VidMsg: A Benchmark for Implicit Message Inference in Short Videos
Issar Tzachor, Michael Green, Rami Ben-Ari · 2026
Read VidMsg: A Benchmark for Implicit Message Inference in Short Videos by Issar Tzachor, Michael Green, Rami Ben-Ari (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-03635.txt.
Introduction
Tzachor, Green, and Ben-Ari benchmark whether models grasp the hidden message of short videos. Online clips carry more than visible objects and actions. Makers embed a purpose or point in the footage. VidMsg tests that implicit message skill. It holds 400 YouTube clips across nine topic areas and 52 target messages. Topics span careers, health, safety, sustainability, and lifestyle.
The build starts from messages, not clips. A language model turns each message into indirect search scenarios. Human annotators keep only clips that convey the point without stating it plainly. The main task pairs messages and clips in both directions for retrieval. A multiple-choice diagnostic adds a second test. Strong current models often fail here. The task needs pragmatic inference and fine separation of close messages. A baseline method, VidVec-Msg, improves message retrieval but leaves large headroom.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Issar Tzachor, Michael Green, Rami Ben-Ari |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY SA |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.03635
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
VidMsg: A Benchmark for Implicit Message Inference in Short Videos Issar Tzachor, Michael Green, Rami Ben-Ari Abstract Understanding short online videos involves more than identifying visible objects and actions; video makers often include an underlying message or purpose in the clip. We introduce VidMsg, a benchmark for evaluating implicit message understanding in short, internet-native video clips. VidMsg contains 400 YouTube-derived clips across 9 practical topic areas and 52 fine-grained target messages, covering domains such as career and finance, education, health and well-being, culture, safety, sustainability, and lifestyle. VidMsg is constructed through a message-first pipeline: an LLM first translates target messages into indirect search scenarios, which are used to retrieve candidate clips. Human annotators then retain clips that convey the intended message without being overly explicit. VidMsg is designed primarily for bidirectional message–clip retrieval for scalable applications such as video search and recommendation, where systems must capture holistic video understanding. In addition to retrieval, VidMsg includes a diagnostic multiple-choice QA benchmark, where models select the intended message of a clip from semantically related alternatives. Experiments with contemporary video-language and retrieval models show that strong models often fail on VidMsg, because the task requires pragmatic inference, integration of contextual cues, and discrimination among semantically close messages. We also introduce VidVec-Msg, a baseline method that improves message-oriented retrieval while leaving substantial headroom for future work. Figure 1 : VidMsg: Examples & Clip Durations Figure 2 : VidMsg: Topics and Messages 1 Introduction Understanding a video often requires looking beyond the visible objects and actions. Viewers also infer the broader message a clip is trying to communicate: the high-level proposition, attitude, or interpretation that the video encourages them to adopt. This message is distinct from a caption, which describes what is shown or said; from an actor’s intent, which concerns what a person in the scene wants; and from a topic, which provides only a coarse semantic category. A video message is instead the communicative meaning implied by the clip as a whole. This distinction is especially important for short, internet-native videos. Such clips are often consumed, searched, shared, and recommended because of the message they convey rather than their literal visual content. A user may look for videos about perseverance, body acceptance, environmental responsibility, or distrust of consumer culture even when those phrases are never spoken or shown. The relevant evidence may be distributed across visual cues, speech, text overlays, facial expressions, narrative contrast, and cultural context. For example, a clip showing a person struggling with ill-fitting clothes may communicate that discomfort with clothing should not be interpreted as a failure of one’s body, but as a mismatch between diverse bodies and standardized clothing design. Inferring this message requires pragmatic and multimodal reasoning beyond object recognition, action recognition, or surface-level captioning. Video-language benchmarks have driven substantial progress in multimodal understanding. Early and foundational datasets evaluate capabilities such as action recognition, temporal localization, video captioning, and video-text retrieval [ 14 , 11 , 44 , 12 , 42 ] . More recent benchmarks extend evaluation to causal and temporal reasoning, long-form video understanding, and multimodal large language model (MLLM) assessment [ 40 , 19 , 8 , 29 , 37 , 47 ] . These benchmarks are complementary to our goal; they primarily ask what is visible, what happened, when it happened, or why one observable event followed another. Even benchmarks targeting higher-level reasoning, such as intent-sensitive [ 40 , 19 ] or advertisement-focused evaluation [ 26 ] , do not directly isolate the general problem of inferring the implicit communicative message of everyday short video clips. We introduce VidMsg, a benchmark for implicit message understanding in real-world short video clips. VidMsg evaluates whether models can identify and retrieve videos according to what they communicate, rather than only according to what they depict. The benchmark contains 400 curated clips spanning 9 practical topic areas and 52 fine-grained target messages, including career and finance, education, health and well-being, culture, safety, sustainability, and lifestyle. These topics were selected because short videos in such domains often convey abstract advice, values, emotions, or social meanings that are not directly stated. VidMsg is designed primarily around a bidirectional message–clip retrieval setting. In a bidirectional retrieval task, a model must retrieve clips given a message query or retrieve the intended message given a clip. This setting is important for scalable applications such as search, recommendation, clustering, content analysis, and educational media discovery, where systems must represent the holistic meaning of a video in a compact embedding rather than rely only on visible entities or events. In addition to retrieval, VidMsg includes a multiple-choice question-answering (MCQ) task as a diagnostic analysis tool: given a clip, a model selects the intended message from semantically related alternatives within the same topic. This MCQ setting helps probe whether models can discriminate intended messages, under a common QA evaluation protocol. Constructing such a benchmark is challenging because direct web search often returns clips where the target message is stated explicitly in the title, speech, or text overlay. To address this, we use a message-first data collection pipeline. Starting from a target message, we generate narrative scenarios that imply the message without stating it directly. These scenarios are used to produce indirect search queries for retrieving candidate real-world clips. Candidate clips are then annotated by multiple human workers, who rate how strongly each clip conveys the target message and flag cases where the message is too explicit. We retain only clips with majority high-relevance judgments, no very-low relevance judgment, and no “too obvious” flag. This conservative filtering procedure yields a benchmark focused on relevant but non-trivial examples of implicit message understanding. Our experiments show that strong contemporary video-language and retrieval models remain far from reliable on VidMsg. Models that perform well on conventional video benchmarks often fail here because the task requires pragmatic inference, integration of weak multimodal cues, and discrimination among semantically close messages. In many cases, models may describe the surface content of a clip correctly but still select a generic or incorrect message, suggesting a gap between perceptual recognition and faithful message understanding. Finally, we introduce VidVec-Msg, a baseline method for message-oriented retrieval. Rather than treating implicit message understanding as standard captioning or video QA, VidVec-Msg builds on [ 36 ] through lightweight text-only adaptation. Specifically, we extend their approach to synthetic dense clip-storyline–message pairs, encouraging the model to identify visual and contextual cues associated with implied messages. This improves retrieval performance on VidMsg, while leaving substantial headroom for future work. Our contributions are threefold: (i) We introduce VidMsg, a benchmark for implicit message understanding in short, real-world, internet-native video clips. (ii) We target message-level video retrieval and define complementary multiple-choice and bidirectional evaluation protocols for assessing message-level comprehension. (iii) We provide a message-first data construction pipeline with human annotations of relevance and explicitness, conduct extensive model evaluations, and introduce a baseline method for message-oriented retrieval, evaluated both with and without video transcripts as inputs to MLLMs. (a) Total number of clips per topic. (b) Distribution of the number of clips per message. Figure 3 : Distribution of videos across topics and messages. 2 Related Work Action- and event-centric video benchmarks. Early video benchmarks primarily drove progress in visual recognition and event understanding.