Beyond Self-Similarity: Reconciling X-Ray Scaling Relations in Galaxy Clusters and Groups
S. Ettori , · 2026
Read Beyond Self-Similarity: Reconciling X-Ray Scaling Relations in Galaxy Clusters and Groups by S. Ettori , (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-02719.txt.
Introduction
Ettori reconciles X-ray scaling relations for galaxy clusters and groups with two physical ingredients. Scaling relations link the thermodynamic traits of hot cluster gas. Data depart from self-similar predictions, above all at low masses. Ettori models the departures with power laws in two quantities. The gas mass fraction is one. The temperature variation across the system is the other.
An MCMC meta-analysis uses a wide set of published scaling relations. It constrains how both quantities depend on temperature and redshift. Gas fraction shows no significant evolution with cosmic time. It falls steeply as halo mass decreases. Temperature variation rises mildly with mass and redshift. Tension among relations collapses under the model. Relations in strong tension drop from 49 percent to 11 percent. The generalized form predicts slopes and evolution for several scaling laws. A new volume proxy links directly to mass with no redshift evolution.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | S. Ettori , |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.02719
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Beyond Self-Similarity: Reconciling X-Ray Scaling Relations in Galaxy Clusters and Groups S. Ettori , Abstract Context. Scaling relations hold among observed quantities that describe the thermodynamic properties of the gas in galaxy clusters and groups. However, observed data show systematic departures from the self-similar model’s baseline predictions, particularly in lower-mass systems. Aims. I show that the observed departures from self-similar predictions can be efficiently described by two physical quantities modeled with power laws. These phenomenological parameters are the gas mass fraction ( f g ∼ T f 1 E z f z f_{g}\sim T^{f_{1}}E_{z}^{f_{z}} ) and the temperature variation ( f T ∼ T t 1 E z t z f_{T}\sim T^{t_{1}}E_{z}^{t_{z}} ), which are also discussed in the context of the generalized form of the X-ray scaling laws. Methods. Using a large variety of published X-ray scaling relations, this study proceeds with an MCMC-based meta-analysis to constrain the temperature- and redshift-dependence of the meta-parameters f g f_{g} and f T f_{T} to calibrate the model. Results. These calibrations indicate that, while the gas mass fraction ( f g f_{g} ) does not show significant evolution with cosmic time ( f z = − 0.11 ± 0.03 f_{z}=-0.11\pm 0.03 ), it decreases significantly with decreasing halo mass ( f 1 = 0.50 ± 0.01 f_{1}=0.50\pm 0.01 ). On the other hand, the temperature variation ( f T f_{T} ) shows a mild positive increase with both mass and redshift ( t 1 = 0.16 ± 0.01 t_{1}=0.16\pm 0.01 ; t z = 0.12 ± 0.07 t_{z}=0.12\pm 0.07 ). Overall, modeling the departures from the self-similar model with { f g , f T } \{f_{g},f_{T}\} drastically improves predictive accuracy, reducing the number of scaling relations in > 3 σ >3\sigma ( > 5 σ >5\sigma ) tension from 49 (36) percent under the self-similar scenario to just 11 (3) percent (four and one out of 39, respectively) that might be identified for their peculiarity. By imposing a minimal relative statistical error of 3 (5) percent on the published relations, I reduce the number of relations in tension at > 3 σ >3\sigma to two (none). Moreover, the modelization through the generalized form allows me to present an extended discussion of the expected slopes and redshift evolution for several X-ray scaling laws, including the new quantity Y L G T 0 = L − 1 M g 2 T 1 / 2 Y_{LGT0}=L^{-1}M_{g}^{2}T^{1/2} , a proxy for the cluster’s volume which does not depend on f g f_{g} and f T f_{T} by construction, and is predicted to relate directly to the mass without any redshift evolution: M ∼ Y L G T 0 f g 0 f T 0 E z 0 M\sim Y_{LGT0}f_{g}^{0}f_{T}^{0}E_{z}^{0} . 1 Introduction In the self-similar model of galaxy cluster formation and evolution, the thermodynamic properties of the X-ray-emitting plasma are predicted to depend solely on the halo mass ( M ) and redshift ( z ). The model is based on a gravity-dominated scenario where clusters are essentially scaled versions of one another. It predicts specific power-law scaling relations between integrated quantities such as mass, temperature, gas mass, and luminosity. Any redshift evolution is governed by the factor E_{z}=[\Omega_{\Lambda}+\Omega_{m}(1+z)^{3}]^{0.5} , which represents the evolution of the Hubble constant with cosmological parameters \Omega_{m} and \Omega_{\Lambda} indicating the mass and dark energy densities with respect to the critical value \rho_{c} . Under this model, characteristic thermodynamic quantities within an overdensity \Delta=M_{\Delta}/(4/3\pi R_{\Delta}^{3}\rho_{c}) scale according to the mass M_{\Delta} and redshift z of the halo (see e.g. the review in 32 , 4 , 10 , the latter one hereafter referred to as E23). While the self-similar model provides a baseline, observed data show systematic departures, particularly in lower-mass systems ( 8 ; 17 ; 21 , \sim 10^{13}-10^{14}M_{\odot} ; see recent reviews in) . These deviations are attributed to non-gravitational processes such as feedback from active galactic nuclei (AGNs) and star formation, which impact the distribution of the intra-cluster medium (ICM). To account for these departures, E23 present a semi-analytic model, i(cm)z , that introduces temperature-dependent and redshift-evolving parameters (namely f_{g} and f_{T} ) to modify the ideal self-similar relations. These parameters f_{g} and f_{T} (see Sect 2.1 and 2.2 in E23) are introduced as phenomenological, but physically motivated, factors that accommodate observed departures in galaxy cluster scaling relations and can encode deviations from the self-similar model generalizing X-ray scaling relations. These (meta-)parameters we adopt and propagate through the scaling relations are: • f_{g} (Gas Mass Fraction): this parameter represents the gas mass fraction within a fixed overdensity (hereafter \Delta=500 times the critical density of the Universe at the cluster’s redshift), defined as the ratio of gas mass to the total mass ( M_{\rm g}/M ). It accounts for deviations in the gas distribution and from the “closed-box” expectation. It is expressed as a power-law dependence on temperature ( T ) and the evolution factor ( E_{z} ) in the form: f_{g}=f_{0}T^{f_{1}}E_{z}^{f_{z}}. (1) • f_{T} (Temperature Variation): this parameter describes the variation between the value of the gas temperature that should be considered and the one adopted in a scaling relation; it is described extensively in Sect. 3 and is modeled, like the gas mass fraction, with a power-law dependence: f_{T}=t_{0}T^{t_{1}}E_{z}^{t_{z}}. (2) It is worth noting that the temperature T in both equations refers to a “measured” quantity, such as the spectroscopic estimate T_{\rm sp} , and is here adopted as the reference quantity due to its intensive nature, which does not depend on any cosmological parameter. Assuming that published scaling relations reflect the intrinsic properties of the underlying galaxy group and cluster population, and thus represent different projections of the same physical quantities, we can use their best-fit values to calibrate our model and its parameters for departures from self-similarity. E23 did this against 17 observed X-ray scaling laws from various cluster samples (including Planck ESZ, eFEDS, and SZ-selected objects), and determined the following constraints for these parameters: f_{1}=0.403\pm 0.009;f_{z}=-0.004\pm 0.023;\,t_{1}=0.144\pm 0.017;t_{z}=0.349\pm 0.059 . These calibrations indicate that while the gas mass fraction f_{g} does not show significant evolution with cosmic time ( f_{z}\approx 0 ), it decreases significantly as halo mass decreases. Conversely, f_{T} shows a mild positive evolution with redshift. These parameters enable the model to accurately predict the slopes and redshift evolution of various thermodynamic quantities (such as luminosity, mass, and pressure). In the present work, I revise this calibration according to the largest set of published scaling laws and adopt a more robust MCMC analysis. To refine the constraints on the four (meta-)parameters describing the departures from self-similarity, namely \{f_{1},f_{z};t_{1},t_{z}\} (see Eqs. 1 and 2 , respectively), I use summary statistics collected from published work (see App. A.2 ) on the best-fit values of the slopes B and evolution C for a large variety of scaling relations represented by the form \log(Y)=A+B\log(X)+C\log(E_{z}). (3) The normalization A will not be considered in the present analysis, despite bringing a lot of physical information, as we highlight in E23 ( 14 ; 11 , see, for more details) , but also several systematics depending, e.g., on the selection function,