When Black Holes Can Wear Pants
Giacomo Cacciapaglia, Manuel Del Piano, Francesco Sannino, Vania Vellucci · 2026
Read When Black Holes Can Wear Pants by Giacomo Cacciapaglia, Manuel Del Piano, Francesco Sannino, Vania Vellucci (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-24642.txt.
Introduction
Cacciapaglia, Del Piano, Sannino, and Vellucci ask when a black hole can split in two, a process whose horizon topology resembles a pair of pants. Classical general relativity forbids it for Schwarzschild black holes, through the area law. Splitting would shrink total horizon area. For spinning Kerr black holes, kinematic constraints block fragmentation even where entropy might allow it. Near extremality, where spin approaches its maximum, is the possible exception.
The hunt therefore turns to escape routes. The Gregory-Laflamme instability fragments extended horizons in higher dimensions. Superradiant instabilities, with non axisymmetric radiation trapping, might pry four-dimensional holes apart. Models modifying the relations among entropy, radius, and mass can also favour splitting. In all these scenarios, emitting small fragments can be entropically favoured, though occurrence still hinges on the initial state's kinematics. The 2026 analysis clarifies the landscape for primordial black holes, and other settings where fragmentation would leave evidence.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Giacomo Cacciapaglia, Manuel Del Piano, Francesco Sannino, Vania Vellucci |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 62 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY SA |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.24642
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
When Black Holes Can Wear Pants Giacomo Cacciapaglia, Manuel Del Piano, Francesco Sannino, Vania Vellucci Abstract We investigate the conditions under which black hole fragmentation, the splitting of a black hole horizon into multiple smaller ones, may occur. The simplest realization is that of a single black hole horizon splitting into two, giving rise to the eponymous pants topology. In classical general relativity, the Bekenstein–Hawking area law forbids such processes for Schwarzschild black holes. For spinning Kerr black holes, purely kinematic analyses impose constraints that prevent fragmentation, even in regimes where entropy considerations might allow it, except possibly in near-extremal cases. We then hunt for scenarios where black holes can wear pants: from the well-known Gregory–Laflamme instability in higher dimensions, to the potential effect of superradiant instabilities in non-axisymmetric radiation trapping, to finally gravitational models that modify the relations between entropy and/or horizon radius and the black hole mass in four dimensions. In all such cases, emission of small fragments can be entropically favored, however its occurrence still depends on the kinematic configuration of the initial state. Our analysis clarifies the theoretical landscape where black holes may fragment, which is particularly relevant for primordial black holes and catastrophic events such as black hole mergers. 1 Introduction Answering the question whether a black hole can “wear pants” , that is, whether a single horizon can evolve into a configuration that effectively resembles multiple black holes, is a probe of the interplay between dynamics, thermodynamics, and global structure in gravity. The simplest illustration of this process would be a single black hole horizon evolving into two separate ones, see Fig. 1 , which showcases the eponymous topology. In four-dimensional classical general relativity (GR), stationary black holes appear remarkably rigid: Hawking’s area theorem 37 constrains any process that tends to reduce the total area of the horizon, as it would lead to a decrease of the total entropy stored in the black holes, a statement that has recently received direct observational support through the gravitational signal of binary mergers 1 ; 60 . As such, a single Schwarzschild black hole is always entropically favored over two black holes of the same total mass. Furthermore, the linear stability of spinning Kerr black holes under small perturbations has been well established 65 ; 35 . At face value, these facts suggest that spontaneous fragmentation of an isolated black hole into smaller constituents is forbidden. Yet this conclusion is contingent on assumptions, notably suitable energy conditions and a form of cosmic censorship, and it can fail in settings such as higher-dimensional spacetimes, higher-curvature theories, or semiclassical regimes. Understanding precisely what is forbidden, what is merely unlikely, and what becomes possible once the assumptions are relaxed is the central goal of this work. Figure 1: Simplest diagram representing black hole pants: a single black hole of mass M splitting into two fragments of masses m_{1} and m_{2} . A complementary, and conceptually important, viewpoint comes from global properties of event horizons. Penrose’s non-bifurcation theorem implies that, in a strongly asymptotically predictable spacetime, horizon generators cannot have future endpoints 64 ; heuristically, event horizons do not split in such spacetimes and black holes do not wear pants. The theorem does not exclude every notion of “fragmentation”, instead it clarifies what must give way: a genuine horizon bifurcation in a classical setting would require a breakdown of strong asymptotic predictability, which is typically associated to the appearance of naked singularities. Note, however, that in a black hole scattering not every multi-object outcome requires horizon splitting: for instance, a 2\to 2 process, where two black holes interact and separate into two new black holes of different parameters, may not involve a bifurcation of a single connected event horizon, provided no common trapped region forms during the interaction. If fragmentation were possible under certain conditions, the observational consequences could be significant. It would provide an alternative formation channel for black holes with masses outside the ranges accessible through standard astrophysical processes, potentially producing black hole morsels small enough to exhibit observable Hawking evaporation on experimentally accessible timescales 15 . Conversely, the observed stability of black holes across a wide range of masses and spins places stringent constraints on any fragmentation scenario. In our analysis, we will be mainly concerned with entropy considerations, i.e. the fact that states with larger entropy are statistically favored, including kinematics, when possible, to study black hole fragmentation within various contexts. Within GR, the basic entropic obstruction to fragmentation is immediate for non-rotating black holes with Schwarzschild metric, for which the entropy is proportional to the mass squared, i.e. S(M)\propto GM^{2} , where G=1/M_{\text{P}}^{2} is Newton’s constant in terms of the Planck mass M_{\text{P}} . Being a convex function of the mass, if one imagines a putative splitting process, 1\to 2 , with M=m_{1}+m_{2} see Fig. 1 , then S(m_{1})+S(m_{2})\leq S(M) , so fragmentation would violate the second law of thermodynamics. The rotating case is more subtle: for a Kerr black hole of given mass, the larger the spin the smaller the entropy. Hence, in principle one can envision a configuration where some, if not all, of the original angular momentum could be converted into orbital angular momentum of the fragments, allowing the total entropy of the final configuration to compete with the initial one. However, any such channel must also satisfy energy and angular momentum conservation together with the requirement that the fragments actually separate rather than promptly re-merge. We make this tension explicit and we delineate, in the cleanest possible way, the combined entropic and kinematic obstructions to true fragmentation within classical four-dimensional GR. Higher-dimensional GR dramatically changes the situation and provides a concrete arena where fragmentation-like evolution is not only entropically plausible, but dynamically realized. Extended horizons, such as black strings, suffer from the Gregory–Laflamme instability 36 , and ultra-spinning Myers–Perry black holes 53 develop instabilities that can be understood as approaching the physics of extended black branes 31 ; 32 . In these cases, the “ black hole pants ” picture becomes literal: the horizon evolves toward highly inhomogeneous configurations, and the endpoint can involve pinch-off behavior and violations of cosmic censorship in classical evolution 49 . These examples teach us an essential lesson: entropic reasoning is a powerful diagnostic, but the actual fate of an instability is ultimately dynamical and may involve singular behavior once the classical assumptions are relaxed. Motivated by these lessons, we broaden the discussion toward two additional directions. First, we consider effective fragmentation mechanisms in which a Kerr black hole may come to behave as if it had developed companions without a literal horizon bifurcation. A representative possibility is provided by superradiant amplification 56 in the presence of asymmetric trapping, which may occur due to plasma-induced effective masses for photons or additional light degrees of freedom in a non-uniform accretion disk 23 . Second, we examine how fragmentation criteria are altered beyond GR, where the mass-dependence of the horizon radius and/or entropy is affected. As an example, we consider higher-derivative gravity theories 13 ; 14 , where both the radius and the entropy functional (via Wald entropy) differ from the GR ones. This can in principle reverse the entropic balance for sufficiently asymmetric mass splits, when one fragment