Totally Disconnected Semigroup Compactifications: Non-Introversion of the Full Boolean Algebra of Clopen Sets
Joshua Basman Monterrubio, Thomas Czyzowicz, Ross Stokke, Emily Thevenot · 2026
Read Totally Disconnected Semigroup Compactifications: Non-Introversion of the Full Boolean Algebra of Clopen Sets by Joshua Basman Monterrubio, Thomas Czyzowicz, Ross Stokke, Emily Thevenot (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-23987.txt.
Introduction
Basman Monterrubio, Czyzowicz, Stokke, and Thevenot settle when the largest possible collection of clopen sets of a topological group can support a semigroup compactification, in a 2026 paper on topological algebra. Compactifications extend a group into a compact semigroup. Staying inside totally disconnected spaces requires sets that are both open and closed, clopen sets, and the key property is left introversion of the Boolean algebra they form. A predecessor paper asked whether the full algebra of all clopen sets can fail to be left introverted; no example was known.
The authors characterize left introversion of the full algebra using one clopen set and two nets. Applying it, they prove that for a locally compact, first countable, sigma compact, totally disconnected group, the full algebra is left introverted exactly when the group is compact or discrete. Hereditary properties extend the result to further classes of groups.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Joshua Basman Monterrubio, Thomas Czyzowicz, Ross Stokke, Emily Thevenot |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.23987
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Totally Disconnected Semigroup Compactifications: Non-Introversion of the Full Boolean Algebra of Clopen Sets Joshua Basman Monterrubio, Thomas Czyzowicz, Ross Stokke, Emily Thevenot Abstract In terms of the existence of a single clopen set and two related nets, we characterize when the full Boolean algebra, B ( G ) {\mathboondoxfrak B}(G) , of clopen subsets of a topological group G G is left introverted. We employ this characterization to show that when G G is a first countable, σ \sigma -compact, totally disconnected locally compact group, B ( G ) {\mathboondoxfrak B}(G) is left introverted if and only if G G is compact or discrete, thus providing a strong positive answer to a question posed in [ 10 ] . Examples of clopen sets and nets witnessing our non-introversion theorem are presented. Some hereditary properties of left introversion of B ( G ) {\mathboondoxfrak B}(G) are proved and then employed to extend our main result to other classes of topological groups. MSC codes: Primary 22A10, 22A20, 06E15, 54D35 Key words and phrases: semigroup compactification, totally disconnected locally compact group, Boolean algebra, Stone space, introversion, Arens product 1 Introduction Totally disconnected locally compact (tdlc) groups are an important class of topological groups that have been studied by many authors in a wide variety of contexts. A recent survey article on tdlc groups is [ 4 ] ; also see [ 2 , 3 , 7 , 11 ] . Semigroup compactification theory has meanwhile served as a fundamental tool in the study of topological groups and semigroups, e.g., see [ 1 , 9 ] . Motivated by the desire to remain within the class of totally disconnected spaces when studying the semigroup compactifications of a totally disconnected group, the authors of [ 10 ] introduced definitions of left/right introversion of a Boolean algebra, {\cal{B}} , of clopen subsets of a topological group G and left/right Arens products on the associated Stone space, \nu_{\cal{B}}G , with respect to which \nu_{\cal{B}}G is a totally disconnected (right/left topological) semigroup compactification of G . Moreover, every totally disconnected semigroup compactification of G is equivalent to \nu_{\cal{B}}G , with left Arens product, for a unique left introverted Boolean algebra of clopen subsets of G [ 10 , Theorem 3.3] . The universal totally disconnected right topological semigroup, universal semitopological semigroup, and universal topological group compactifications of G , \nu_{LMC}G , \nu_{WAP}G and \nu_{AP}G , respectively, were described in [ 10 ] by their associated Boolean algebras of clopen subsets of G , {\cal{B}}^{LMC} , {\cal{B}}^{WAP} and {\cal{B}}^{AP} , respectively. To help motivate the theory developed in [ 10 ] , the referee of that paper suggested that the authors should aim to find an example of a topological group G for which the universal totally disconnected compactification of G , \nu_{\mathboondoxfrak B}G , is not equivalent to the universal semigroup compactification of G , \nu_{LMC}G [ 10 , Theorem 4.1] . The referee was thus asking for an example of G for which {\mathboondoxfrak B} , the full Boolean algebra of clopen subsets of G , is strictly larger than {\cal{B}}^{LMC} ; equivalently, the referee was looking for an example of G for which {\mathboondoxfrak B} is not left introverted. Not knowing of an example, the authors posed this as part of Question 3 on p. 324 of [ 10 ] . The purpose of this note is to provide a strong positive answer to this question: among other results, we will show that whenever G is a first countable (equivalently metrizable), \sigma -compact tdlc group, {\mathboondoxfrak B} is not left introverted when G is nondiscrete and noncompact (and conversely). It should be noted, however, that if G is any tdlc group (more generally a non-Archimedean topological group), the totally disconnected semigroup compactifications determined by the left introverted Boolean algebras of clopen sets, \Omega (the open coset ring of G ), {\cal{B}}^{WAP} , {\cal{B}}^{LUC} and {\cal{B}}^{LMC} , as defined in [ 10 ] , are all topologist’s compactifications in the sense that their associated compactification homomorphisms are homeomorphisms onto their images [ 10 , Corollary 4.15] ; that is, though they may be properly contained in {\mathboondoxfrak B} , each of the left introverted Boolean algebras \Omega , {\cal{B}}^{WAP} , {\cal{B}}^{LUC} and {\cal{B}}^{LMC} contain sufficiently many clopen sets to yield topologist’s compactifications of tdlc groups. Let X be a (always Hausdorff) topological space. We let {\mathboondoxfrak B}(X) , or just {\mathboondoxfrak B} , denote the full Boolean algebra of all clopen subsets of X . If {\cal{B}} is any Boolean algebra of clopen subsets of X , \nu_{\mathcal{B}}X is its Stone space: this is the set of all {\cal{B}} -ultrafilters, which becomes a compact, zero-dimensional Hausdorff space with respect to the topology determined by the sets \lambda_{\cal{B}}(B)=\{{\mathcal{U}}\in\nu_{\mathcal{B}}X:B\in{\mathcal{U}}\}\quad(B\in{\cal{B}}) as an open basis. By the Stone representation theorem, \{\lambda_{\cal{B}}(B):B\in{\cal{B}}\} is precisely the set of clopen subsets of \nu_{\mathcal{B}}X and B\mapsto\lambda_{\cal{B}}(B) is a Boolean algebra isomorphism of {\cal{B}} onto {\mathboondoxfrak B}(\nu_{\mathcal{B}}X) . Letting \nu_{\mathcal{B}}(x) denote the fixed {\cal{B}} -ultrafilter at x in X , the pair (\nu_{\mathcal{B}}X,\nu_{\mathcal{B}}) is a zero-dimensional compactification of X , and is a topologist’s compactification of X exactly when X is zero-dimensional and {\cal{B}} is an open basis for X . Every zero-dimensional compactification of X is equivalent to (\nu_{\mathcal{B}}X,\nu_{\mathcal{B}}) for a unique Boolean algebra of clopen sets {\cal{B}} [ 10 , Proposition 2.3] . For x\in X and B\in{\cal{B}} , it is helpful to note that x\in B,\ B\in\nu_{\mathcal{B}}(x)\text{ and }\nu_{\mathcal{B}}(x)\in\lambda_{\cal{B}}(B)\text{ are equivalent statements.} The reader is referred to Sections 3.2 and 4.7 of [ 8 ] , and Section 2 of [ 10 ] , for additional definitions and details. Assume now that G is a (Hausdorff) topological group. For a subset B of G and s\in G , let B\cdot s=s^{-1}B and s\cdot B=Bs^{-1} . If {\cal{B}} is a G -invariant Boolean subalgebra of {\mathboondoxfrak B}(G) and {\mathcal{V}}\in\nu_{\mathcal{B}}G , we let {\mathcal{V}}\cdot B=\{s\in G:B\cdot s\in{\mathcal{V}}\}\quad\text{ and }\quad B\cdot{\mathcal{V}}=\{s\in G:s\cdot B\in{\mathcal{V}}\}, and say that {\cal{B}} is left (respectively right ) introverted if {\mathcal{V}}\cdot B\in{\cal{B}} (respectively B\cdot{\mathcal{V}}\in{\cal{B}} ) for every {\mathcal{V}}\in\nu_{\mathcal{B}}G and B\in{\cal{B}} . When {\cal{B}} is left (respectively right) introverted, (\nu_{\mathcal{B}}G,\nu_{\mathcal{B}}) becomes a totally disconnected right (left) topological semigroup compactification of G with respect its left (right) Arens product defined by {\mathcal{U}}{\scriptscriptstyle\square}{\mathcal{V}}=\{B\in{\cal{B}}:{\mathcal{V}}\cdot B\in{\mathcal{U}}\}\quad\text{(respectively }{\mathcal{U}}\diamond{\mathcal{V}}=\{B\in{\cal{B}}:B\cdot{\mathcal{U}}\in{\mathcal{V}}\}). Moreover, every totally disconnected right topological semigroup compactification of G is equivalent, as a semigroup compactification, to (\nu_{\mathcal{B}}G,\nu_{\mathcal{B}}) for some left introverted Boolean subalgebra {\cal{B}} of {\mathboondoxfrak B}(G) [ 10 , Theorem 3.3] . Additional details, definitions, references, and motivation for these notions can be found in [ 10 ] . 2 Non-introversion theorems and examples Proposition 2.1 . Suppose that B is a clopen subset of a topological group G for which (N B ): there are nets (a_{\gamma})_{\gamma\in\Gamma} in B and (c_{\kappa})_{\kappa\in K} in G such that \lim c_{\kappa}=e_{G} , and for each \kappa in K there is some \gamma_{\kappa} in \Gamma such that c_{\kappa}a_{\gamma}\notin B for \gamma\geq\gamma_{\kappa} . If {\cal{B}} is any G -invariant Boolean algebra of clopen sets containing B , then there exists some {\mathcal{V}} in \nu_{\mathcal{B}}G such that {\mathcal{V}}\cdot B is not open. Thus, any Boolean algebra of clopen sets containing B is not left introverted. Proof. Let {\cal{B}} be a