Binary black hole scattering with generic spins

Adam Clark, Geraint Pratten, Patricia Schmidt · 2026

Read Binary black hole scattering with generic spins by Adam Clark, Geraint Pratten, Patricia Schmidt (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-24432.txt.

Introduction

Clark, Pratten, and Schmidt confront theory predictions for black hole flybys with full numerical simulations, for the first time. When two black holes scatter rather than merge, their deflection encodes strong field gravity. Post-Minkowskian theory, an expansion treating gravity step by step, predicts it order by order. The 2026 letter extracts azimuthal and polar scattering angles from numerical relativity simulations, with generic, freely oriented spins, and relates them to the theory's spin kick observable.

Euler angles for unbound motion are introduced, and tied in geometry to the scattering angles. The simulations then expose something the perturbative results miss. A strong field precession turning point structure appears, including a polar angle sign change with no counterpart in the post-Minkowskian predictions. Clark's team targets better waveform models for oval, precessing binaries, the systems gravitational wave detectors increasingly see. It shows exactly where high order theory stops describing nature.

Catalog record

CREATORAdam Clark, Geraint Pratten, Patricia Schmidt
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.24432

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Binary black hole scattering with generic spins Adam Clark, Geraint Pratten, Patricia Schmidt Abstract In this Letter, we confront high-order post-Minkowskian (PM) predictions for generic-spin black-hole scattering with numerical-relativity (NR) simulations for the first time, targeting improvements for eccentric and precessing waveform modelling. We extract azimuthal and polar scattering angles from NR and relate them to the PM spin-kick observable. We introduce asymptotic Euler angles for unbound motion and derive their geometric relation to the scattering angles. Notably, NR exposes a strong-field precessional turning-point structure, including a polar-angle sign change absent in the perturbative PM results. Introduction – Gravitational waves (GWs) from compact binary coalescences provide a unique probe of strong-field gravitational dynamics and the nature of the interacting bodies. Of all their properties, spin is one of the most fundamental Carter 1971 , encoding valuable information on the astrophysical origin of black holes and neutron stars across the Universe Vitale et al. 2022 . Spin adds significant complexity to the emitted radiation, with generic spin orientations exciting spin-orbit and spin-spin couplings that drive precession of the spins and orbital plane, breaking planar symmetry Lense and Thirring 1918 ; Barker and O’Connell 1975 ; Apostolatos et al. 1994 ; Kidder 1995 . To realise the potential of current Abbott et al. 2023 ; Abac et al. 2025a and next-generation detectors such as the Einstein Telescope and Cosmic Explorer Abac et al. 2025b ; Evans et al. 2021 , with order-of-magnitude improvements in sensitivity, demands theoretical models that accurately capture these complexities. Besides spin, recent evidence for orbital eccentricity Morras et al. 2026 ; Planas et al. 2025 ; Gupte et al. 2025 ; Kacanja et al. 2025 ; Romero-Shaw et al. 2025 ; Gamba et al. 2023 has renewed interest in non-circular waveform models. Here the orbital velocity peaks at each periastron passage, precisely where the small-velocity expansion of post-Newtonian (PN)-based models Blanchet 2014 is least reliable. PM theory offers a complementary route as a weak-field expansion in G with no restriction on velocity Khalil et al. 2022 , so each order retains full velocity dependence and resums an infinite tower of PN terms Bertotti 1956 ; Westpfahl and Goller 1979 ; Damour 2016 ; Damour 2018 ; Bern et al. 2019a . Recent developments exploiting the classical limit of quantum gravitational scattering have driven PM calculations to remarkably high orders Damour 2018 ; Bern et al. 2019a ; Driesse et al. 2025 ; Driesse et al. 2026 , through scattering amplitude methods Bern et al. 2019b ; Bern et al. 2021a , worldline effective field theory Kälin and Porto 2020a ; Dlapa et al. 2022 , and worldline quantum field theory Mogull et al. 2021 ; Driesse et al. 2025 , exploiting generalised unitarity, the double copy Bern et al. 2008 ; Bern et al. 2010 ; Bern et al. 2019b , and advanced multiloop integration Driesse et al. 2025 ; Driesse et al. 2024 ; Driesse et al. 2026 ; Dlapa et al. 2022 ; Bern et al. 2025 . These approaches give direct access to gauge-invariant observables, such as the scattering angle Damour 2016 and radial action Bern et al. 2021a , that characterise the two-body dynamics and enable cross-validation between calculations. These quantities feed directly into effective-one-body (EOB) models for bound and unbound orbits Buonanno and Damour 1999 ; Damour 2016 ; Buonanno et al. 2024a ; Buonanno et al. 2024b ; Damour et al. 2025 , transcribing high-order PM information into state-of-the-art GW waveform models. In the worldline approach, higher-order worldline operators capture spin effects on the dynamics Liu et al. 2021 ; Jakobsen et al. 2022 ; Haddad et al. 2025a . For generic spins, PM calculations employ asymptotic covariant observables, notably the momentum impulse \Delta p^{\mu} and spin kick \Delta S^{\mu} , which encode the transition between incoming and outgoing states Bern et al. 2021b ; Jakobsen et al. 2022 ; Jakobsen and Mogull 2023 ; Akpinar et al. 2025a . Remarkably, the scattering angle extracted from these asymptotic observables determines the conservative dynamics up to canonical transformations and, in suitable gauges, fixes the corresponding Hamiltonian coefficients Damour 2018 ; Kosower et al. 2019 ; Cheung et al. 2018 ; Mogull et al. 2021 ; Damour and Rettegno 2023 ; Bern et al. 2019a , including for generically oriented spins Jakobsen and Mogull 2023 . Numerical relativity (NR), on the other hand, solves the two-body problem non-perturbatively from the full Einstein field equations Bruegmann et al. 2004 ; Pretorius 2005 ; Campanelli et al. 2006 ; Baker et al. 2006 . Several studies have explored BH scattering across the non-spinning and aligned-spin sector Damour et al. 2014 ; Rettegno et al. 2023 ; Hopper et al. 2023 ; Swain et al. 2025 ; Albanesi et al. 2025 ; Long et al. 2025a ; Long et al. 2025b , focussing on the scattering angle, which is gauge invariant for planar dynamics and enables faithful comparison with analytics. Despite recent progress, direct comparisons between PM and NR in the generic-spin, non-planar regime remain a significant gap. In this Letter, we perform the first direct PM-NR scattering comparisons in the generic-spin sector. We present a systematic suite of NR simulations of precessing black-hole scattering, together with an explicit dictionary relating the covariant asymptotic observables \Delta p^{\mu} and \Delta S^{\mu} to the quantities extracted from NR. We compute the polar scattering angle in PM beyond the probe limit for the first time, and derive a simple geometric relation between the scattering angles and the orbital-plane Euler angles, providing a natural basis for boundary-to-bound maps Kälin and Porto 2020b of binaries on generic orbits. Comparing NR and PM, we find that the spin dependence of the scattering angles is captured remarkably well by the linear-in-spin PM results, with higher-order spin terms suppressed in the configurations considered here. As in the aligned-spin limit Damour and Rettegno 2023 ; Rettegno et al. 2023 ; Swain et al. 2025 ; Clark and Pratten 2025 , PM and NR demonstrate excellent agreement in the weak-field regime, which breaks down as we approach the strong field. In particular, we observe that the polar scattering angle exhibits phenomenology that is not captured by PM, pointing to the non-perturbative nature of the precessing dynamics. We use geometric units, G=c=1 , where the black hole masses are denoted by m_{i} , with i=1,2 , the total mass by M=m_{1}+m_{2} , and the spin angular momentum by {\bm{S}}_{i}=m_{i}{\bm{a}}_{i} , where {\bm{a}}_{i} is the Kerr spin parameter. Geometry of Scattering and Precession – For spins aligned or anti-aligned with the orbital angular momentum \bm{L} , black-hole scattering is planar in the CoM frame, here chosen as the xy -plane. Generic spin orientations break reflection symmetry, and, neglecting radiation reaction, only |\bm{L}| remains conserved. Spin-orbit couplings therefore change the direction of \bm{L} , and hence the scattering plane, between the ingoing and outgoing states Barker and O’Connell 1975 ; Kidder 1995 ; Apostolatos et al. 1994 . The initial and final scattering states are specified at past ( i^{-} ) and future ( i^{+} ) timelike infinity Compère et al. 2023 . At i^{-} , the relative momentum \bm{p}_{\rm in} and impact parameter \bm{b} span the initial scattering plane,

Read the complete text