Coupled atmospHere Interior modeL Intercomparison ( CHILI ). I. Evolutionary Modelling – Primordial Magma Oceans of Earth and Venus

Harrison Nicholls, Joshua Krissansen-Totton, Tim Lichtenberg, Laura Schaefer, Keiko Hamano, Maxime Maurice, Henri Samuel, Alexandra Papesh, Carlos Ortiz-Quintana, Junellie Perez, Yamila Miguel, Denis E. Sergeev, Philipp Baumeister, Spandan Dash, Leoni Janssen, Jonathan W. Keathley, Alexandre de Larminat, Emmanuel Marcq, Lena Noack, Hugo Pelissard, Bo Peng, Emma Postolec, Ramses Ramirez, Mariana Sastre, Andrea Zorzi · 2026

Read Coupled atmospHere Interior modeL Intercomparison ( CHILI ). I. Evolutionary Modelling – Primordial Magma Oceans of Earth and Venus by Harrison Nicholls, Joshua Krissansen-Totton, Tim Lichtenberg, Laura Schaefer, Keiko Hamano, Maxime Maurice, Henri Samuel, Alexandra Papesh, Carlos Ortiz-Quintana, Junellie Perez, Yamila Miguel, Denis E. Sergeev, Philipp Baumeister, Spandan Dash, Leoni Janssen, Jonathan W. Keathley, Alexandre de Larminat, Emmanuel Marcq, Lena Noack, Hugo Pelissard, Bo Peng, Emma Postolec, Ramses Ramirez, Mariana Sastre, Andrea Zorzi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-24757.txt.

Introduction

Harrison Nicholls leads the CHILI project, a comparison of codes that simulate young rocky planets. Earth and Venus both began as molten worlds covered by magma oceans. Coupled interior atmosphere models are the main tool for reconstructing those histories. Different codes, though, make different approximations, and results can drift apart. CHILI benchmarks the codes against each other to find where the sensitivities lie.

The first results cover evolutionary modelling of the early magma ocean stage. Nominal Earth models agree on solidification times within four million years. They also match empirical constraints on Earth's early history. Venus cases behave far more diversely. There, magma oceans can persist for fifty million years under the right conditions. Cooling times track the starting budgets of hydrogen and carbon. Treatments of volatile partitioning and vertical energy transport still differ between codes. Those choices drive much of the spread between models, the comparison shows.

Catalog record

CREATORHarrison Nicholls, Joshua Krissansen-Totton, Tim Lichtenberg, Laura Schaefer, Keiko Hamano, Maxime Maurice, Henri Samuel, Alexandra Papesh, Carlos Ortiz-Quintana, Junellie Perez, Yamila Miguel, Denis E. Sergeev, Philipp Baumeister, Spandan Dash, Leoni Janssen, Jonathan W. Keathley, Alexandre de Larminat, Emmanuel Marcq, Lena Noack, Hugo Pelissard, Bo Peng, Emma Postolec, Ramses Ramirez, Mariana Sastre, Andrea Zorzi
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE114 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.24757

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Coupled atmospHere Interior modeL Intercomparison ( CHILI ). I. Evolutionary Modelling – Primordial Magma Oceans of Earth and Venus Harrison Nicholls, Joshua Krissansen-Totton, Tim Lichtenberg, Laura Schaefer, Keiko Hamano, Maxime Maurice, Henri Samuel, Alexandra Papesh, Carlos Ortiz-Quintana, Junellie Perez, Yamila Miguel, Denis E. Sergeev, Philipp Baumeister, Spandan Dash, Leoni Janssen, Jonathan W. Keathley, Alexandre de Larminat, Emmanuel Marcq, Lena Noack, Hugo Pelissard, Bo Peng, Emma Postolec, Ramses Ramirez, Mariana Sastre, Andrea Zorzi Abstract Earth and Venus represent two evolutionary outcomes arising from initially molten ‘magma ocean’ periods, followed by lifetimes of chemical and geophysical divergence. Their physics is common to all rocky planets and is accessible to simulations that adopt coupled interior-atmosphere modelling approaches. Our understanding of planet histories and interpretation of current states is dependent on this modelling, yet existing codes vary in their approximations. Here, we present the first results from the Coupled atmospHere Interior modeL Intercomparison ( CHILI ) project; benchmarking planetary evolution codes in the context of Earth and Venus to identify key model sensitivities. Our ‘nominal’ Earth models predict magma ocean solidification timescales within 4 Myr of thermal evolution, and are consistent with empirical constraints on Earth’s early history. Venus scenarios exhibit more diverse behaviours where prolonged magma ocean stages can be conditionally sustained for 50 Myr. Cooling timescales correlate with initial hydrogen and carbon budgets, but model-specific treatments of volatile partitioning and vertical energy transport introduce substantial inter-model variance. Different parametrisation of mantle geodynamics, convection, melting curves, rheological properties, and radiative transfer give rise to divergent evolutionary behaviours. Discrepancies in atmospheres generated by magma ocean outgassing underscore these differences, although C-H-O compositions with surface pressures exceeding 100 bar are favoured. This intercomparison identifies critical sensitivities in volatile partitioning, escape processes, mantle viscosity, and melting curves. Validating these treatments is essential for enabling deep insight into the early histories of the Solar System’s terrestrial planets, and for drawing meaningful interpretations from ongoing observational exoplanet campaigns. I Introduction Rigorous intercomparison of the planetary evolution models and their physics is critical for interpreting current observations of exoplanets. The Coupled atmospHere Interior modeL Intercomparison ( CHILI 1 1 1 https://github.com/projectcuisines/chili ) project ( Lichtenberg et al. 2026 ) 2 2 2 https://nexss.info/cuisines/ identifies key uncertainties and limitations in these models, as part of the established CUISINES model intercomparison framework ( Sohl et al. 2024 ) . Here, we present Part I of CHILI by simulating Earth and Venus scenarios and comparing outcomes from a range of magma ocean evolution models. All rocky planets are born into hot states with global ‘magma oceans’ ( Schaefer & Elkins-Tanton 2018 ; Abe & Matsui 1985 ; Canup & Asphaug 2001 ; Cameron & Ward 1976 ) . Yet, Earth and Venus’ present climates differ substantially from each other, despite these two rocky planets orbiting the same star and being of similar sizes ( Lodders & Fegley 1998 ; Genda 2016 ; Javoy 2005 ) . How did Earth become habitable and Venus did not ( Hamano et al. 2025 ) ? Why does Earth have plate tectonics in contrast to Venus’ different tectonic setting ( Solomatov & Moresi 1996 ; Gillmann & Tackley 2014 ; Gülcher et al. 2020 ; Byrne et al. 2021 ) ? Does physics dictate these to be common outcomes of early planetary evolution, or two niche scenarios? Earth and Venus’ differential climates and geodynamics represent billions of years of evolution, shaped by the interplay of fluid dynamic, chemical, and physical processes ( Abe 1997 ; Lichtenberg et al. 2023 ) . Isotopic measurements of zircon minerals suggest that the Earth’s mantle solidified before 4.2 Gyr ago ( Cavosie et al. 2005 ; Sole et al. 2025 ) . Given these measurements, Earth’s last global magma ocean period then dates to between \approx 100 and 400 Myr after its formation ( Dalrymple 2001 ) . Giant impact events – such as those suggested having formed the Moon – would have re-melted Earth’s mantle during the period between its formation and its final solidification ( Canup & Asphaug 2001 ; Borg et al. 2014 ; Barboni et al. 2017 ) , potentially allowing multiple sequential magma ocean stages to modulate Earth’s structure and volatile budget ( Abe & Matsui 1985 ; Citron et al. 2018 ; Canup & Asphaug 2001 ) . Xenon isotopes provide further evidence for efficient, magma ocean mediated volatile degassing within Earth’s first 100 Myr ( Rzeplinski et al. 2022 ) . When Earth first solidified, and whether solidification occurred once or episodically, is dependent on the processes regulating its early cooling ( Schaefer & Fegley 2017 ; Nakajima & Stevenson 2015 ) . The formation of a solid crust remains a necessary condition for condensing water oceans and geochemical weathering ( Foley 2015 ; Pierrehumbert 2002 ) , potentially active between magma ocean epochs ( Mojzsis et al. 2001 ; Dasgupta 2013 ) . So, careful comparison between computer modelling and empirical constraints on Earth’s earliest stages contextualise the conditions for the origin of life and our current climate ( Elkins-Tanton 2012 ; Zahnle et al. 2010 ) . Venus’ age is comparable to Earth’s, but its early thermal and geodynamical history are less well constrained ( Halliday & Canup 2023 ; Lammer et al. 2020 ) . Direct insights into Venus’ geothermal history are precluded due to the absence of samples and global resurfacing by active volcanic processes within the last \sim 750 – 150 Ma ( Marchi et al. 2023 ; Strom et al. 1994 ; Ivanov & Head 2013 ) . We expect that Venus’ early magma ocean modulated escape of its initial volatiles \sim 10 to \sim 100 Myr after the planet formed ( Hamano et al. 2013 ) . Indications of a water-poor Venusian interior ( Constantinou et al. 2025 ) and depletion of radiogenic {}^{40}\mathrm{Ar} in its atmosphere ( O’Rourke & Korenaga 2015 ; Kaula 1999 ) potentially suggest efficient early magma ocean degassing. Magma ocean solidification was followed by several Gyr of uncertain atmosphere-interior interactions ( Rolf et al. 2022 ; Warren & Kite 2023 ; Ghail et al. 2024 ; Gillmann et al. 2022 ) . After magma ocean solidification, Venus may have sustained an uninhabitable post-runaway greenhouse state throughout its lifetime, or it could have temporarily hosted a water ocean ( Turbet et al. 2021 ; Warren & Kite 2023 ; Way et al. 2016 ; Krissansen-Totton et al. 2021b ) , a view which is supported by the possible felsic compositions of highland tessera terrain ( Gilmore et al. 2017 ) . Understanding the lifetime history of our sister planet is strongly dependent on modelled predictions to interpret limited in-situ measurements. Planetary evolutionary models – informed by known physics – can predict the feasible historical pathways potentially undertaken by a given planet, based on its measured size, irradiation, and composition ( Elkins-Tanton 2008 ; Lichtenberg et al. 2025 ; Krissansen-Totton et al. 2022 ) . Numerical simulation methods have remained the leading approach for quantifying planetary lifetime histories since Abe & Matsui 1985 . More recently, computer modelling developments have appealed to exoplanet environments starkly different to the Solar System; e.g. the peas-in-a-pod TRAPPIST-1 planets ( Agol et al. 2021 ; Krissansen-Totton &

Read the complete text