Difference-Making without Making a Difference Preprint
Sander Beckers · 2026
Read Difference-Making without Making a Difference Preprint by Sander Beckers (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-24832.txt.
Introduction
Sander Beckers, a philosopher of causation, argues that a prominent new account of actual causation collapses distinctions its own authors rely on. Andreas and Günther have published seven definitions of actual causation across seven papers. They sort those definitions into three rival types: factual difference making, counterfactual difference making, and regularity based accounts. Their newest definition is presented as the factual kind. It is also offered as superior to rival accounts.
Beckers shows the newest definition in fact instantiates all three types at once. The threefold classification, he argues, marks distinctions without a difference. He then compares the new account directly with the authors' six earlier ones. Several crucial examples drive the comparison. On his reading, the results falsify both selling points claimed for the new account. Worse, the analysis undermines all seven accounts together. The preprint is a critique, not a new definition of its own.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sander Beckers |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 28 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.24832
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Difference-Making without Making a Difference Preprint Sander Beckers Abstract Over a series of seven papers, Andreas & Günther have introduced seven definitions of actual causation and have classified them as belonging to three different, competing, types of accounts: factual difference-making , counterfactual difference-making , and regularity-based . I show that their most recent – factual difference-making – definition instantiates all three types, thereby proving that these are distinctions without a difference. I further compare their novel account to the other six accounts on several crucial examples, revealing that this undermines all seven of their accounts. 1 Introduction 8 have recently proposed an account of actual causation, aka token causation, and compare it favorably to the accounts of several other authors by making two claims: first, it offers better verdicts on examples, and second, it replaces a muddled appeal to counterfactual difference-making with a consistent and simple appeal to factual difference-making . Yet Andreas & Günther’s (AG from now on) comparison to the literature contains an important oversight: AG fail to compare their novel account to the other six accounts of causation that they have themselves previously proposed ( AG1-7 from now on, where AG7 is the current account). I show that comparing the current account to these earlier accounts results in falsifying both of AG’s claims, and that it undermines all seven of their accounts. Their six earlier accounts engage with a similar set of examples as the current one, and several of them are likewise motivated explicitly by invoking an appeal to some form of difference-making. So the question presents itself: does this novel difference-making account make a difference in comparison to their existing accounts? I answer this in the negative by proving that the current account ( AG7 ) is equivalent to one of their most recent accounts ( AG5 ) (which they acknowledge is itself almost identical to another recent account of theirs ( AG6 )). Furthermore, I prove that there exists an equivalent formulation of their account as a counterfactual difference-making account, thereby revealing the distinction between factual and counterfactual difference-making to be one without a difference. AG present AG5 and AG6 as regularity-based accounts, which they claim also stand in contrast to counterfactual difference-making accounts. As a consequence of the above equivalence, the distinction between regularity and counterfactual difference-making accounts is likewise revealed as one without a difference. I then compare the verdicts on examples given by their current account to the verdicts on these and similar examples that they have defended throughout their other six accounts, and show that they are faced with an unappealing dilemma: either they stick with their earlier view ( AG1 , AG2 , AG4 ) that the examples Simple Switch and Early Preemption are to be distinguished solely on the basis of their structural properties, in which case all of their later accounts offer the wrong verdict – by AG’s own light – on several variants of the switch example that they discuss, or they stick with their more recent view ( AG5 , AG6 , AG7 ) that the distinction between these examples is due to the (non-structural) deviancy condition, in which case all of their accounts offer the wrong verdict on cases of Early Preemption for which the backup-process is not deviant. Additionally, choosing the second horn undermines one of the most frequent and important criticisms that AG offer of other accounts, namely that those accounts fail to structurally distinguish between Simple Switch and Early Preemption . Concretely, I will use the following labels to refer to the seven definitions of actual causation proposed so far by AG: • AG1 : 2 • AG2 : 4 • AG3 : 3 • AG4 : 5 • AG5 : 7 • AG6 : 6 • AG7 : 8 2 Equivalence of AG7 and AG5 In ( 8 ) AG define a causal model <M,V> as consisting of a set M of structural equations of the form X=\varphi for some binary variable X and propositional formula \varphi , and a consistent set of literals V . (A literal is either a variable ( X ) – representing truth – or the negation of a variable ( \lnot X ) – representing falsehood.) They also implicitly assume there to be a fixed set of variables P out of which the literals in V and the formulas \varphi can be constructed. If V does not contain a literal involving X , then X is said to be unsettled . For each variable in P there is at most one equation in M . We say that X is a child of C if C occurs in the equation for X . The descendant relation is the transitive closure of the child relation, and the ancestor relation is the reversal of the descendant relation. The semantics of a causal model are given by combining M with V in the following manner. V\models(X=\varphi) iff X\in V and V classically implies \varphi or \lnot X\in V and V classically implies \lnot\varphi . V\models M iff V satisfies each equation in M . <M,V>\models\varphi for some formula \varphi iff \varphi is classically implied by V and M . <M,V> is unsettled about a formula \varphi iff <M,V> satisfies none of \varphi and \lnot\varphi . 1 1 1 In ( 4 ) and ( 5 ) they offer the same definitions but using the terminology of uninformativeness instead of unsettled . An intervention I is a consistent set of literals that functions as an operator on causal models, turning <M,V> into <M,V>[I]:=<M_{I},V\cup I> . Here M_{I} is defined as M_{I}:=\{(X=\varphi)\in M|X\not\in I\text{ and }\lnot X\not\in I\} . Lastly, for each X\in P we assume that either X or \lnot X is labelled as the default value, so that the opposite value can be labelled as deviant . (For now we set aside what determines this labelling.) With these elements in place, we can present AG7 . Definition 2.1 : [ Actual Causation (AG7) ] Let <M,V> be a causal model such that V\models M and <M,V>\models C\land E . Then C is a cause of E relative to <M,V> iff there is V^{\prime}\subseteq V and M^{\prime}\subseteq M such that • (C1) <M^{\prime},V^{\prime}> is unsettled on C and E , • (C2) there is no V^{\prime\prime}\subseteq V such that V^{\prime}\subset V^{\prime\prime} and <M^{\prime},V^{\prime\prime}> is unsettled on C and E , and • (C3) <M^{\prime},\emptyset>[V^{\prime}][C]\models E . • (C4) the structural equation of each descendant of C is in M^{\prime} . 2 2 2 Note that AG have appealed to a syntactic criterion for determining the graph structure. As a result, adding the semantically vacuous subformula Y\lor\lnot Y to the equation of C allows one to make any variable a descendant of C . This counterintuitive behavior can be avoided by using Halpern’s standard semantical criterion for the child-parent relation ( 18 ) . • (C5) for any literal C^{\prime}\in V\setminus V^{\prime} whose variable is neither a descendant nor an ancestor of C , C^{\prime} is more deviant than \lnot C^{\prime} . Let us walk through a simple example to illustrate AG7 . In cases of symmetric overdetermination, two independent events are both directly sufficient for producing an outcome.