A Conditional Timing Protection Level: Holdover-Limited Undetected Time Error Under GNSS Spoofing
Chakshu Baweja · 2026
Read A Conditional Timing Protection Level: Holdover-Limited Undetected Time Error Under GNSS Spoofing by Chakshu Baweja (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-24210.txt.
Introduction
Baweja measures how badly a satellite timing receiver can be fooled while insisting everything is fine. Timing receivers underpin power grids and networks. A spoofing attack can drag the served clock slowly off true time. Standard integrity monitoring looks for position faults, but a slow pull of time itself leaves no geometric fault to catch, and the receiver's accuracy flag need not notice.
Field evidence comes first. Re-solving a recorded over-the-air spoof from the public JammerTest 2024 campaign, Baweja shows a survey-grade receiver was pulled by about a millisecond of served time. Yet it reported self-assessed accuracy in the tens of nanoseconds, a claim-versus-reality gap of four orders of magnitude. An impossibility observation follows. Against an adversary choosing the ramp freely, no finite unconditional bound on undetected error exists. Baweja therefore defines a conditional Timing Protection Level, bounding error given holdover limits.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Chakshu Baweja |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.24210
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Conditional Timing Protection Level: Holdover-Limited Undetected Time Error Under GNSS Spoofing Chakshu Baweja Abstract A GNSS timing receiver under spoofing has no nominal-geometry fault to bound with position-domain receiver autonomous integrity monitoring: the threat is a slow, common-mode pull of served clock time that the receiver’s own time-accuracy flag need not reveal. We make three contributions of graded strength. First, a field measurement: solving the receiver clock-solution trajectory from the raw L1 pseudoranges, the receiver’s clean dual-band position, and broadcast ephemeris, we show that a recorded over-the-air spoof in the public JammerTest 2024 campaign pulled a survey-grade u-blox ZED-F9P by roughly 1.01 1.01 ms of served time while the receiver reported a self-assessed time accuracy of at most 51 51 ns, a claim-versus-reality gap near 2 × 10 4 2\times 10^{4} . Second, an impossibility observation: against an adversary free to choose the ramp rate, no finite unconditional bound on undetected time error exists under a single self-referential clock-aided monitor, because a ramp slow enough to keep the disciplined reference in lock-step (equivalently, below a sequential test’s reference value) is never alarmed while the integrated error grows without limit. A finite guarantee is therefore necessarily conditional . Third, the conditional bound itself: the Timing Protection Level (TPL), equal to a model-free monitor’s static detectability floor plus the oscillator’s coast uncertainty over the detection latency, holds given detection by an independent cross-satellite consistency check that a coherent spoofer does not drive in lock-step. Each term is a closed form over a primitive verified separately in the open Kshana simulator, so the sum is reproducible by hand. Calibrated on the recorded attack, the holdover budget is 114 114 ns at a one-second recovery and 458 458 ns even at a 60 60 -second coast, between 2200 2200 and 8800 8800 times below the 1.01 1.01 ms the receiver silently accepted; on this slow ramp a clock-aided sequential test alone gives essentially no protection (it alarms only after ∼ \sim 993 μ 993\,\mu s), whereas the model-free consistency monitor crosses its alarm during the spoofer’s ramp, minutes before the capture. We are explicit about the boundary: the bound is calibrated on real data but not independently validated against ground-truth field error, it carries no aviation-style integrity-risk budget, and its long-coast value is governed by the oscillator’s long-tau red-noise floor and is reported as a swept band rather than a single scalar. The simulator, the bound, and the calibration example are open source under AGPL-3.0. I Introduction Critical infrastructure increasingly takes its time from GNSS. Power grids timestamp phasor measurements, cellular base stations align frames, financial venues stamp trades, and data-center fabrics order events, all to a common clock that is, in practice, a GPS-disciplined oscillator distributed over packet networks by protocols such as IEEE 1588 PTP [ 23 , 26 , 25 , 27 ] . The same property that makes GNSS attractive, a free global time reference, makes it a single point of failure now recognised at the policy level [ 24 ] : an attacker who controls the signal controls the clock, and the feasibility of doing so over the air is well established [ 3 , 4 ] . The defensive literature is dominated by two framings that do not, on their own, protect a timing user. The first is spoofing detection : a large body of work raises an alarm when the received signal looks inauthentic, using power, correlation-peak, angle-of-arrival, or clock-consistency cues [ 2 , 3 , 5 , 7 , 8 , 9 ] . Detection answers “is something wrong?” but not “how wrong can the time be before I would have noticed?” The second is integrity , formalised for aviation as a protection level: a statistical bound on position error that, with quantified probability, is not exceeded without an alarm [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] . Protection levels are the right shape of guarantee, but the classical construction, receiver autonomous integrity monitoring (RAIM) and its advanced multi-hypothesis descendants, bounds a position error produced by anomalous ranges. A time-synchronization spoofer of the coordinated, coherent class [ 2 , 4 ] produces no such fault: it can drive every satellite coherently, hold a clean four-satellite fix, and leave the position essentially stationary while it walks the clock. A position-domain solution with a floating clock absorbs the common-mode pull entirely into the clock estimate, leaving no range residual, so position-domain T-RAIM has nothing to bound. (An authentication layer such as Galileo OSNMA [ 13 ] attacks the problem upstream, at the signal; it is complementary to, and does not replace, a receiver-side error bound.) A timing user needs a bound on the time error that can be served without detection , given the monitor in place and the oscillator on the bench. That quantity is the subject of this paper. We call it the Timing Protection Level (TPL), and we make three contributions of graded strength. First, a field measurement of the gap (Section III ). Using a recorded over-the-air spoof from JammerTest 2024 [ 1 ] , we solve the receiver clock-solution trajectory from raw pseudoranges and show a real \sim 1.01 ms pull of served time while the receiver’s own reported time accuracy stayed at or below 51 ns. The integrity flag was not merely optimistic; it was wrong by four orders of magnitude. This is the problem the TPL exists to address, observed in the field rather than asserted. Second, an impossibility observation (Section IV ). We show that no finite unconditional TPL exists: against an adversary free to choose the ramp rate, a sufficiently slow common-mode pull keeps the disciplined reference corrupted in lock-step and is never alarmed, so the integrated undetected error is unbounded. Any finite guarantee must be conditional, either on a detectable ramp rate or on a cross-check that does not depend on the disciplined reference. Third, the conditional bound and its real calibration (Sections IV – VII ). Given detection by a model-free cross-satellite consistency monitor, the served error is holdover-limited to the sum of the monitor’s static detectability floor and the oscillator’s coast 1-sigma over the detection latency. Each term is a closed form over a primitive verified independently: a k -sigma offset floor, a van Loan coast variance calibrated to the measured Allan deviation [ 16 , 17 ] , and a CUSUM time-to-alarm [ 18 ] . Calibrated on the recorded attack, the bound runs from 114 ns at a one-second latency to 458 ns at a 60 -second coast, between 2200 and 8800 times below the 1.01 ms. We are explicit about the limits: the bound is calibrated, not field-validated; it carries no integrity-risk-per-hour budget; and its long-coast value is reported as a band swept over the oscillator’s long-tau floor, not a single number. II Related work Spoofing feasibility and detection. The feasibility of coordinated over-the-air spoofing is established by Humphreys et al. [ 3 ] and, from the security side, by Tippenhauer et al. [ 4 ] ; Psiaki and Humphreys [ 2 ] , and the surveys of Jafarnia-Jahromi et al. [ 8 ] and Schmidt et al. [ 9 ] , catalogue the detection cues, while Akos [ 5 ]