Augusto Eiji Yamazaki, Hugo Garrido-Lestache Belinchon

Milwaukee School of Engineering · 2026

Read Augusto Eiji Yamazaki, Hugo Garrido-Lestache Belinchon by Milwaukee School of Engineering (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-24575.txt.

Introduction

Yamazaki and Garrido-Lestache Belinchon test whether Benjamin Graham's old value investing rules can discipline modern stock picking. Machine learning models hunting market patterns often memorise short term noise instead of durable value. The pair writes from the Milwaukee School of Engineering in 2026. They treat Graham's classic screening rules as a low pass filter, and build three feature sets: pure Graham rules, modern market factors, and a combination.

Complex models, including XGBoost and AutoGluon, train on twenty years of S&P 500 data, then run a strict buy and hold over a four year test window ending in March 2026. Complexity does not win. The AutoGluon model posts high returns. It suffers a steep drawdown, though, after loading up on volatile technology stocks before a crash. A pure Graham random forest achieves the highest return, with much less risk. The moral is restraint: simple rules still filter noise that sophisticated models chase.

Catalog record

CREATORMilwaukee School of Engineering
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/
RIGHTSCC0
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.24575

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Augusto Eiji Yamazaki, Hugo Garrido-Lestache Belinchon Milwaukee School of Engineering Abstract Quant Convergence: Bridging Classical Value Investing and Modern Factor Models for Systematic Equity Selection Abstract Modern finance relies heavily on complex machine learning models to find patterns in the stock market. However, as these AI models get more complicated, they often memorize short-term market noise instead of finding companies with real, lasting value. We designed this research to test if Benjamin Graham’s classic value investing rules could act as a mathematical “low-pass filter” to keep these modern models in check. We built three different sets of features—pure Graham rules, modern market factors, and a mix of both—and tested them against highly complex models (XGBoost and AutoGluon) using 20 years of S&P 500 data. By applying a strict buy-and-hold strategy over a four-year test period (March 2022 to March 2026), the results showed that more complex algorithms do not always win. While the AutoGluon model captured high returns (222.68%), it suffered a substantial 39.78% drop because it bought volatile tech stocks right before the market crashed. On the other hand, the pure Graham Random Forest achieved the highest overall return (232.13%) with much less risk (1.38 Calmar Ratio). Furthermore, the Combined Random Forest successfully mixed momentum with Graham’s rules, making a 202.91% return while keeping the lowest maximum drop (34.53%) of any model tested. Ultimately, this research proves that Graham’s “margin of safety” isn’t outdated; it is actually a highly effective way to prevent modern AI from taking on too much risk. 1 Introduction Stock selection has evolved from manual analysis to algorithmic trading driven by complex neural networks. In modern quantitative finance, state-of-the-art machine learning models like XGBoost and AutoGluon are often used to hunt for hidden patterns in financial data. However, the stock market is incredibly noisy. As these models get more complicated, they risk “overfitting”—memorizing short-term market hype instead of finding companies with actual, long-term value. Long before machine learning existed, Benjamin Graham wrote The Intelligent Investor , creating strict, rule-based screens to find companies with strong balance sheets and conservative valuations. Specifically, his defensive framework requires seven core criteria: (1) adequate enterprise size, (2) strong short-term liquidity ( CurrentRatio\geq 2 ), (3) consistent positive earnings, (4) an uninterrupted dividend record, (5) demonstrated long-term earnings growth, (6) a moderate price-to-earnings ratio ( P/E\leq 15 ), and (7) a conservative combined valuation multiple ( P/E\times P/B\leq 22.5 ). While designed for the 1940s, the engineering goal behind these rules—acting as a mathematical “low-pass filter” to remove financially fragile companies—makes intuitive sense. But does it actually hold up against modern AI? We designed this research to find out. By combining industrial engineering principles with quantitative finance, we built a system to test Graham’s classical value signals against modern quantitative factors (like momentum and volatility) and highly complex automated ensembles. Through a rigorous 20-year backtest, our goal was to see if the structural simplicity of classic fundamental screens provides a better signal-to-noise ratio than modern black-box algorithms. What we found challenged our own assumptions. Not only did Graham’s 1940s rules survive, but they actively beat the modern AI models in both absolute returns and risk management. Even more surprisingly, trying to modernize Graham’s rules by combining them with contemporary momentum factors actually diluted their performance. This paper breaks down exactly how we built this system, why the complex AI failed during market shocks, and why pure fundamental logic is still the best regularization tool we have in quantitative finance. 2 Related Works 2.1 Historical Validation of Value Investing Criteria The historical foundation of classical value investing relies heavily on the defensive screens formalized by Benjamin Graham. Early empirical studies demonstrated that Graham’s strict criteria—including adequate enterprise size, low P/E ratios, and robust equity capitalization—yielded positive abnormal risk-adjusted returns for defensive investors [ 12 ] . Modern quantitative asset pricing has inadvertently echoed these principles; for example, the “Quality Minus Junk” (QMJ) factor captures dimensions like safety, profitability, and payout ratios that closely mirror Graham’s original requirements [ 3 ] . While these studies confirm that Graham’s metrics work in isolation or in simple linear models, we need to evaluate how this entire defensive framework holds up when mathematically transformed into a unified feature set for complex, non-linear machine learning architectures. 2.2 Machine Learning in Fundamental Analysis and Asset Pricing Machine learning has fundamentally shifted how we forecast financial data. Recent research highlights this by applying Random Forests and Artificial Neural Networks to raw fundamental accounting variables, proving that non-linear models drastically reduce earnings forecast errors and generate significant predictive alpha compared to traditional linear models [ 5 ] . This intersection has expanded by successfully digitizing and evaluating Graham’s fundamental criteria using modern supervised learning algorithms [ 1 ] . Random Forests trained on comprehensive valuation variables can systematically isolate market signals while minimizing human bias [ 8 ] . In the broader scope of empirical asset pricing, non-linear architectures effectively double the out-of-sample Sharpe ratio of standard panel regressions by naturally capturing complex characteristic interactions [ 7 ] . Dissecting financial characteristics with nonparametric methods further shows that accommodating non-linearities significantly increases out-of-sample explanatory power [ 6 ] . Evaluating the equity premium utilizing non-linear methods like multiple kernel learning on financial features validates the necessity of moving beyond simple linear regressions [ 2 ] . 2.3 Investability and Market-Specific Constraints While academic backtests of ML algorithms often ignore trading frictions, recent literature emphasizes realistic implementations. “Investable and interpretable” ML utilizing 12-month prediction horizons can significantly reduce portfolio turnover, proving that while ML consistently outperforms linear models, the practical benefits are incremental when subjected to liquidity constraints [ 10 ] . Similarly, ML strategies maintain robust alphas even after adjusting for transaction costs by dynamically adapting to regime shifts [ 14 ] . Data integrity and synchronization are also critical. Studies capitalizing on synchronized fiscal year-ends to eliminate look-ahead bias have shown that feeding financial ratios into machine learning models generates significant excess returns [ 20 ] . Deep learning models have successfully extracted robust signals from fundamental profitability and growth metrics in international markets as well [ 9 ] . To respect these real-world constraints and guarantee reproducibility, our methodology enforces a strict 80/20 temporal split, locks all algorithmic random seeds, and utilizes a single-trade buy-and-hold rule. This ensures that the extracted ML signals are not just mathematically significant, but practically investable without succumbing to look-ahead bias or prohibitive turnover. 2.4 Algorithmic Architectures: Ensembles and AutoML The literature provides extensive evaluations of the specific tree-based and ensemble architectures used in equity classification. Comprehensive evaluations of multiple classifiers have long established that ensemble methods generally offer superior predictive accuracy for stock price direction compared to single algorithms [ 4 ] . The evolution of financial ML highlights how simple linear models have been superseded by robust ensembles like Random Forest and XGBoost for handling non-linear asset behaviors [ 16 , 21 ] . Comparative studies explicitly verify that Random Forests achieve significantly higher prediction accuracy with lower error rates than simple decision trees [ 22 ] . Moreover, portfolios optimized via XGBoost and Random Forest easily achieve higher Sharpe ratios than traditional mean-variance frameworks [ 11 ] . To

Read the complete text