The Measurable Majority

Lawrence S. Moss †, Arthur Paul Pedersen ‡ ⁣ ∗ {}^{\ddagger\,\ast} · 2026

Read The Measurable Majority by Lawrence S. Moss †, Arthur Paul Pedersen ‡ ⁣ ∗ {}^{\ddagger\,\ast} (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-23853.txt.

Introduction

Moss and Pedersen give an exact account of when qualitative majority judgments can be backed by numbers, in a 2026 paper on logic and social choice. Phrases like most and more likely than not sit between pure rankings and full probabilities. The authors study social decision frames: finite sets of voters with designated families of coalitions counted as strict majorities. When can such verdicts be represented by a finitely additive measure, a consistent assignment of weights?

They identify a coherence criterion, stated purely in terms of the frame's structure, and prove it characterizes representability exactly. A minimal natural logic for strict majority reasoning is also shown sound and complete. The framework corrects a classical representation theorem of Patrick Suppes, and yields a May type characterization of strict majority rule.

Catalog record

CREATORLawrence S. Moss †, Arthur Paul Pedersen ‡ ⁣ ∗ {}^{\ddagger\,\ast}
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE91 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.23853

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Measurable Majority Thanks: ( ∗ \ast ) The authors are grateful to Sam Alexander, Clint Davis-Stober, Michael Grossberg, Conor Mayo-Wilson, Kris Patel, Rohit Parikh, Marcus Pivato, Andrew Powell, David Schrittesser, Jack Stecher, and Max Stinchcombe, as well as participants of the Indiana University Logic Seminar , for valuable comments and discussion on the subject matter of this paper. Lawrence S. Moss †, Arthur Paul Pedersen ‡ ⁣ ∗ {}^{\ddagger\,\ast} Abstract . This paper studies strict majority reasoning in finite electorates using social decision frames : finite sets of voters equipped with distinguished families of coalitions interpreted as those voting blocs evaluated to form a strict majority. A coherence criterion for qualitative majority judgments is identified and shown to give an exact characterization for representability of strict majorities by finitely additive measures. In addition, a minimal natural logic for reasoning about strict majorities is shown to be sound and complete. These developments motivate examination of associated combinatorial questions concerning incoherence in finite families of sets; partial results and a conjecture are given. Finally, the results of this paper are applied to correct a classical representation theorem for weak qualitative probability structures due to Patrick Suppes and to establish a May-type characterization for ordinary strict majority rule for social decision frames. mathx”30 mathx”38 1. Introduction Expressions such as most , more likely than not , and the majority of occupy a central place in everyday and scientific reasoning. Still, even as they arise naturally across logic, probability theory, and social choice, their formal treatment has been limited. Majority statements are weaker than full probabilistic assertions, yet stronger than purely ordinal or comparative claims, occupying an intermediate position that complicates standard representation results. They invite numerical interpretation, but do not obviously require it. This paper studies strict majority reasoning in finite settings . We introduce social decision frames : finite structures consisting of a universe together with a distinguished family of subsets interpreted as those propositions that count as holding “for most.” The problem we address is to identify formal conditions under which such qualitative majority judgments admit representation by a finitely additive measure, and when they do not. Our focus on finiteness is deliberate: many of the phenomena we isolate arise only from finite combinatorial structures rather than from infinitary or measure‑theoretic considerations. While other foundational treatments approach problems of representability by relaxing mathematical requirements built into standard orthodox doctrine — such as dropping Archimedean, commensurability, or even binary comparability conditions ( 20 ; 17 ) — the present analysis focuses on recovering elements of standard machinery. Our main contributions in this paper are twofold. One of them is the identification of a formal criterion of coherence that exactly characterizes representability. Coherence is formulated entirely in terms of the frame structure itself, without reference to numbers or measures, yet it is shown to be equivalent to the existence of a finitely additive measure that represents strict majority. Our formal criterion is reminiscent of classical coherence principles in the foundations of probability, most notably those associated with 2 , 9 , and 21 , but it applies directly to majority judgments rather than to comparative or numerical probabilities. In this sense, measurability emerges as a structural property of majority reasoning rather than as a primitive assumption. This orientation treats representability not as an unexamined convention, but as a problem of formal coordination and measurement validity, whereby the scale type of a qualitative attribute is determined by abstract requirements that the attribute’s measurement imposes on its representation ( 19 ) . One motivation for isolating such a condition comes from an analysis of work in qualitative probability that treats “more likely than not” as a primitive notion related to judgments of certainty. The apparent simplicity of this setting suggests that a correspondingly simple axiomatization might suffice to characterize measurability. 22 states such a representation result connecting these judgments to probability measures. That result, however, is false, as we show. Even in the finite case, the axioms given do not suffice to guarantee representability: they might be satisfied while no representing measure exists. The obstruction lies not in infinitary effects or technical subtleties of measure theory, but in finite combinatorial configurations. Drawing on lessons from 9 , coherence precisely rules out these configurations. A second source of motivation comes from social choice theory. Strict majority rule enjoys powerful characterization results under symmetry and neutrality assumptions, most notably in May’s theorem. From this perspective, majority rule is not merely a convenient aggregation procedure but a structurally distinguished one. Our framework clarifies this point. Under a natural symmetry condition — requiring invariance under permutations of the underlying universe —every coherent frame collapses to the standard strict majority rule. This yields a May-type characterization result within the present setting and helps to isolate the assumptions that distinguish majority rule from alternative aggregation mechanisms. Our second main contribution is logical. Building on the coherence characterization, we develop a simple term logic designed to capture statements of the form “most of everything is an X ,” together with Boolean operations at both the predicate and sentence levels. In this respect, the system aligns with the core objective of the natural logic program: to isolate low-complexity, decidable fragments of natural language reasoning that bypass the full machinery of standard first-order logic ( 14 ; 13 ) . To give some sense of the kind of reasoning can be captured in this logic, let us consider an example. Suppose a society has six important voting blocs: non-high-school graduates (NHS), women (W), suburban or rural (SR), church attendees (C), fiscal conservatives (FC), and social liberals (SL). Each of these blocs can claim at least half of the voters. At the same time, everyone belongs to at most three of these blocs. Our logic incorporates a coherence axiom entailing under the foregoing assumptions that each bloc must contain exactly half of the voters and that everyone must belong to exactly three of the six blocs. See 4.1 . Our logic is the smallest one which includes coherence axioms like this. The semantics of the logic is given by frames, and its axioms are directly motivated by coherence. We prove that our logic is sound and complete with respect to measurable frames. Unlike earlier work on majority logics that relies on infinite models, our completeness result is obtained entirely in the finite setting and yields the finite model property and decidability. Finally, the paper opens a line of combinatorial investigation. Coherence is an infinite scheme, and we show that it cannot be reduced to any small finite fragment in a straightforward way. To analyze failures of measurability, we introduce the notion of an incoherence index , measuring the minimal complexity of incoherent configurations, and we derive partial results and conjectures linking coherence to extremal problems concerning balanced families of sets. Taken together, the results of this paper give a unified account of strict majority reasoning in finite settings, clarifying its measure-theoretic foundations, its logical structure, and its combinatorial limits. The rest of this paper is organized as follows. Section 2 introduces social decision frames and their measurability, examining their connection to weak qualitative probabilities; Section 3 formulates the coherence criterion and derives its main

Read the complete text