Certifying coherence in quantum devices under classical control
Gabriele Cobucci, Nicola D’Alessandro, Raphael Brinster, Alexander Bernal, Nikolai Wyderka, Armin Tavakoli · 2026
Read Certifying coherence in quantum devices under classical control by Gabriele Cobucci, Nicola D’Alessandro, Raphael Brinster, Alexander Bernal, Nikolai Wyderka, Armin Tavakoli (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-03699.txt.
Introduction
Cobucci and co-authors give quantum coherence a sharp meaning when hidden classical control may be at play. States that do not commute show coherence. That claim assumes the preparation device is untouched by hidden classical settings. Allowing such control yields a stronger notion of coherence. Its worth is shown through randomness certification.
A preparation device is coherent exactly when it can certify randomness in a prepare-and-measure test. Certifying coherence under hidden control becomes the core problem. A hierarchy of semidefinite programs characterizes it in full. A practical variant stays accurate while scaling to many high-dimensional states. For qubits, links to joint measurability push accuracy higher still. The toolbox covers more than one thousand qubit states. Quantum information readers get both meaning and method for this stronger coherence.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gabriele Cobucci, Nicola D’Alessandro, Raphael Brinster, Alexander Bernal, Nikolai Wyderka, Armin Tavakoli |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 73 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.03699
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Certifying coherence in quantum devices under classical control Gabriele Cobucci, Nicola D’Alessandro, Raphael Brinster, Alexander Bernal, Nikolai Wyderka, Armin Tavakoli Abstract Quantum states that do not commute exhibit coherence, but only when the device preparing them is assumed to be unaffected by classical parameters inaccessible to the experimenter. Such hidden classical control arises both in fundamental tests of quantum phenomena and in quantum information protocols that operate under limited control assumptions. Here, we address the problem of coherence certification by developing complete and practically efficient methods. First, we prove that coherence can be fully characterised through a hierarchy of semidefinite programs. Second, we introduce a practical semidefinite programming approach that achieves useful accuracy while remaining computationally efficient even for preparation devices generating many, potentially high-dimensional, quantum states. For the important special case of qubits, we further exploit conceptual connections with the theory of joint measurability to obtain highly accurate coherence characterisation that scales to more than one thousand qubits. Finally, we apply these methods to determine whether quantum channels are able to preserve coherence or are inherently coherence-breaking. Together, these results provide a powerful toolbox for analysing quantum superposition in the presence of hidden classical control. I Introduction Superposition lies at the heart of quantum theory and constitutes an essential resource for quantum science and technology. However, certifying superposition crucially depends on the assumptions made about the system. In its simplest formulation, a quantum state that is not diagonal in a chosen reference basis—representing the states accessible to classical physics—is said to be in superposition and is therefore called coherent. Quantifying, transforming, and interpreting coherence in this framework has attracted considerable research attention 1 ; 30 . This perspective, however, comes with a conceptual limitation: coherence becomes a basis-dependent notion. This raises the question of how coherence can be certified in an absolute sense, without specifying a privileged basis. Since any quantum state is diagonal in its own eigenbasis, basis-independent coherence cannot be a property of a single state but must instead arise from relations between multiple states. In particular, a set of states admits a common diagonalising basis if and only if the states commute pairwise. Consequently, non-commuting states necessarily exhibit coherence, and this has been quantified using tools from resource theory 12 . However, this too comes with a conceptual limitation: it requires us to have a complete description of the system. In other words, if some parts of an incoherent system are inaccessible to us, the parts of the states that we have access to may be non-commuting, leading us to falsely conclude that the system is coherent. The states in a given set can be viewed as on-demand outputs of a quantum preparation device. Assessing their coherence may therefore require accounting for the possible preparation mechanisms involved in their generation. As in significant areas of quantum foundations and modern quantum information protocols, this may involve inaccessible classical control parameters—traditionally referred to as hidden variables. In foundational studies, hidden variables arise in scenarios such as Bell tests 4 , quantum steering 33 , and prepare-and-measure experiments 3 . In quantum information protocols, they capture situations in which a quantum device is subject to a remote classical influence that is hidden from the user. This perspective arises naturally, for example, in entanglement-assisted classical communication 6 , in benchmarking quantum communication advantages 3 , and in quantum random number generation 22 ; 28 . Such classical parameters can stochastically modify the programming of a quantum device according to a predetermined rule. Although generating this type of classical control is comparatively inexpensive, access to it is known to significantly enhance the explanatory power of classical models (see, e.g., 2 ; 11 ). This enhancement of classical models also appears when studying coherence. Suppose an inaccessible classical parameter, \lambda , determines the basis in which a classical preparation device generates commuting states. By marginalising over \lambda , the device can simulate sets of states that appear non-commuting to the user. As an example, consider noisy preparations of the positive eigenstates of the Pauli X and Z observables, \rho_{1}=v\outerproduct{0}{0}+\frac{1-v}{2}\mathds{1} and \rho_{2}=v\outerproduct{+}{+}+\frac{1-v}{2}\mathds{1} , where \ket{+}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left(\ket{0}+\ket{1}\right) and x\in\{1,2\} labels the desired preparation \rho_{x} . These states commute only when the visibility parameter v\in[0,1] is zero. Nevertheless, a simple classical process can simulate them for a much wider range of parameters. Let \lambda\in\{1,2\} be uniformly distributed. When \lambda=1 , the device generates commuting states whose Bloch vectors are \pm\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(1,0,-1) for x=0,1 , respectively. When \lambda=2 , the device always produces the state with Bloch vector \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(1,0,1) , which trivially commutes with itself. After marginalising \lambda , the states observed by the user coincide with \{\rho_{1},\rho_{2}\} when v=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} (see Fig. 1 ). Thus, for 0<v\leq\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} , the observed states do not commute, yet they admit a classical model, which when conditioned on \lambda is based entirely on incoherent preparations. Models of this general type were recently introduced in Ref 9 , but methods to certify coherence are limited to just a few simple cases. Figure 1: Classical model simulating the non-commuting states \rho_{1}=v\outerproduct{0}{0}+\frac{1-v}{2}\mathds{1} and \rho_{2}=v\outerproduct{+}{+}+\frac{1-v}{2}\mathds{1} for v=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} , where \ket{+}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left(\ket{0}+\ket{1}\right) . A classical parameter \lambda=\{1,2\} uniformly chooses a classical device which generates commuting states whose Bloch vectors are represented in the figure. The diagonal in each box denotes the basis in which each device operates. This leads to a natural question: how can one certify that a preparation device is genuinely coherent in the presence of hidden classical parameters? In this work, we develop general and versatile methods to address this problem using relaxation techniques based on semidefinite programming 31 . We begin by proving that coherence admits a complete characterisation through a hierarchy of semidefinite programs (SDPs). Although this necessary and sufficient condition is conceptually appealing, it is less suitable for benchmarking state-of-the-art quantum preparation devices. To address the practical setting, we therefore introduce an alternative SDP condition that is sufficient for coherence and can be applied to arbitrary sets of states. This method achieves useful accuracy while remaining computationally efficient even for large numbers of preparations and for systems with Hilbert space dimensions well into the double-digit regime. For the important special case of qubit states, we further identify connections between coherence certification and results from the literature on joint measurability 14 . Exploiting these connections allows us to analyse coherence using tools originally developed for measurement compatibility. This leads to highly accurate certification for very large sets of qubits and enables analogous certification of the absence of coherence. Finally, since realistic quantum information protocols are often subjected to noisy and lossy environments, we shift our focus to the characterisation of coherence over quantum channels. We show how the tools developed here can be used to certify whether a channel is capable of preserving coherence, or whether it inevitably destroys it. This distinction leads us to the notion of coherence-breaking channels. II Preliminaries & basic results Consider a preparation device that emits a set of N quantum states, \mathcal{E}=\{\rho_{x}\}_{x=1}^{N} , where each state has dimension d . For simplicity, we have chosen the set to be of finite size but it can equally well be uncountably infinite. Our goal is to determine whether the states \mathcal{E} are coherent when we allow the preparation device