GalSBI: Forward Modelling Galaxy Clustering and Population

Alexandre Refregier · 2026

Read GalSBI: Forward Modelling Galaxy Clustering and Population by Alexandre Refregier (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-23783.txt.

Introduction

Refregier extends the GalSBI forward model so it can simulate galaxy populations and their clustering together, in a 2026 paper on cosmology. A forward model builds fake survey images that carry the same selection effects as real data. GalSBI now assigns galaxies to dark matter subhalos with an efficient optimal transport scheme. Simulation based inference fits the model by comparing the fake images with Dark Energy Survey data.

The fake galaxies match real ones in brightness and shape across data of different depths. Their clustering agrees across brightness and color cuts. Redshift estimates match precise photo based values, with means agreeing within the stated errors. The galaxy brightness spread and the galaxy halo link also match earlier work.

Catalog record

CREATORAlexandre Refregier
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE71 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.23783

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

GalSBI: Forward Modelling Galaxy Clustering and Population Alexandre Refregier Abstract Forward modelling is a powerful approach for analyzing large-scale structure surveys. For this purpose, we extend the GalSBI framework to jointly model the galaxy population and clustering using an efficient subhalo abundance matching scheme based on optimal transport. We use simulation-based inference to constrain the model parameters by comparing UFig image simulations with DES Y3 imaging data. As a validation, we find that galaxy photometry and morphology agree well with multi-band imaging data of different depths, namely DES and HSC deep fields. Galaxy clustering for simulation and data is also in good agreement when comparing the angular power spectrum for different magnitude and color cuts. We further compare simulated redshift distributions against high-precision photometric redshifts in HSC deep field imaging of the COSMOS field. We find the redshift distributions across magnitude cuts to be similar to previous work, however with more realistic uncertainty modelling due to the addition of clustering contribution to sample variance. The agreement of the mean redshifts with data is very good, between 0.2 ​ σ 0.2\sigma and 1.6 ​ σ 1.6\sigma for different magnitude cuts, with sample variance being the dominant uncertainty contributor in bright samples ( < 24 <24 mag) and subdominant compared to galaxy population model uncertainty in fainter samples. As a byproduct we measure the galaxy luminosity function and galaxy-halo connection, which are broadly consistent with existing literature. The updated GalSBI code and galaxy population model are publicly available. They enable accurate forward-modelled image simulations with realistic clustering, which can be used to model the effect of sample variance, source clustering, redshift distributions, and blending in large-scale-structure surveys. This makes GalSBI a powerful tool for the analysis of current and next-generation cosmological galaxy surveys. 1 1 footnotetext: Corresponding author. 1 Introduction Since its first detection at the beginning of the century [ 11 , 73 , 126 , 132 ] , weak gravitational lensing has been demonstrated to be a powerful cosmological probe. Its constraining power can be further enhanced through the combination with galaxy clustering, typically referred to as 3\times 2 pt analysis. This combination further breaks parameter degeneracies and improves cosmological constraints thanks to their sensitivity to complementary systematic effects [ 34 , 66 , 88 , 108 ] . Currently, Stage-III surveys such as the Dark Energy Survey [ 36 , DES,] , the Kilo-Degree Survey [ 37 , KiDS,] , and the Hyper Suprime-Cam Subaru Strategic Program [ 3 , HSC,] are publishing their final cosmological constraints while Stage-IV surveys, such as the Vera Rubin Observatory’s Legacy Survey of Space and Time [ 113 , Rubin-LSST,] , Euclid [ 76 ] , and the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope [ 104 , NGRST,] , have started or will soon start to take their first data. The increased statistical power of these surveys will place even more stringent requirements on systematic uncertainties, demanding improvements in both accuracy and precision. An increasingly popular approach to achieve these improvements is forward modelling. The core idea is to generate synthetic observations that are subject to the same systematic effects and selections as the real data. This approach requires two main ingredients: a galaxy population model from which intrinsic properties can be sampled, and a model of the transfer function from intrinsic to observed properties. Depending on the realism of these two parts, different applications can be unlocked. One possible application is the estimation of photometric redshifts [photo- z , see e.g., 94 , 121 , for reviews] . This is one of the dominant sources of systematic uncertainties in current Stage-III surveys, where challenges with photo- z estimation affected their final cosmological analyses, ranging from biases requiring mitigation [ 35 , 81 ] , to the exclusion of redshift bins [ 40 , 34 ] , to shifts in cosmological constraints following improved calibration [ 133 , 135 ] . Forward modelling offers a complementary approach that avoids the need to correct for selection effects in spectroscopic calibration samples. By generating synthetic observations to which the same selection is applied as to the real data, it directly yields the ensemble redshift distribution without requiring a separate calibration step. To do this, the galaxy population model and transfer function have to accurately model all galaxy properties relevant for the sample selection, at minimum the broadband magnitudes. If the population model further includes morphology, the transfer function can be realistically modelled with image simulations, which additionally enables shear calibration [ 26 ] . Adding realistic galaxy clustering then unlocks a further set of applications: it allows quantification of sample variance when calibrating on small fields such as COSMOS, and combined with image simulations it improves blending calibration [see 86 , and references therein] since blending is more likely in overdense regions. Clustering of source galaxies is furthermore a systematic effect in weak lensing itself. While it is negligible for standard 2-point analyses in Stage-III [ 74 ] , it already affects higher-order statistics [ 56 ] and will become more important for Stage-IV. Taken together, a forward model that jointly describes photometry, morphology and spatial positions opens the door to a fully self-consistent 3\times 2 pt analysis. Several frameworks have been developed along these lines with different modelling choices. Our GalSBI model [ 51 , hereafter 51 ] [ 119 ] consists of a parametric description of the galaxy population and image simulations for the transfer function; it is described in detail below. A similar parametric approach but with a data-driven noise model was used in [ 8 , 77 ] . Later work replaced the population model with a diffusion model [ 9 , pop-cosmos, ] trained on COSMOS2020 catalog data [ 130 ] , further enabling individual photo- z and physical property inference [ 115 , 116 , 39 ] . The model was recently adapted to KiDS-1000 data [ 78 , 61 ] calibrating their noise model on SKiLLS image simulations [ 80 ] , with an architecture consisting of a detection classifier and a conditional ODE flow, conceptually similar to the emulator developed in 51 . A complementary SPS-based forward model, PROVABGS, jointly fits photometry and spectra for the DESI Bright Galaxy Survey galaxies [ 60 , 59 ] , providing full posterior distributions of physical properties for over 10 million galaxies via a neural-emulator-accelerated SPS model and enabling downstream hierarchical population inference [ 79 ] . A further forward modelling example is the Diffsky framework, built from fully differentiable models for stellar population synthesis [ 62 ] , halo mass assembly [ 63 ] , galaxy assembly history [ 5 ] , and the star formation history [ 4 ] . GalSBI builds on a series of work on forward modelling galaxy surveys, first proposed in [ 99 ] . The galaxy population model uses parametric descriptions of observed statistical quantities such as the luminosity function, and the transfer function is applied using image simulations with the ultra-fast image generator UFig [ 15 , 53 ] or spectra simulations using USpec [ 47 , 48 , 84 ] . The galaxy population model parametrization has been progressively improved [ 64 , 92 , 51 ] , and applied to multiple

Read the complete text