Gravity theory of the generalized mass-to-horizon entropy : The Iyer–Wald approach
Subhra Mondal, Amitava Choudhuri · 2026
Read Gravity theory of the generalized mass-to-horizon entropy : The Iyer–Wald approach by Subhra Mondal, Amitava Choudhuri (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-24495.txt.
Introduction
Mondal and Choudhuri trace a generalised black hole entropy back to a gravity action. This entropy deforms the standard horizon entropy, with an exponent index and a scaling parameter. What gravity theory actually produces it? Their 2026 letter applies the Iyer-Wald approach, the covariant method deriving entropy from a theory's Lagrangian, inside a modified f(R) gravity scenario with constant curvature solutions.
The entropy is rebuilt from an extended Lagrangian: a power of the curvature scalar slightly above one. The departure from Einstein's linear choice is set by the entropy's exponent index. Tiny departures from general relativity thus generate the whole family. Mondal and Choudhuri close by discussing the cosmos. They ask whether the construction might relieve the thermal instability of Schwarzschild black holes, whose negative heat capacity has troubled gravity thermodynamics for decades.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Subhra Mondal, Amitava Choudhuri |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.24495
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Gravity theory of the generalized mass-to-horizon entropy : The Iyer–Wald approach Subhra Mondal, Amitava Choudhuri Abstract In this letter, our aim is to study the gravitational origin of the generalized mass-to-horizon entropy (GMHE), described by an entropic exponent index n n and a multiplicative parameter γ \gamma . We employ Iyer-Wald’s approach within the modified 𝔣 ( ℜ ) \mathfrak{f(R)} gravity scenario in order to assess the horizon entropy of the black hole (BH) by considering solutions with constant curvature for the spherically symmetric vacuum field equations. In this process, we explicitly show that the GMHE can effectively be reconstructed from a generalized Lagrangian 𝔏 ∝ ℜ 1 + ϵ \mathfrak{L}\propto\mathfrak{R}^{1+\epsilon} , where ϵ ≡ n − 1 2 \epsilon\equiv\frac{n-1}{2} measures tiny departures from the standard formulation of general relativity (GR). Finally, we discuss the physical implications of our results in relation to cosmology and the prospects for alleviating the thermodynamic instability of Schwarzschild BHs. I Introduction The Boltzmann-Gibbs (BG) statistical mechanics stands as one of the most successful and robust frameworks in modern physics. Its applications are incredibly broad, ranging from standard thermodynamics and solid-state physics to high-energy physics and information theory, in both classical and quantum sectors 47 . Despite its huge success, a closer look reveals severe difficulties or anomalies in describing the non-standard or complex systems, highlighting its limited applicability (see Refs. 82 ; 68 ; 53 ). Gibbs 30 himself showed that systems with divergent canonical partition functions, such as gravitational systems (long-range interactions), violate the BG theory. It is important to note that the standard BG statistics, which leads to the famous Bekenstein-Hawking area law 7 ; 35 for BHs, break down in explaining thermodynamic extensivity if BHs are treated as ( 1+3 )-dimensional objects 36 ; 78 ; 77 . These clear conceptual boundaries have driven physicists to look beyond standard models, searching for broader frameworks that can handle systems where standard thermodynamics and statistical mechanics fail. The main problematic issue with the concept of BH entropy is due to the unavailability of a proper description in conventional statistical mechanics. Rather, it depends on Bekenstein and Hawking’s definition, which is nonadditive and nonextensive in nature. As a result, gravity-related applications cannot be well defined by the laws of standard thermodynamics and statistical mechanics. In order to resolve this difficulty, some nonextensive statistical mechanical formulations have been developed and employed to explain phenomena in BHs and other cosmological applications (see 13 ; 63 ; 65 ; 64 ; 66 ; 69 ; 70 ; 80 ; 61 ; 17 ; 62 ; 72 ; 18 ; 57 ; 58 ; 46 ; 45 ; 67 ; 48 ; 54 ; 49 ; 25 ; 26 ; 3 ; 1 , and the references therein). These nonextensive statistics/entropies have become popular nowadays and include a variety of propositions, such as Tsallis statistics 83 ; 84 , Sharma–Mittal statistics 74 ; 73 ; 55 , Rényi statistics 71 and Kaniadakis statistics 42 ; 43 ; 41 , the Tsallis–Cirto entropy 81 ; 85 , Zamora-Tsallis entropy 89 ; 90 and Barrow entropy 5 are some specific examples. The application of nonextensive entropies to self-gravitating systems is evident due to the significant impact that long-range interactions play in nonextensive thermodynamics. Nonextensivity that results from long-range interactions is anticipated in Tsallis’s statistical mechanics. Rényi statistics has been extensively used in quantum information theory, and Rényi entropy quantifies the entanglement of quantum mechanical systems. Sharma–Mittal statistics simply extend the ideas of Tsallis and Rényi statistics, while the Lorentz transformation of special relativity inspires building Kaniadakis statistics. It is worth mentioning that some of these entropies have formal similarities. However, they differ in their conceptual foundations. For instance, Tsallis-Cirto entropy arises from the requirement of the extensive property of classical BH thermodynamics, whereas Barrow entropy emerges from consideration of the fractal nature of the BH horizon, motivated by the structure of the COVID- 19 virus, where the effects of quantum gravitational spacetime foam have been taken care of. Zamora-Tsallis entropy arises in the cosmological context by considering a thermodynamically consistent entropic-force model, where the Legendre structure of thermodynamics has been conserved. Another promising formalism in pursuit of nonextensive statistics is the entropic formalism based on generalized mass-to-horizon ratio 31 ; 24 ; 32 ; 75 . Recently, the GMHE framework has been explored in different contexts, especially in the cosmological sector 31 ; 24 ; 32 ; 50 ; 52 ; 6 ; 51 ; 75 ; 2 ; 59 . An analysis presented in Ref. 31 reveals that this framework can create a cosmological model that is in agreement with observation, quite similarly to the widely accepted Lambda cold dark matter ( \Lambda CDM) model, provided specific conditions. In Ref 32 , the authors study the foundations of entropic cosmologies, addressing their inconsistencies, potential solutions, and identifying signs of dead ends. In Ref. 24 , late-time acceleration of our Universe has been investigated along with observational data sets and claim that the GMHE-inspired cosmological model is statistically preferred over the standard \Lambda CDM profile. The study in Ref. 75 formulates the modified Friedmann equations based on GMHE and searches for the origin of cosmic space by exploiting the equilibrium approach, inspired by Padmanabhan’s idea of ‘emergent gravity’ and the first law of thermodynamics on the apparent horizon. Authors in Ref. 6 derive the modified Friedmann equations from this entropy and add an effective DE component by using the gravity-thermodynamics conjecture. Their findings, based on different datasets, show that this modified model is consistent with observations. The study of the generation of the baryon asymmetry within this cosmological setting has been explored in Ref. 51 and establishes certain limits on the entropic parameters. In Ref. 50 , authors impose observational constraints on this model, and note this model closely resembles the \Lambda CDM profile without significant deviations. The effect of this modified cosmology on the growth of matter density perturbation and primordial gravitational waves in the early Universe has been analyzed in Ref. 52 . In Ref. 2 , background cosmology and growth of density perturbation in the context of GMHE have been investigated, which is found to be fully compatible with observed data. In our previous article 59 , we explored the cosmological dynamics and structure formation by employing the spherical top-hat collapse formalism in the same cosmological setup. Although a lot of studies of GMHE in the field of cosmology exist in the literature, its application to BH is still lacking. In this work, we aim to investigate the roots of the GMHE of the BH horizon in gravity theory. It is established that the entropy associated with a BH horizon in any diffeomorphism-invariant gravity theory can, theoretically, be obtained from the effective Lagrangian of the system through the Noether charge method proposed by Iyer and Wald 87 ; 38 ; 39 . In analogy with the recently established study on the Lagrangian approach to Tsallis entropy via the Iyer-Wald approach 27 , we seek an extension of GR to GMHE for BHs at the fundamental level. The consistency of the Iyer-Wald formula can, in principle, be verified by reproducing the standard area law in GR, whereas