Collaborative and AI-Supported Requirements Elicitation: An Empirical Study
Manoel Salgado Neto, Allan Araujo, Ronnie de Souza Santos · 2026
Read Collaborative and AI-Supported Requirements Elicitation: An Empirical Study by Manoel Salgado Neto, Allan Araujo, Ronnie de Souza Santos (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-24060.txt.
Introduction
Salgado Neto and co-authors test how artificial intelligence changes the earliest step of building software: gathering requirements from the people who will use it. Stakeholders must explain needs, argue over priorities, and turn discussion into documents developers can follow. Their 2026 mixed-method experiment compares four routes, from plain group discussion to a language model writing requirements directly from transcripts.
One route pairs group work with the Strateegia platform and its GPT-powered writing applet, which drafts documents from the discussion. Another hands transcripts to a language model with no live collaboration at all. Judges scored the outputs against the ISO/IEC/IEEE 29148 quality standard, and participants rated each process. Combining stakeholder discussion with AI drafting produced the highest-rated documents and felt clearer and easier to run. Salgado's team concludes that generative tools work best reshaping human discussion, not replacing it.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Manoel Salgado Neto, Allan Araujo, Ronnie de Souza Santos |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.24060
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Collaborative and AI-Supported Requirements Elicitation: An Empirical Study Manoel Salgado Neto, Allan Araujo, Ronnie de Souza Santos Abstract Requirements elicitation requires stakeholders to communicate needs, negotiate priorities, and collaboratively construct knowledge that can be transformed into software requirements artifacts. Recent advances in LLMs have created opportunities to support these activities through AI-assisted collaboration and automated artifact generation. However, limited empirical evidence is available regarding how AI-supported collaborative environments influence requirements elicitation outcomes. In this study, we conducted a mixed-method controlled experiment comparing four requirements elicitation approaches: collaborative elicitation without AI support, collaborative elicitation supported by the Strateegia platform and its GPT-powered Writer applet, direct requirements generation using a Large Language Model, and requirements generation from collaborative discussion transcripts using a Large Language Model. We evaluated the resulting artifacts using quality criteria derived from ISO/IEC/IEEE 29148 and collected participant perceptions regarding the elicitation process. Our findings indicate that approaches combining stakeholder collaboration and AI-supported synthesis produced the highest-rated requirements artifacts and were perceived as clearer and easier to execute than traditional collaborative elicitation. The results suggest that generative AI can support the transformation of collaboratively generated knowledge into structured requirements documentation while preserving the value of stakeholder participation. We discuss implications for AI-supported requirements elicitation and human-AI collaboration in Requirements Engineering. I Introduction Requirements elicitation is a common activity in software development, involving the identification, discussion, and documentation of stakeholder needs that guide subsequent design and implementation activities [ 16 , 15 ] . This process typically involves multiple stakeholders, including clients, users, developers, and managers, who may possess different goals, expertise, and perspectives regarding the system under development [ 16 , 13 ] . To support coordination among these stakeholders, collaborative platforms have been proposed as mechanisms to facilitate collective knowledge construction and stakeholder interaction. More recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have been incorporated into a variety of software engineering activities due to their ability to interpret, summarize, and generate natural language content [ 4 , 17 ] . These capabilities create opportunities to support requirements elicitation and documentation activities in collaborative environments. Despite the availability of such tools, requirements elicitation remains associated with coordination challenges among stakeholders [ 5 ] . Stakeholders may express needs using ambiguous, incomplete, or evolving language, while developers are responsible for translating these discussions into formal requirements specifications. Differences in interpretation, changing expectations, incomplete participation, and misaligned understanding may contribute to requirements documents containing ambiguities, inconsistencies, or omissions [ 5 , 14 ] . Such issues have been associated with rework, increased development effort, project delays, and software systems that do not fully address stakeholder needs [ 16 , 15 , 7 ] . Regarding potential solutions, collaborative platforms and LLM-based systems provide mechanisms that may offer relevant support for requirements elicitation activities. Collaborative environments facilitate stakeholder participation and the externalization of knowledge, while LLMs can assist in organizing, synthesizing, and transforming information generated during discussions [ 2 , 1 ] . Recent work has investigated the use of generative AI in software engineering activities, including requirements engineering [ 2 , 1 ] . However, limited empirical evidence is available regarding how AI-supported collaborative environments influence requirements elicitation outcomes. In particular, little is known about how collaboratively generated knowledge can be transformed into requirements artifacts through generative AI, or how such approaches compare with traditional collaborative elicitation and LLM-based artifact generation approaches in terms of artifact quality and participant experience [ 2 , 1 ] . To address this gap, we investigate the following research question: How does an AI-supported collaborative platform influence software requirements elicitation and the production of requirements artifacts compared with alternative elicitation approaches? To answer this question, we conducted a mixed-method controlled experiment comparing four approaches to requirements elicitation and artifact generation: collaborative elicitation without AI support, collaborative elicitation supported by the Strateegia 1 1 1 https://strateegia.digital/en platform and its GPT-powered Writer applet, direct requirements generation using a Large Language Model, and requirements generation from collaborative discussion transcripts using a Large Language Model. The study combined artifact quality assessment, participant perceptions, and qualitative observations to investigate both process and outcome differences among the approaches. This paper makes four contributions: (1) an empirical comparison of collaborative, AI-supported, and LLM-based requirements elicitation approaches, (2) an evaluation of generative AI mechanisms for transforming stakeholder discussions into requirements artifacts, (3) evidence regarding participant experiences with AI-supported collaborative elicitation, and (4) implications for the adoption of collaborative platforms and generative AI in Requirements Engineering. II Background This section provides the background necessary to understand the context of this study. We begin by discussing requirements elicitation, collaborative platforms, and the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) to support requirements engineering activities, followed by a presentation of existing tools and approaches that integrate AI into requirements-related tasks. II-A Requirements Elicitation, Collaborative Platforms, and Artificial Intelligence Requirements elicitation is a central activity in Requirements Engineering (RE), concerned with identifying, understanding, and documenting stakeholder needs, expectations, and constraints that will guide software development efforts [ 16 , 13 ] . Traditional elicitation approaches commonly rely on interviews, questionnaires, workshops, observation, and other stakeholder-centered techniques [ 14 ] . Over time, RE research and practice have increasingly emphasized collaborative approaches that promote interaction among multiple stakeholders and support the collective construction of knowledge. Methods such as Joint Application Development (JAD) and the Nominal Group Technique (NGT) encourage collective discussion, negotiation, and decision-making during elicitation activities. More recently, technology-assisted approaches have emerged, incorporating AI, Natural Language Processing (NLP), and requirements mining techniques to support parts of the elicitation process [ 11 , 2 ] . These developments reflect continued efforts to improve stakeholder participation, reduce elicitation effort, and support the production of higher-quality requirements artifacts. Collaborative digital platforms provide socio-technical environments that support collective knowledge construction and co-authoring activities. These platforms enable both synchronous and asynchronous participation, allowing stakeholders to discuss ideas, exchange perspectives, and collaboratively construct shared artifacts [ 12 ] . As an example of such environments, the collaborative platform strateegia provides structured support for stakeholder interaction through guided discussion and decision-making journeys. The platform is designed to facilitate collective reflection and knowledge construction among participants engaged in complex problem-solving activities. Recent advances in AI have expanded the capabilities available within collaborative environments. AI has evolved from symbolic and statistical approaches toward connectionist and generative models enabled by advances in deep learning and Transformer-based architectures [ 10 , 17 ] . Within this context, NLP has enabled the development of Large Language Models (LLMs) capable of interpreting, generating, summarizing, and transforming textual information in context [ 4 ] . Recent studies suggest that these models can support requirements-related activities such as requirements elicitation, information extraction, requirements interpretation, requirements formalization, quality analysis, and artifact generation [ 11 , 2 , 1 ] . The integration of LLMs into requirements engineering has motivated the development of human-AI collaboration approaches in which AI assists analysts and stakeholders throughout elicitation, analysis, specification, and validation activities [ 1 , 2 ] . Following this trend, strateegia incorporates the Writer applet, which uses GPT-4.1 and GPT-4.1 Mini models to support text generation and knowledge synthesis from participant contributions. Such capabilities illustrate how collaborative environments can integrate generative AI mechanisms to assist participants during knowledge-intensive activities. Despite