a dense multi-vehicle pre-impact motion history that is consistent with the available semantic, geometric, and collision evidence. We denote the input evidence as X=\{x^{\mathrm{text}},x^{\mathrm{veh}},x^{\mathrm{road}},p^{\star},q^{\star},c^{\star},w\}, (1) where x^{\mathrm{text}} is the accident summary, x^{\mathrm{veh}} contains vehicle-level attributes such as travel direction, pre-event movement, attempted avoidance maneuver, and speed limit, x^{\mathrm{road}} denotes road and lane geometry, p^{\star} is the accident point, q^{\star} is an impact-side cue, c^{\star} is the collision pair when available, and w denotes weak scene priors. The output is a dense pre-impact trajectory set \hat{T}=\{\hat{\mathbf{s}}_{v}(t_{n})\}_{v=1}^{V},\qquad\hat{\mathbf{s}}_{v}(t_{n})=[\hat{x}_{v}(t_{n}),\hat{y}_{v}(t_{n}),\hat{u}_{v}(t_{n})], (2) where V is the number of involved vehicles and t_{n} indexes the pre-impact time steps. Figure 1 illustrates the overall framework. TRACER reconstructs \hat{T} through a structured hypothesis. H=\{H_{v}\}_{v=1}^{V} (3) denote an event-level trajectory hypothesis, where each H_{v} contains sparse control points, segment relations, and speed-temporal variables. The method seeks a hypothesis that minimizes a structured consistency energy: \displaystyle\mathcal{E}(H;X,M)= \displaystyle\lambda_{\mathrm{sem}}\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{sem}}+\lambda_{\mathrm{act}}\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{act}}+\lambda_{\mathrm{geo}}\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{geo}}+\lambda_{\mathrm{spd}}\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{spd}}+\lambda_{\mathrm{kin}}\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{kin}}+\lambda_{\mathrm{col}}\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{col}}, (4) where M=M(X) denotes retrieved case memory. The terms respectively measure consistency with the accident description, action sequence, road geometry, path–speed relation, vehicle kinematics, and collision configuration. Since this objective involves discrete semantic judgments, geometric constraints, and collision-specific reasoning, TRACER approximates its minimization through a closed-loop constrained inference process: X\rightarrow M(X)\rightarrow H^{(0)}\rightarrow C^{(0)}\rightarrow H^{(1)}\rightarrow\cdots\rightarrow\hat{T}, (5) where the planner proposes an initial event-level hypothesis, the checker diagnoses violations of the consistency energy, the refiner reduces the diagnosed inconsistencies, and the realizer converts the refined hypothesis into dense trajectories. Figure 1: Overview of TRACER. Our framework reconstructs pre-impact trajectories through closed-loop constrained inference. Structured memory provides weak priors, the planner generates an event-anchored hypothesis, the checker diagnoses semantic, action-level, geometric, kinematic, and collision inconsistencies, and the refiner repairs the hypothesis with the criticism from checker. 3.1 Structured Case Memory Sparse accident evidence often leaves