Early Experiments on Macroscopic Quantum Tunneling
Willem den Boer · 2026
Read Early Experiments on Macroscopic Quantum Tunneling by Willem den Boer (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-02770.txt.
Introduction
den Boer revisits the first claimed sightings of macroscopic quantum tunneling. Conclusive evidence came in 1985 from Clarke, Devoret, and Martinis. Earlier groups had reported results read as tunneling sooner. The first, in 1980, grew from 1979 work at Leiden University. The experiments used low capacitance niobium point contacts. They sat in an rf SQUID configuration. Temperatures ran between 1 and 4.2 kelvin.
Theory had pointed the way earlier. Ivanchenko and Zilberman predicted tunneling in current-biased Josephson junctions in 1969. Leggett extended the idea to closed loops with a superconducting weak link in 1978. The paper looks back at the Leiden experiments in that light. It weighs how the early claims read against the later standard of proof. The history clarifies what counted as evidence for macroscopic quantum tunneling, and when.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Willem den Boer |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 25 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.02770
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Early Experiments on Macroscopic Quantum Tunneling Willem den Boer Abstract Before conclusive evidence of Macroscopic Quantum Tunneling (MQT) was published by Clarke, Devoret and Martinis in 1985 [ 9 , 14 ] , several other groups reported experimental results interpreted as MQT. The first, in chronological order, was in 1980 based on studies done at Leiden University in 1979. This paper looks back at these experiments on low capacitance Niobium point contacts in an rf-SQUID (radio-frequency Superconducting Quantum Interference Device) configuration at temperatures between 1 and 4.2 K. The research was inspired by the theoretical predictions by Ivanchenko and Zil’berman in 1969 [ 11 ] on MQT in current-biased Josephson junctions and by Leggett in 1978 [ 13 ] on MQT in closed loops with a superconducting weak link. 1 Introduction In 1985 John Clarke, Michel Devoret and John Martinis published two seminal papers [ 9 , 14 ] which provided definite proof of macroscopic quantum tunneling (MQT) and energy level quantization in superconducting circuits with Josephson tunnel junctions. Their meticulous experiments with well-defined parameters led to the Nobel prize for Physics award in 2025. Ivanchenko and Zil’berman, theoretical physicists at the Donetsk Physico-technical Institute in Ukraine, had first introduced the concept already in 1969 [ 11 ] , although not under the term Macroscopic Quantum Tunneling. In section 3 of their paper, they matter-of-factly describe quantum transitions of the phase in a current-biased Josephson junction with the so-called tilted washboard potential: “If \Theta (i.e. kT) = 0, then in the classical case the system will be found in some state with a fixed phase difference and, consequently, with V = 0. In the quantum-mechanical case the system can tunnel into a neighboring quasi-stationary state.” They proceed with the quantum analog of the Hamiltonian for the system and the probability equation of a phase slip via tunneling. Apparently, they considered this obvious, while others, including our group at Leiden, wondered about the philosophical implications of extending quantum tunneling to macroscopic systems such as electrical circuits ten million times larger than an atom. The 1985 papers from the group at the University of California in Berkeley cited several earlier experimental studies of Josephson junction circuits interpreted as evidence for MQT. Two were performed on current driven Josephson junctions, respectively on 1 \mu m 2 tunnel junctions below 100 mK [ 21 ] and on high current density junctions at 1.6 K [ 12 ] . Two others used magnetic flux controlled superconducting loops with point contacts [ 7 , 18 ] . In addition, other Ukrainian scientists performed pioneering, underreported research in this field as well, recently summarized by Turutanov [ 20 ] . The current paper recalls the early experiments at Leiden University, which were, to our knowledge, the first experimental evidence of MQT, although not conclusive. 2 Retrospective During the 1970’s research was ongoing at Leiden University on rf SQUIDs using Nb point contacts. Rudolf de Bruyn Ouboter was leading the efforts in this field. He was a professor in low temperature physics and made significant contributions in the fields of superfluid helium, cooling techniques, superconductivity and Josephson junctions. He was also a resident historian and wrote several articles about the discovery of superconductivity by Kamerlingh Onnes [ 6 , 5 ] at Leiden University. Professor de Bruyn Ouboter passed away in February 2026 at the age of 92 after a remarkable career in experimental low temperature physics. The author of this paper had the opportunity to join his group at the end of 1978, having received his engineering degree several years earlier in the dynamic group at Delft University started by professor J.E. Mooij. The graduate work in Delft involved superconducting Sn microbridges in tunable microwave cavities (this research did, unfortunately, not lead to a predicted step in the current voltage curve corresponding to the resonance frequency). I was interviewed for the postgraduate position at the Kamerlingh Onnes Laboratory by professors K.W. Taconis and R. de Bruyn Ouboter, not realizing at the time that they had led the effort to experimentally demonstrate the first dilution refrigerator allowing cooling to 220 mK [ 4 ] and later to 50 mK. This work followed de Bruyn Ouboter’s doctoral dissertation in 1961: “Thermodynamic Properties of Liquid 3 He– 4 He Mixtures” . The following is a discussion of the 1979 results at Leiden with a caveat. As an outsider in the field of superconducting quantum electronics for decades, I am not in a position to give a rigorous analysis taking into account the numerous papers which led to greatly improved understanding of macroscopic quantum phenomena. The retrospective and analysis presented here is based on the prevailing thought processes at the time in 1979, some of which were superseded by later theoretical and experimental studies. Research that occurred decades ago is not always easy to reconstruct, but the paper we published [ 7 ] gives details. What follows is a summary of the experiments based on the paper, on my notes and on my recollection. A brief analysis is also included based on our understanding and the simplest available models at the time. The original purpose of the project was to study flux transitions in rf-SQUID type devices with one weak link in the superconducting loop. Tunnel junctions based on thin film deposition and microfabrication were not available, so the focus was on Nb point contacts. The skilled workshop had ample experience making high quality devices, although reproducibility was never as good as with tunnel junctions. The samples consisted of two cylindrical blocks of Niobium separated by a thin foil and with two finely threaded holes for Niobium screws with sharpened points (figure 1). A cylindrical hole formed in the center of the two blocks formed the loop inductance. Fig1 . Sample with Nb point contacts for measurement of flux transitions (left) [ 7 ] and equivalent circuit (right), block I refers to one of two Nb blocks used (reprinted with permission from Elsevier) Both screws could be adjusted from outside the cryostat. The first one was set to obtain a suitable critical supercurrent, while the second one remained open. After recording the current-voltage characteristic of the point contact, the loop was closed by short-circuiting the second point contact. Reopening and reclosing the second point contact was used to verify that the current-voltage of the first one had not changed. The process of adjusting the first screw to get a critical supercurrent I_{c} in the right range was very delicate and sometimes frustrating. In retrospect this method seems quite primitive compared to the current state of the art in fabricating Josephson tunnel junctions with well-defined parameters. The author was responsible for performing the measurements which were initially done at 4.2 K only, already well below the critical temperature of 9.2 K for Nb. We were inspired by the theoretical papers by Ivanchenko and Zil’berman [ 11 ] and in particular Leggett [ 13 ] who suggested the possibility of MQT under the right conditions in superconducting loops with a Josephson junction. Professor Leggett, who was awarded the Nobel prize for physics in 2003 (with V.L. Ginzburg and A.A. Abrikosov) for pioneering contributions to the theory of superconductors and superfluids, passed away in