Bounds for Standard Errors in Combined Data

Jooyoung Cha, Yuya Sasaki, Nelson Matthew P. Tan · 2026

Read Bounds for Standard Errors in Combined Data by Jooyoung Cha, Yuya Sasaki, Nelson Matthew P. Tan (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-24867.txt.

Introduction

Jooyoung Cha, Yuya Sasaki, and Nelson Matthew P. Tan bound the standard errors of estimates built by combining data from several samples. Researchers often merge moments from different, possibly interdependent sources, like surveys and administrative records. The uncertainty of the combined estimates depends on correlations across samples, which may be unknown. Their methods construct lower bounds on the standard errors anyway.

Sharp explicit bounds come from geometric inequalities when nothing is known about cross sample correlation. For settings with partial information, the authors develop sharp bounds that stay computable. Those bounds are obtained by solving a simple semidefinite program. Three empirical cases show the method at work. Two are macroeconomic: menu cost models and heterogeneous agent New Keynesian models. The third is a two sample instrumental variable study in microeconomics. The bounds tell researchers the best precision their combined data could possibly support.

Catalog record

CREATORJooyoung Cha, Yuya Sasaki, Nelson Matthew P. Tan
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE88 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.24867

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Bounds for Standard Errors in Combined Data Thanks: We thank Isaiah Andrews, Pol Antrás, Michal Kolesár, Mikkel Plagborg-Møller, Elie Tamer, and participants of the 2023 New York Camp Econometrics, the 2025 Canadian Econometric Study Group, and the Princeton Econometrics Workshop for their valuable comments. This work is based on merging “Bounds for Standard Errors from Interdependent Data” by Jooyoung Cha and Yuya Sasaki with “Top to Bottom: Best-case Standard Errors for Calibrated Model Parameters” by Nelson Matthew P. Tan. All remaining errors are our own. Yuya Sasaki gratefully acknowledges generous funding from Brian and Charlotte Grove. Jooyoung Cha, Yuya Sasaki, Nelson Matthew P. Tan Abstract We propose methods for constructing lower bounds on the standard errors of parameters estimated from moment conditions obtained across different samples. Sharp explicit bounds are derived by exploiting geometric inequalities when no information about correlations across samples is available. Furthermore, we develop computationally tractable sharp bounds for more general settings with no or partial correlation information, which can be obtained by solving a simple semidefinite program. Finally, we illustrate the practical usefulness of our method through three empirical cases: two macroeconomics examples involving menu cost and Heterogeneous Agent New-Keynesian models; and a two sample instrumental variable microeconomic study. Keywords: data combination, standard error, upper and lower bounds. JEL Code: C10 1 Introduction Researchers frequently combine empirical moments from multiple, and potentially interdependent, data sources. Examples include integrating survey data with administrative records, combining cross-sectional data with time-series data, and using time-series observations recorded at different frequencies. In applications such as meta-analysis and calibration, the focus is often placed more on parameter estimation than on statistical inference. This emphasis may reflect the fact that conventional inference methods are typically infeasible, because the covariances of empirical moments across samples are often unknown, rendering standard errors for the parameter of interest impossible to compute. When a covariance is not directly observable, it can still be bounded using marginal variances. Recent work by 10 derives a sharp upper bound on the covariance from marginal variances via the Cauchy–Schwarz inequality, and 28 extends 10 along several dimensions. We complement this literature by characterizing the full range of standard errors that are feasible when only marginal variances are known. In addition to the sharp worst-case standard error, we derive the sharp best-case standard error and show that it is governed by a geometric cancellation condition. The resulting interval describes exactly how much uncertainty about the standard error is induced by the absence of covariance information. The diagonal-only case provides the least-informative benchmark. The upper bound corresponds to maximal alignment of the sampling errors across empirical moments. The lower bound corresponds to maximal cancellation. This lower bound is often zero, but this should not be interpreted as a defect of the bound. Rather, it reveals when the unknown covariance structure can, in principle, offset the marginal sampling uncertainty in the combined estimator. Our characterization makes this possibility precise. With two moments, exact cancellation requires a knife-edge balance between the two components. With three or more moments, the condition has a geometric interpretation: the marginal contributions must be capable of closing into a polygon. Thus, the sharp lower bound describes the covariance configurations under which the combined estimator can have a very small standard error despite nontrivial uncertainty in its individual components. The diagonal-only bounds are useful not because researchers should necessarily base inference on either extreme, but because they describe the full range of standard errors consistent with the available information. Figure 1 outlines how applied researchers can use the bounds we derive and the existing knowledge of the data as a diagnostic for adjusting their empirical design. If both the lower and upper bounds are large, the data are uninformative for the parameter of interest regardless of the unknown covariance structure. If the bounds are far apart, the missing covariance information is consequential: different admissible covariance structures lead to substantively different inferential conclusions. In that case, the bounds may help decide whether it is worth collecting, estimating, or justifying additional information about the covariance structure. In many combined-data applications, researchers may know more than the marginal variances. The design of the data combination may imply that some components are estimated from independent samples, that two samples partially overlap, that dependence is confined within blocks, or that some pairwise correlations have known signs or plausible magnitude restrictions. We show how such information sharpens the standard error bounds. Information that rules out strong negative effective dependence raises the lower bound by limiting cancellation. Information that rules out strong positive effective dependence lowers the upper bound by limiting alignment. Exact independence, block independence, bounded sample overlap, and sign restrictions therefore have transparent effects on the range of feasible standard errors. Do I know the full correlation structure of my data? Use conventional GMM or minimum-distance inference. Compute lower and upper bounds on standard errors. What do the standard-error bounds imply? Bounds are close, i.e. both small or large. Additional knowledge over unknown covariances likely uninformative. Bounds are very different: lower bound \approx 0 , upper bound \gg|\text{point estimate}| . Do I know the correlations among some moments? Use the SDP procedure (Section 5 ). After the SDP procedure, is the lower bound still \approx 0 and the upper bound still large? Partial-information design is informative. Additional correlation information may be worthwhile. Estimate the joint correlation structure of the data. Impose additional assumptions or structure on moment correlations. Yes No Yes No No Yes Figure 1: Decision tree for choosing an empirical strategy under partial information about the correlation structure. We develop two complementary approaches. First, we provide analytic characterizations for several empirically relevant forms of covariance information. For example, when moments can be partitioned into independent blocks, the bounds decompose block by block. When two components are estimated from partially overlapping samples, the overlap structure can place direct limits on the magnitude of their correlation. These cases show how features of the data-combination design translate into sharper inference. Second, for more general forms of partial covariance information, we formulate the problem as a semidefinite program (SDP). This computational approach allows researchers to incorporate arbitrary linear or convex restrictions on the unknown covariance matrix and obtain the corresponding standard-error bounds using standard numerical solvers. Our framework applies to a wide range of empirical settings. In two-sample instrumental variables, conventional inference often relies on an independence assumption between the sample used to estimate the first stage and the sample used to estimate the reduced form. Our approach nests that assumption but also allows researchers to examine weaker alternatives, such as bounded cross-sample dependence. Similar issues arise in empirical macroeconomics, where constructed or generated shock series are often estimated in one sample and then used in downstream analyses. Classical generated-regressor arguments, such as those associated with 25 , justify standard inference when the relevant covariance structure is negligible or consistently estimable. But when a constructed shock is made externally and then used in a different estimating sample, the relevant joint covariance may not be directly recoverable. Moreover, calibration, the most common setting in macroeconomics applicable to our framework ( 17 ; 21 ; 23 ; 20 ; 15 ; 4 ; 14 ) , faces an analogous

Read the complete text