Do Waders, Swimmers, and Divers Exist? A GPS-Based Pilot Study of Site-Dependent Visitor Movement in Theme Parks

Dane M. Utley, Jürgen Hackl · 2026

Read Do Waders, Swimmers, and Divers Exist? A GPS-Based Pilot Study of Site-Dependent Visitor Movement in Theme Parks by Dane M. Utley, Jürgen Hackl (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-24434.txt.

Introduction

Utley and Hackl check whether theme park planners' folk typology of guests survives GPS evidence. Planners informally sort visitors into waders, who drift and sightsee, swimmers, who plan moderately, and divers, who maximise attractions. Their 2026 pilot study grounds the scheme in observed movement. GPS tracks and an exit survey come from recruited guests across three Southern California parks.

Each visit is summed up by eight hand-annotated movement features. They are clustered per park, and judged by a multi-criteria protocol covering quality indices, firmness under restarts and subsampling, and agreement between algorithms. Separation is modest everywhere. No cluster structure scores sharply. At Knott's Berry Farm, though, the three-group partition repeats very well. Its groups differ sharply in attractions ridden per hour. Repeating without sharp separation suggests a conduct continuum, rather than discrete species of guest. The typology gestures at something real but graded, not three kinds of visitor.

Catalog record

CREATORDane M. Utley, Jürgen Hackl
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE93 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.24434

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Do Waders, Swimmers, and Divers Exist? A GPS-Based Pilot Study of Site-Dependent Visitor Movement in Theme Parks Dane M. Utley, Jürgen Hackl Abstract Theme-park master planners informally sort guests into behavioral types (waders, who sightsee aimlessly; swimmers, who plan moderately; and divers, who maximize attractions) to guide layout decisions and to seed pedestrian simulations, yet the typology is rarely grounded in observed movement. To ground it, GPS tracks and an exit survey are collected from 23 recruited guests, yielding 26 park visits across three Southern California parks (Knott’s Berry Farm, n = 15 n=15 ; Disneyland, n = 7 n=7 ; Disney California Adventure, n = 4 n=4 ). Each visit is summarized by eight manually annotated movement features; visits are clustered per park and the partitions assessed with a multi-criteria protocol: internal validity indices, the gap statistic, restart and subsampling stability, and agreement across clustering algorithms. Geometric separation is modest everywhere (no silhouette ≥ 0.35 \geq 0.35 ), yet at Knott’s the three-group partition is highly reproducible ( k k -means and Ward agree exactly; consensus co-assignment 0.79 within versus 0.09 between), and its groups differ on behavioral rates (attractions per hour, p = 0.004 p=0.004 ). Reproducibility without sharp geometric separation indicates a behavioral continuum rather than discrete types. The exit survey does not distinguish the clusters, so objective movement and self-report diverge. Feature directionality reverses across parks for three of eight features, so parameters cannot be universalized. The observed heatmaps carry a monotone type signature, a thrill-versus-commercial occupancy gradient that rises from waders to divers, and an agent-based test localizes its source: agent populations differing only in measured movement parameters fail to separate the types, as does a homogeneous baseline, whereas a model adding a priori type-specific destination preference and visit sequencing reproduces the gradient’s direction and ordering. Type-specific space use therefore arises from destination choice more than from how visitors walk. Visitor-behavior parameters are site-specific, and a reproducible, critically validated segmentation pipeline offers a route to calibrating them per park. Keywords GPS tracking \cdot visitor behavior \cdot theme parks \cdot trajectory clustering \cdot behavioral segmentation \cdot agent-based pedestrian simulation 1 Introduction On a single operating day a 100-acre theme park such as Disneyland moves tens of thousands of guests several miles each on foot ( Themed Entertainment Association 2024c ) . Sustaining the seamless visual storytelling that defines these venues depends on keeping that pedestrian traffic flowing, so understanding and simulating guest movement is a central task of theme-park master planning, both before a park is built and throughout its operating life ( Li 1995c ) . A planner who can anticipate where crowds will form can shape sightlines, place retail and dining, size walkways, and stage attractions to spread demand. The difficulty is that there is no single “guest” whose movement can be planned for. Visitors arrive with different goals, energy, and tolerance for crowds, and they pursue those goals in different ways across the same physical space, so the spatial demand a park experiences is the superposition of several distinct movement styles rather than the behavior of one average visitor. The stakes of getting this superposition right are operational and economic. Walkway width, queue placement, retail frontage, show capacity, and the staging of headline attractions are all sized against anticipated pedestrian load, and the cost of error is asymmetric: under-provisioned circulation produces congestion that degrades the guest experience and, at the extreme, raises safety and egress concerns, while over-provisioned circulation wastes land that in a theme park is exceptionally expensive per square foot. Because a park cannot be re-poured once built, operators turn to pedestrian simulation to test layouts before construction and to evaluate operational changes afterward, and the realism of those simulations depends on how faithfully the agent population reproduces the mix of real movement styles. A simulation seeded with a single average agent will systematically misplace demand, smearing it evenly where real guests concentrate at thrill nodes or linger in retail cores; a simulation seeded with the wrong proportions or the wrong per-type parameters will misplace it differently. The behavioral parameters that distinguish visitor types are therefore not a modeling nicety but a determinant of the predictions on which capital and safety decisions rest, which is what makes their empirical grounding worth pursuing. Industry practice manages this heterogeneity with a swimming-pool metaphor that sorts guests into three types. Younger et al. 2016c describes waders as those who “just want to walk around and see pretty pictures,” divers as those who “want to know every shred of information that exists,” and swimmers as the bridging case. Translated into movement, waders are expected to wander slowly, take scenic detours, and be drawn to incidental sights; divers to move quickly and directly so as to ride as many attractions as possible; and swimmers to blend the two. The vocabulary is common among designers and is used not only for attraction storytelling but, more relevant here, to seed the digital pedestrian simulations on which operators increasingly rely for layout, safety, and revenue decisions ( Rajaram & Ahmadi 2003c ) . Yet the typology rests on expert judgment rather than measurement. To our knowledge, the proportions of each type, and the movement parameters that distinguish them, have never been grounded in observed guest trajectories. Existing academic theme-park models either optimize a single named park from proprietary operational data ( Ahmadi 1997c ; Rajaram & Ahmadi 2003c ) or treat guests as homogeneous agents that choose destinations by popularity and distance ( Solmaz et al. 2015c ; Vukadinovic et al. 2011c ) , leaving unmodeled exactly the behavioral heterogeneity the wader/swimmer/diver framing presupposes. This gap matters in three distinct ways that prior work has not separated. First, the categories may not correspond to any recoverable structure in measured movement at all. Second, even if a partition is recoverable, it may be a fragile artifact of a particular algorithm or sample rather than a reproducible grouping. Third, even a reproducible partition may carry different behavioral meaning at different parks, so that parameter values calibrated at one venue mislead at another. A credible empirical treatment of the typology must address all three questions, and it must do so with validation that does not simply restate the assumptions used to construct the groups. Research questions. We ask: (RQ1) Can the wader/swimmer/diver typology be recovered from GPS-derived movement features, and is the resulting partition reproducible across algorithms and resamples rather than a single-method artifact? (RQ2) Do the recovered groups differ on theoretically motivated movement features, and do they agree with an independent exit survey? (RQ3) Does the behavioral meaning of each feature transfer across structurally different parks, or is it park-dependent? (RQ4) Do cluster-derived parameters, when used to drive a microscopic pedestrian model, reproduce observed spatial patterns, and do type-specific parameters add value over a homogeneous baseline? Contribution and scope. This is an exploratory, park-specific pilot, not a confirmatory or generalizable study, and we state that limit at the outset rather than burying it. We make no claim to a representative sample, we report uncertainty rather than confirmatory hypothesis tests, and we do not validate parameters in an operational deployment. Within those bounds the study makes four contributions. First, it provides a

Read the complete text