Reentrant superconductivity enabled by spin-orbit coupling: Application to UTe 2

Changhee Lee, Nico A. Hackner, Daniel F. Agterberg, P. M. R. Brydon · 2026

Read Reentrant superconductivity enabled by spin-orbit coupling: Application to UTe 2 by Changhee Lee, Nico A. Hackner, Daniel F. Agterberg, P. M. R. Brydon (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-23638.txt.

Introduction

Lee, Hackner, Agterberg, and Brydon propose a new explanation for superconductivity that returns as a magnetic field grows stronger, in a 2026 paper on condensed matter physics. Magnetic fields usually kill superconductivity, the zero resistance state of some materials. In a few materials the field instead revives it, a puzzle called reentrant superconductivity. The known explanations invoke field compensation or field boosted magnetic fluctuations. Neither seems able to explain the striking phase diagram of the uranium compound UTe2.

The authors show analytically that spin orbit coupling, the link between an electron's spin and its motion, can strongly enhance pairing between opposite spins at high fields. The effect works through the two sublattice sites in each unit cell, with no magnetism required. A pairing state of a specific symmetry then reproduces the directional phase diagram of the reentrant state of UTe2.

Catalog record

CREATORChanghee Lee, Nico A. Hackner, Daniel F. Agterberg, P. M. R. Brydon
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY SA
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.23638

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Reentrant superconductivity enabled by spin-orbit coupling: Application to UTe 2 Changhee Lee, Nico A. Hackner, Daniel F. Agterberg, P. M. R. Brydon Abstract Reentrant superconductivity has been understood primarily in terms of the Jaccarino-Peter field-compensation effect or from a change of the strength in the pairing interaction. However, neither mechanism appears able to entirely explain the remarkable phase diagram of UTe 2 . Here we propose a generic theory of the field-enhancement of opposite -spin Cooper pairings which does not necessitate the coexistence of magnetism or the vicinity of a magnetic quantum critical point. Our analytical treatment shows that the reentrance has its origin in the interplay of the sublattice degrees of freedom and spin-orbit coupling, which can can strikingly enhance opposite-spin Cooper pairings at strong Zeeman fields. Based on these results, we show that a pairing state with B 3 ​ u B_{3u} symmetry can reproduce the highly anisotropic phase diagram of the reentrant superconducting state of UTe 2 . I Introduction The suppression of superconductivity by magnetic fields is well established, with the Lorentz force and the Zeeman effect providing robust and universal depairing mechanisms. In a small number of superconductors, however, magnetic fields enhance the critical temperature Aoki et al. 2019 ; Llanos et al. 2026 , or even induce reentrant superconductivity Uji et al. 2001 ; Konoike et al. 2004 ; Levy et al. 2005 ; Lewin et al. 2023 ; Yang et al. 2026 . Such field-enhanced superconductivity is typically explained by one of two mechanisms. The first is the Jaccarino-Peter effect, in which an applied magnetic field compensates the internal magnetic field, resulting in a reduced net field for the conduction electrons Jaccarino and Peter 1962 ; Uji et al. 2001 ; Konoike et al. 2004 . The second explanation is that the applied magnetic field tunes the magnetic fluctuations responsible for the pairing interaction Aoki et al. 2019 ; Llanos et al. 2026 ; Wu et al. 2025 ; Hattori and Tsunetsugu 2013 . A spectacular example of this physics occurs in UTe 2 . This material displays several superconducting phases under magnetic fields at ambient pressure ( Ran et al. 2019 ; Lewin et al. 2023 ) : a low-field superconducting state (SC1) which survives field strengths far exceeding the Pauli limit; a reentrant superconducting state (SC2) at magnetic field 15\,{\rm T}<H<35\,{\rm T} along the b -axis; and another reentrant superconducting state (SC3) appearing in the magnetic field-polarized state. There is growing evidence that field-enhanced magnetic fluctuations play a key role in stabilizing the SC3 state Zambra et al. 2026 ; Wu et al. 2025 . However, such enhanced fluctuations have not been associated with the SC2 phase; Indeed, under increasing pressure, SC2 has been observed to move to lower fields and become stable at zero field Vasina et al. 2025 . This phenomenology is not explicable by the usual mechanisms of field-enhanced superconductivity, suggesting another effect is at play. Motivated by the SC2 phase of UTe 2 , we propose a theory of reentrant superconductivity that does not rely on field-enhanced magnetic fluctuations or the Jaccarino-Peter effect. At the heart of our theory is a local, spin-triplet state in which quasiparticles on the two U atoms in the unit cell form a sublattice-singlet Cooper pair. Although the pairing interaction for this state originates from local inter-sublattice ferromagnetic fluctuations, it is stabilized as a weak-coupling instability by the spin-sublattice texture of the band states at the Fermi energy Shishidou et al. 2021 . We find that the interplay of the magnetic field with spin-orbit coupling can dramatically enhance the stability of this state by modifying this texture. Under rather general conditions, this leads to a pairing susceptibility that displays a pronounced peak for fields along the b -axis, as shown in Fig. 1 . We argue that the field strength at which this peak occurs is consistent with the maximum critical temperature of the SC2 phase. We note that the same pairing state has recently been suggested as an explanation for the extremely strong fluctuations observed in the high-field superconducting state Kamat et al. 2026 . Significantly, this high-pressure state evolves into the reentrant SC2 phase as the pressure is reduced Kamat et al. 2026 ; Vasina et al. 2025 . We conclude this work by discussing the potential relevance of our theory to other superconductors which display reentrant superconductivity, specifically the uranium-based ferromagnetic superconductors ( Aoki et al. 2019 ) . Figure 1: Magnetic Field-Angle superconducting phase diagram at a constant temperature T=0.005|t_{1}| obtained by using the same model as that used for Fig. 2 . The color gradient represents the pairing susceptibility \chi of an opposite-spin spin-triplet pairing channel represented by \tau_{y}s_{y} . The black dot indicates the magnetic field used to obtain Figure. 3 (b) II Microscopic model The heavy-fermion nature of UTe 2 implies that quasiparticles originating from the U 5 f orbitals must play a central role in the physics. A minimal model for the low-energy states should therefore explicitly include the sublattice degree of freedom arising from the dimer (or “rung”) of U atoms in the unit cell. The general form of such a Hamiltonian is \displaystyle h_{\vec{k}}=\varepsilon_{0,\vec{k}}\tau_{0}s_{0}+(\vec{t}_{\vec{k}}\cdot\vec{\tau})s_{0}+\tau_{z}(\vec{\alpha}_{\vec{k}}\cdot\vec{s})+\tau_{0}(\vec{B}\cdot{\vec{s}}), (1) where the \tau_{\mu} matrices act on the U sublattices A and B , while s_{\mu} denotes the spin Pauli matrices. The last term is the Zeeman coupling. Since inversion exchanges the sublattices, i.e. {\cal P}=\tau_{x} , the two intersublattice hoppings t_{x,\vec{k}} and t_{y,\vec{k}} are even and odd in the wavevector, respectively. The local breaking of inversion symmetry at each sublattice site permits a staggered spin-orbit coupling (SOC) \vec{\alpha}_{\vec{k}} which is also odd in \vec{k} . Following Ref. Shishidou et al. 2021 , we consider the following tight-binding forms \displaystyle\varepsilon_{0,\vec{k}}= \displaystyle t_{1}\cos k_{x}+t_{2}\cos k_{y}-\mu, (2) \displaystyle t_{x,\vec{k}}= \displaystyle m_{0}+t_{3}\cos(k_{x}/2)\cos(k_{y}/2)\cos(k_{z}/2), (3) \displaystyle t_{y,\vec{k}}= \displaystyle t_{4}\cos(k_{x}/2)\cos(k_{y}/2)\sin(k_{z}/2), (4) \displaystyle\alpha_{x,\vec{k}}= \displaystyle\alpha_{1}\sin k_{y},\quad\alpha_{y,\vec{k}}=\alpha_{2}\sin k_{x}, (5) \displaystyle\alpha_{z,\vec{k}}= \displaystyle\alpha_{3}\sin(k_{x}/2)\sin(k_{y}/2)\sin(k_{z}/2). (6) Fitting the effective model Eq. ( 1 ) to realistic Fermi surfaces of UTe 2 typically requires that t_{x,\vec{k}} be the largest sublattice-nontrivial term Shishidou et al. 2021 ; Yu et al. 2023 ; Tei et al. 2024 ; Ando et al. 2025 . In previous investigations based on this Hamiltonian, the SOC terms are taken to be small or vanishing, but the physical justification for this simplification is unclear. To address this we consider a coherent heavy fermion state in UTe 2 that is formed from the hybridization of the U 5f orbitals with the conduction electrons. We suppose the dominance of the lowest-lying doublets from the two uranium ions of the primitive unit cell in the composition of the itinerant state. To obtain a minimal effective model for the itinerant electrons associated with those doublets, we integrate out the conduction electrons from the U 6d or Te 5p orbitals, see the End Matter for details. This yields a Hamiltonian of the form given above, and hence sheds light on the relative sizes of the various tight-binding parameters. Surprisingly, we find that f - d hybridization generates all tight-binding parameters in Eqs ( 2 )-( 6 ) except m_{0} , implying that the SOC terms are generically comparable to other sublattice-nontrivial terms; in contrast, the only sublattice-nontrivial terms generated by f - p hybridization

Read the complete text