Formation of multiple dust rings and gaps in protoplanetary discs by a single migrating planet
K. M. Weiskopf, S. C. Meiners, A. Ziampras and C. P. Dullemond · 2026
Read Formation of multiple dust rings and gaps in protoplanetary discs by a single migrating planet by K. M. Weiskopf, S. C. Meiners, A. Ziampras and C. P. Dullemond (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-02734.txt.
Introduction
Weiskopf and co-authors test whether one migrating planet can carve many dust rings in a young disk. Dust structures in protoplanetary discs are widely observed. Their origin is still debated. Magnetohydrodynamics, shadows, and planet-disc interaction are rival accounts. The team runs high-resolution 2D hydrodynamic simulations. A planet migrates in a low-viscosity, radiative disc. Three equations of state are compared.
The cooling models are isothermal, constant beta-cooling, and an adaptive beta model. Dust is included in every run. Radiative transfer images are built from the dust profiles. For all cooling choices, the planet makes migration jumps. Each jump produces dust rings and gaps. Structures stay visible for at least 400 thousand years. Cooling decides the migration path and jump count. It does not change structure lifetimes. Large vortices last only about 90 thousand years on average. One planet, the results show, can open multiple gaps while migrating.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | K. M. Weiskopf, S. C. Meiners, A. Ziampras and C. P. Dullemond |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 59 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.02734
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Formation of multiple dust rings and gaps in protoplanetary discs by a single migrating planet K. M. Weiskopf, S. C. Meiners, A. Ziampras and C. P. Dullemond Abstract Context. Dust structures in protoplanetary discs have been widely observed and their creation remains an active field of research. Several possible origins have already been explored, including magneto-hydrodynamics, shadows and planets–disc interactions. Aims. The goal of this paper is to investigate whether a single migrating planet in a low-viscosity disc, including radiative processes, is capable of generating observable dust structures. We aim to examine both the lifetime of such structures and potential asymmetries within them. Methods. We perform a set of high-resolution, two-dimensional hydrodynamic simulations of migrating planets using three different equations of state: isothermal, constant β \beta -cooling and an adaptive β \beta model. Dust is included in all simulations and the resulting dust density profiles are then post-processed to create radiative transfer images. Results. For all equations of state considered, the planet undergoes one or several migration jumps, each producing dust rings and gaps. The lifetime of these structures depends on the phase of slow migration preceding and occurring between jumps, but in all cases they remain visible for at least 400 kyr. We find that cooling has a deciding effect on the migration behaviour and the number of jumps, but no measurable influence on the lifetime of the dust structures. The structures exhibit relatively few asymmetries, and large-scale vortices persist for an average of only 90 kyr. Conclusions. Our models highlight the capacity of planets to open multiple gaps while migrating, and stress the importance of a realistic cooling model. Care should be taken when interpreting and comparing such models directly to observations. II: radiative discs and observational signatures 1 Introduction The DSHARP survey ( 1 ) observed the \lambda=1.25 mm continuum and {}^{12}\mathrm{CO}\mathrm{\penalty\ J}=2-1 line emission of 20 nearby protoplanetary discs. They confirmed without a doubt, that the brightest and largest protoplanetary discs can contain visible dust rings and gaps as well as asymmetries in their dust profile. At \lambda\approx 1.25 mm, the emission is dominated by thermal radiation from millimeter-sized dust grains in the disc mid-plane, which allows the identification of disc substructures. Similar observations have also been made by ODISEA ( 42 ), exoALMA ( 66 ), MAPS ( 40 ) and the ALMA survey of the Lupus ( 2 ) and Taurus ( 26 ) star forming regions. A better understanding of the formation of these dust structures would provide deeper insight into the dynamics of the disc. In this active field of research, several different theoretical formation mechanisms for the development of substructure have been identified. Such mechanisms range from the formation of pressure bumps at the inner edge of the dead zone ( 4 ; 68 ; 16 ; 15 ; 53 ) , to spontaneous dusty rings due to the streaming instability ( 73 ; 43 ) , differential radial drift ( 23 ) , magnetic effects ( 8 ; 52 ) , or thermal instabilities ( 67 ; 65 ; 44 ) , to warps ( 62 ; 63 ) and shadow-driven structures ( 64 ; 49 ; 80 ; 76 ) . Another commonly proposed explanation is the presence of embedded planets. They launch spiral waves, due to a resonance between the planet’s gravitational potential and the epicyclic motion of the disc’s material ( 18 ; 41 ). For sufficiently high planetary masses or low disc viscosities, the excited spiral waves steepen into shocks, clearing material from the planet’s vicinity, thereby opening a gap ( 19 ; 50 ). 77 ; 36 ; 78 and 81 showed that a single non-migrating planet has the ability to open multiple gaps and studied the effects of radiative processes on gap formation. 31 (hereafter 31 ) and later 70 (hereafter 70 ), who considered higher viscosities, further investigated the migration of a single planet in an isothermal disc and discovered migration jumps, referred to as ”intermittent migration”. Those jumps were able to create dust ring and gap structures which remained visible when plotting the continuum emission at (sub)millimetre wavelengths. 32 (hereafter 32 ) continued an analysis of the migration, covering different aspect ratios, viscosities and disabling the gas self-gravity for all simulations. They also observed intermittent migration jumps, further confirming their existence. In general, planetary migration is highly dependent on the level of turbulence within the disc, typically modelled as an effective ”viscosity” with an \alpha parameter ( 61 ) . For \alpha\gtrsim 10^{-3} , planets migrate in the classical type-I and type-II regimes ( 46 ; 24 ), based on whether they can open a gap or not. Type-I migration is driven by an interplay of Lindblad and corotation torques, resulting in a rapid migration. For an Earth-sized planet this corresponds to a migration timescale of \tau_{mig}\sim 10^{5} yr ( 24 ). If the planet opens a sufficiently deep gap, clearing its corotation region, then only very few Lindblad modes are acting, which produce a negligible net torque. 24 suggest, that the planet is now coupled to the viscous evolution of the disc, since the deep gap prevents any material from entering the inner disc. On the other hand, 14 found that the planet only prevents gas from crossing the gap in its immediate vicinity, challenging the idea that the planet is coupled to the viscous evolution. This results in migration rates which differ significantly from the viscous timescale. Furthermore, 60 showed that a planet in the type-II regime might switch from inwards to outwards migration, now decoupled from the viscous evolution but migrating with a similar rate. Additionally, a planet might undergo phases of very rapid migration, which are often labelled as type-III migration ( 28 ; 56 ). In recent years, a number of studies have suggested that the disc’s viscosity takes lower values, with a median around \alpha\sim 10^{-4} ( 69 ; 13 ; 59 ) , but its value remains a topic of discussion. We further have to acknowledge, that inferring values for the viscosity from observations comes with limitations. 83 (hereafter 83 ) introduced new migration regimes in these nearly inviscid discs, which emerge for planets in a certain mass range. Hence, migration is more diverse than thought of before. As a continuation of 31 and 32 work, our goal of this paper is to investigate a single planet’s ability to open multiple gaps while including radiative processes in the disc. We tailor our setups towards modelling the outer disc, ensuring a comparability to the ALMA observations. We further analyse the lifetime and appearance of the created rings and gaps and make a statement about the structures observability. In Sect. 2 we introduce our physical model and numerical framework. We present our results in Sect. 3 and discuss them in Sect. 4 . We conclude everything in Sect. 5 . 2 PHYSICS AND NUMERICS In this section, we briefly outline the physical model and numerical setup. Our radiative cooling model is adopted from 84 , but we will provide a short summary. 2.1 Physical model We model a vertically integrated disc around a central star. The gas is assumed to be ideal with a surface density \Sigma