The EDGE-CALIFA Survey: Star Formation Efficiency and Galaxy Quenching across 62 Main Sequence, Green Valley, and Red Galaxies
Yu-Hsuan Teng, Alberto D. Bolatto, Peter J. Teuben, Erik Rosolowsky, David T. Frayer, Amanda A. Kepley, Sebastian F. Sanchez, Tony Wong, Adam K. Leroy, Dario Colombo, Serena A. Cronin, K. Decker French, Veselina Kalinova, Rebecca C. Levy, Karin M. Sandstrom, Vicente Villanueva, Jorge K. Barrera-Ballesteros, Zein Bazzi, Yixian Cao, Alex Green, Rodrigo Herrera-Camus, Eduardo A. D. Lacerda, Jialu Li, Alejandra Z. Lugo-Aranda, Jocabed Martinez-Lopez, Elizabeth Tarantino, Akshat Tripathi, Carolyn G. Volpert, Di Wen · 2026
Read The EDGE-CALIFA Survey: Star Formation Efficiency and Galaxy Quenching across 62 Main Sequence, Green Valley, and Red Galaxies by Yu-Hsuan Teng, Alberto D. Bolatto, Peter J. Teuben, Erik Rosolowsky, David T. Frayer, Amanda A. Kepley, Sebastian F. Sanchez, Tony Wong, Adam K. Leroy, Dario Colombo, Serena A. Cronin, K. Decker French, Veselina Kalinova, Rebecca C. Levy, Karin M. Sandstrom, Vicente Villanueva, Jorge K. Barrera-Ballesteros, Zein Bazzi, Yixian Cao, Alex Green, Rodrigo Herrera-Camus, Eduardo A. D. Lacerda, Jialu Li, Alejandra Z. Lugo-Aranda, Jocabed Martinez-Lopez, Elizabeth Tarantino, Akshat Tripathi, Carolyn G. Volpert, Di Wen (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-23649.txt.
Introduction
Teng and colleagues present a new radio survey of molecular gas in sixty two nearby galaxies, in a 2026 paper on galaxy evolution. Galaxies form stars from cold molecular gas, and the star forming main sequence links each galaxy's star formation rate to its mass. Galaxies below that sequence are quenching, meaning star birth is shutting down. Whether gas runs out or stops forming stars efficiently is an open question.
Using the Green Bank Telescope, the survey maps carbon monoxide emission, a tracer of molecular gas, for galaxies chosen from the CALIFA optical survey. Combining both datasets yields gas masses, star formation rates, and chemical abundances. The median gas depletion time rises steeply toward red galaxies. Crucially, quenched galaxies can hold gas reservoirs like star forming ones; they simply form stars from it far less efficiently.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yu-Hsuan Teng, Alberto D. Bolatto, Peter J. Teuben, Erik Rosolowsky, David T. Frayer, Amanda A. Kepley, Sebastian F. Sanchez, Tony Wong, Adam K. Leroy, Dario Colombo, Serena A. Cronin, K. Decker French, Veselina Kalinova, Rebecca C. Levy, Karin M. Sandstrom, Vicente Villanueva, Jorge K. Barrera-Ballesteros, Zein Bazzi, Yixian Cao, Alex Green, Rodrigo Herrera-Camus, Eduardo A. D. Lacerda, Jialu Li, Alejandra Z. Lugo-Aranda, Jocabed Martinez-Lopez, Elizabeth Tarantino, Akshat Tripathi, Carolyn G. Volpert, Di Wen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 100 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.23649
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The EDGE-CALIFA Survey: Star Formation Efficiency and Galaxy Quenching across 62 Main Sequence, Green Valley, and Red Galaxies Facilities: GBT spectral-cube ( 41 ) , matplotlib ( 48 ) , numpy ( 46 ) , scipy ( 128 ) , astropy ( 6 ) , ipython ( 82 ) , Pipe3D ( 108 ; 109 ) , reproject ( 89 ) , edge-pydb ( 132 ) , gbtpipe ( https://github.com/GBTSpectroscopy/gbtpipe ), degas ( https://github.com/GBTSpectroscopy/degas ), GBT-EDGE ( https://github.com/teuben/GBT-EDGE ), gbt-edge-analysis ( https://github.com/ElthaTeng/gbt-edge-analysis ; https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20707910 (catalog doi:10.5281/zenodo.20707910) ) Yu-Hsuan Teng, Alberto D. Bolatto, Peter J. Teuben, Erik Rosolowsky, David T. Frayer, Amanda A. Kepley, Sebastian F. Sanchez, Tony Wong, Adam K. Leroy, Dario Colombo, Serena A. Cronin, K. Decker French, Veselina Kalinova, Rebecca C. Levy, Karin M. Sandstrom, Vicente Villanueva, Jorge K. Barrera-Ballesteros, Zein Bazzi, Yixian Cao, Alex Green, Rodrigo Herrera-Camus, Eduardo A. D. Lacerda, Jialu Li, Alejandra Z. Lugo-Aranda, Jocabed Martinez-Lopez, Elizabeth Tarantino, Akshat Tripathi, Carolyn G. Volpert, Di Wen Abstract We present GBT-EDGE, a new CO (1–0) survey using the Green Bank Telescope to map 62 nearby (10–140 Mpc) galaxies spanning the star-forming main sequence (SFMS), green valley, and red sequence. The galaxy sample is selected from the CALIFA survey with integral field spectroscopy (IFS), which provides a representative census of local galactic environments. Combining the CO dataset with CALIFA’s optical IFS measurements, we derive molecular gas masses, star formation rates (SFR), metallicities, and stellar mass densities to measure star formation efficiency (SFE) and investigate the physical drivers of galaxy quenching. We obtain a median molecular gas depletion time of 2.10 − 1.31 + 2.35 2.10^{+2.35}_{-1.31} , 6.90 − 3.67 + 17.00 6.90^{+17.00}_{-3.67} , and 127.7 − 113.4 + 201.6 127.7^{+201.6}_{-113.4} Gyr for our sample of main sequence, green valley, and red galaxies, respectively, assuming a Galactic CO-to-H 2 conversion factor. By applying various conversion factor prescriptions, we also confirm a systematic decrease of SFE with galaxy’s offset below the SFMS, regardless of the adopted prescription. This suggests that the low SFR in some quenched galaxies is primarily driven by suppressed SFE rather than an absence of molecular gas. Our results provide evidence that galaxies below the main sequence can retain substantial molecular gas reservoirs comparable to star-forming galaxies, but they exhibit longer depletion times and form stars inefficiently, possibly due to the combined effects of low gas density and morphological quenching mechanisms. show][email protected] I Introduction Galaxy evolution is driven by variations in the level of star formation activities within galaxies. Observational studies on nearby galaxies over the past two decades have confirmed a strong correlation between a galaxy’s star formation rate (SFR) and its stellar mass ( M_{\mathrm{star}} ), namely, the star formation main sequence ( 15 ; 99 ; 18 ; 93 , SFMS;) . This relation has also been found to hold for spatially resolved observations down to kpc scales, and thus the relation is sometimes expressed in terms of surface densities ( 64 ; 103 , \Sigma_{\mathrm{SFR}} and \Sigma_{\mathrm{star}} ; e.g.,) . The established SFMS relation has further led to a common galaxy classification based on the offset from the SFMS relation: main sequence (MS) galaxies are those aligned with the SFMS, red galaxies (RGs) are those falling on the “red cloud sequence” which is substantially below the SFMS (e.g., 133 ), and green valley (GV) galaxies are those in between, which implies a transitioning stage where star formation begins to shut down ( 99 ) . As a result, the offset from the SFMS (or many studies also use “specific SFR”, which is defined as sSFR \equiv SFR/ M_{\mathrm{star}} ) has been widely adopted to indicate a galaxy’s evolutionary stage in terms of its star formation level ( 94 ; 27 ; 100 , e.g.,) . To probe the reasons for the rise and fall of star formation in galaxies, it is critical to study the cold molecular interstellar medium, which is the birthplace of stars and thus determines the capacity for star formation in a galaxy. Specifically, star formation is governed by the amount of molecular gas as well as how efficiently molecular gas is converted into stars ( 51 ; 95 ) . Previous studies have revealed a roughly constant star formation efficiency (SFE \equiv SFR/ M_{\mathrm{mol}} , where M_{\mathrm{mol}} represents the molecular gas mass) in nearby MS galaxy disks, where the molecular gas depletion time ( t_{\mathrm{dep}}\equiv\mathrm{SFE}^{-1} ) is around 2 Gyr, despite variations found between galaxy centers ( 10 ; 96 ; 59 ; 124 ; 75 ; 117 ; 120 , e.g.,) . The SFE in star-forming galaxy centers is sometimes found to be higher than the value in their disks, which would enhance star formation and support central starbursts ( 124 ; 35 , e.g.,) . SFE in centers may also be lower than in the disks, which can indicate galaxy quenching due to feedback from active galactic nuclei (AGN; 78 ) or morphological quenching driven by bars or bulges ( 73 ; 97 ; 26 ; 68 ) . While these SFE estimations are known to be sensitive to the choices of SFR indicator and CO-to-H 2 conversion factor ( \alpha_{\mathrm{CO}} ; 13 ), measurements and/or prescriptions for SFR and \alpha_{\mathrm{CO}} are relatively well-developed for MS galaxies ( 121 ; 120 ; 22 ; 112 ; 119 , e.g.,) , and thus recent SFE studies are able to account for such systematic variations ( 117 ; 85 ; 120 ; 25 , e.g.,) . On the other hand, SFE across quenched galaxies, including GV galaxies, and especially RGs, remains underexplored. This is because obtaining high-quality molecular gas observations (usually via CO rotational line emission) in such environments requires significant integration time, given the sensitivity of current millimeter-wave telescopes. Therefore, current molecular gas studies are limited to a small sample of GV galaxies and tend to focus only on the transition from MS to GV rather than extending to a comparable sample of RGs. The sensitivity limitation also makes measuring accurate gas mass and \alpha_{\mathrm{CO}} even more challenging in the GV and RGs, and thus most studies on these systems still rely on assuming a constant Galactic-like \alpha_{\mathrm{CO}} value to determine molecular gas-related properties ( 4 ; 29 ; 62 ; 127 , e.g.,) . Furthermore, while both molecular gas fraction and SFE are known to play a role in galaxy quenching, there is not yet a consensus about whether one of these factors dominates, and how they might change across different galaxy evolutionary stages ( 94 ; 27 ; 16 ; 34 ; 49 ; 62 ; 79 ; 127 ) . The physical cause of a reduced molecular gas fraction or SFE in quenched galaxies is also under debate. Previous studies have found that galaxies below the MS tend to be associated with early-type morphologies (e.g., bigger bulges; 17 ) and they are more likely to host AGN ( 3 ; 56 , e.g.,) . Such structural differences can affect the local star formation processes but also complicate explanations of different quenching mechanisms. For instance, the existence of AGN could either indicate increased gas availability due to black hole accretion and its co-evolution with the galaxy ( 47 ; 130 ) , or it may lead