Formalizing All Indexed Mathematics as a Benchmark for General Reasoning: Implementing Dilatations of Categories

Arnaud Mayeux · 2026

Read Formalizing All Indexed Mathematics as a Benchmark for General Reasoning: Implementing Dilatations of Categories by Arnaud Mayeux (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-03835.txt.

Introduction

Mayeux argues for formalizing all published mathematics as a living benchmark for reasoning. Math stands apart through formal rigor. Claims follow from explicit axioms by checkable steps. Interactive theorem provers support that rigor in a fully formal language. A verified, ever-updated corpus of all mathematics is the benchmark vision.

That view treats mathematics as a structured database of linked results. It raises hard questions about scale and organization of large formal libraries. A case study in categorical algebra shows the work in practice. Dilatations of categories are being formalized here. The topic extends classical localizations of categories. Readers see what one brick of the grand corpus looks like up close. The piece links a grand program to concrete daily formalization work.

Catalog record

CREATORArnaud Mayeux
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.03835

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Formalizing All Indexed Mathematics as a Benchmark for General Reasoning: Implementing Dilatations of Categories Arnaud Mayeux Abstract Formal rigor distinguishes mathematics from other disciplines, in the sense that mathematical statements are derived from explicit axioms by logically verifiable steps. Interactive theorem provers support this by expressing definitions, theorems, and proofs in a fully formal language and verifying them mechanically. We consider the benchmark problem of formalizing all published mathematics as a machine-verifiable and continuously updated corpus of mathematical knowledge. This viewpoint treats mathematics as a structured database of interdependent results and raises questions about scalability and organization of large formal libraries. As a case study, we present an ongoing formalization in categorical algebra, namely, dilatations of categories, extending classical localizations and illustrating what such an implementation looks like in practice. † † institute: University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, USA 1 Introduction This study is situated in the context of the growing interaction between mathematics and computer-assisted reasoning systems. Recent developments in interactive theorem provers have made the formal expression of definitions, theorems, and proofs in a fully formal language, and their mechanical verification, both possible and increasingly accessible in practice. In parallel, libraries such as Mathlib in the Lean theorem prover system show that substantial parts of modern mathematics are already represented in machine-checkable form. We motivate the benchmark problem of formalizing all indexed mathematics in a machine-verifiable system and maintaining it as a continuously updated formal corpus. We argue that, at a theoretical level, the program is feasible in principle, and we highlight organizational and infrastructural challenges. Within this framework, we present an ongoing case study in the formalization of categorical constructions, focusing on dilatations of categories, which extend the classical theory of localization. This serves as a concrete example of how new mathematical structures can be developed within an existing formal library. 2 Mathematics and Rigor In principle, by the very definition of mathematics, mathematics gives us results derived with absolute rigor, based on axioms. This absolute certainty makes mathematics special among sciences. In applications to other sciences, mathematics does not always guarantee truth or practical relevance; other sciences require empirical evidence, interpretations, and contextual understanding. As a pillar, mathematics must remain fully rigorous. However, we have reached a time when mathematics is vast, and sometimes errors arise due to its expansion and human imperfection in checking details. On the other hand, as anticipated a long time ago (cf. e.g. NSS56 ; Ha61 ), we now have machines able to compute the validity of a fully formalized proof 1 1 1 Theorem proving began with the Logic Theorist NSS56 , the first AI program to prove mathematical theorems. Interactive systems like LCF (Milner, 1972) Mi72 ; Mi84 , Automath (de Bruijn, 1970) Br70 , HOL (Gordon, 1981) Go87 , Coq (Coquand, Huet, 1988) CH88 , and Isabelle (Paulson, 1990) Pa90 integrated computing and formal logic for verification. Lean and Mathlib aim to scale formalization to the broader mathematical literature dM15 ; dMU21 ; Mathlib . . Theorem provers like Lean can renew the special status of mathematics regarding rigor. Theorem provers transform the verification of rigor into formal computations performed by highly reliable physical systems. As explained, we now have a way to check and verify mathematics mechanically. Currently, it is humans who must communicate with the machine and explain all the details. There is already an AI-generative tool in Lean that, in principle, can fill in the proof by itself, but, as of today, AI systems get stuck very quickly when formalizing advanced math. For instance, they get stuck on the very first lines of a random published article. Most mathematical results build on earlier ones, and formalizing a result also requires formalizing what it relies on. We refer to AH14 ; dM15 ; Bu19 ; dMU21 ; Av22 ; Av24 ; Bu24 ; Mas24 ; ACMT25 for recent surveys on Lean and theorem provers written by researchers who have long been active in this field. 3 Formalizing all Mathematics as a Benchmark We aim to develop general AI systems capable of supporting a wide range of human reasoning routines. The previous sentence is slightly informal, and it is natural to list some of these routines for clarity. Until very recently, almost all existing mathematics had been produced and verified by humans. Any system claiming to be general must be able to perform at least all basic tasks that humans can, including verifying advanced mathematical results. Thus, a general intelligent system has to contain all indexed mathematics in a formalized way. This suggests the following benchmark: formalize all published mathematics and update it in real-time. In some form, such ideas can be traced back to Boy94 ; KoRa16 . As of 2025, the main database for mathematics, MathSciNet, lists 4.5 millions publications. Whatever the estimate for the average size required to formalize a mathematical publication, these data could easily be stored in a relatively small data center. Once this is done (even partly), the integration of these data with artificial reasoning and generative methods MSH16 ; Xu25 will provide a very powerful method for mathematical research. Without full formalization of all indexed papers, current AI is not reliable enough for rigorous original mathematical research at a high level. Fully formalized mathematics is the key for developing serious AI-powered tool for mathematical research. 4 Organizing Formalization Formalizing all mathematics is very important. Improving the tool we use is important: one can only acknowledge smoother version and more user friendly one. However, once we have a theorem prover which in principle can support all of mathematics, the major difference will be if actually all of mathematics is implemented or not. This would require the involvement of mathematicians themselves, not only computer scientists 2 2 2 We already have hundreds of mathematicians involved with Lean and Mathlib, and the number of participants continues to grow. However, as of today, this still represents only a small proportion of mathematicians. . So it is crucial to make mathematicians themselves want to participate in this enterprise. Our main point here is that compatibility between versions of Lean is crucial: more mathematicians will be willing to invest time in the language if they are confident that it will not become obsolete or incompatible within a few years. The following is a list of comments on the formalization of mathematics. We make no claim of originality, as these questions arise naturally in this context. 1. As a basic principle, new formalization depends on what is already formalized, because theorems and definitions rely on previous theorems and definitions. 2. Each contributor will inherently influence what can be formalized next. 3. One would want a database for all formalized mathematics. Today, Mathlib ( http://leanprover-community.github.io/mathlib4˙docs/ ) resembles Bourbaki more than MathSciNet or zbMATH Open: a useful polished foundational selective library rather than a comprehensive catalog of mathematics. Reservoir ( http://reservoir.lean-lang.org/ ) points toward that broader vision by indexing Lean packages and repositories, tracking dependencies and compatibility, and providing searchable metadata and documentation. At present, Reservoir operates mainly at the level of projects, providing infrastructure for archiving and indexing formalization projects. To our knowledge, MathSciNet and Reservoir are not currently integrated, and there does not yet exist a unified established

Read the complete text