A mean-field description of strong-to-weak symmetry breaking in the monitored three-dimensional Bose-Hubbard model
Yicheng Tang, Pradip Kattel, J. H. Pixley · 2026
Read A mean-field description of strong-to-weak symmetry breaking in the monitored three-dimensional Bose-Hubbard model by Yicheng Tang, Pradip Kattel, J. H. Pixley (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-02713.txt.
Introduction
Tang and co-authors give strong-to-weak symmetry breaking a local, mean-field face. This new form of order appears in monitored and open quantum systems. Past work described it only through whole-system probes. The team builds a Gutzwiller mean-field frame for monitored bosonic lattices. It follows the measurement dynamics directly, in three spatial dimensions. The test bed is the monitored Bose-Hubbard model. The setup is simple to state but rich in behavior. Local density measurements and Lindblad-type dissipation act on it.
A local order parameter, averaged over trajectories, detects the breaking. It turns critical near the critical measurement strength. That point matches the charge-sharpening transition. Both transitions share a dynamical exponent of 2 in the dilute limit. The correlation length exponent is near 0.6 for both. A common underlying critical point is suggested. The work gives concrete predictions for future experiments on this model.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yicheng Tang, Pradip Kattel, J. H. Pixley |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 26 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.02713
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A mean-field description of strong-to-weak symmetry breaking in the monitored three-dimensional Bose-Hubbard model Yicheng Tang, Pradip Kattel, J. H. Pixley Abstract Strong-to-weak spontaneous symmetry breaking has emerged as a novel form of ordering in monitored and open quantum systems, yet its characterization has so far primarily relied on nonlocal diagnostics. Here, we develop a Gutzwiller mean-field framework for monitored bosonic lattice systems, enabling the direct simulation of stochastic measurement dynamics in three spatial dimensions. Applying this approach to the monitored Bose-Hubbard model with local density measurements and Lindbladian dissipation, we identify strong-to-weak symmetry breaking through a trajectory-averaged local order parameter. We find that this local order parameter becomes critical near the same measurement strength as the charge-sharpening transition and exhibits Lorentz invariance with a correlation-length exponent, ν ≃ 1.2 \nu\simeq 1.2 , comparable to that of the charge-sharpening transition, suggesting that the two phenomena may originate from a common underlying critical point. Our work establishes a local characterization of strong-to-weak symmetry breaking, reveals its connection to charge sharpening, and provides concrete predictions for future experiments on the monitored Bose-Hubbard model. Figure 1 : Illustration of the Bose-Hubbard model with hopping J (blue arrows) and onsite interaction U (red arrows), subject to measurement (orange dashed lines) at rate \gamma and dissipation (green wavy lines) at rate D . The system is simulated using GMFT, where the local mean-field Hamiltonian at site i (unshaded) is obtained by tracing out all other sites (shaded) and depends on the mean field \Phi_{i} defined in Eq. ( 5 ). The lower panel illustrates the interplay of measurement, Hamiltonian dynamics, and dissipation. Measurement projects the state onto a number eigenstate |n\rangle (single-color circle), destroying quantum coherence. Subsequent Hamiltonian evolution regenerates coherence (multicolored circle). In contrast to measurement and coherent dynamics, which preserve purity, dissipation generates a classical mixture and drives the system into a mixed state described by a density matrix (fuzzy multicolored circle). Spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB) provides a unified framework for understanding phases of matter, ranging from magnets, crystals, superfluids, and superconductors 27 ; 37 . Conventional SSB occurs in long-range ordered equilibrium systems or pure quantum states; the concept has since been generalized to nonequilibrium and mixed states 9 ; 3 ; 38 ; 29 ; 20 ; 24 ; 22 ; 11 ; 23 . Given a symmetry transformation U acting on the density matrix \rho , one distinguishes strong symmetry, where U\rho=e^{i\theta}\rho , from weak symmetry, where U\rho U^{\dagger}=\rho . Physically, strong symmetry implies that every state in the ensemble carries the same symmetry charge, whereas weak symmetry allows different symmetry charges to coexist 29 . A great deal of efforts has been devoted to characterizing these phases through nonlocal information-theoretic diagnostics, including purification order parameters, fidelity-based probes, conditional mutual information, charge-sector distinguishability, and learnability transitions 38 ; 29 ; 22 ; 11 ; 40 ; 23 . However, recent work has shown that for SSB, the computation of the order parameter in a non-equilibrium superconducting system can be described exactly by mean-field(MF) dynamics despite the exact quantum state remaining entangled 43 . This suggests that, at least for Abelian symmetries, entanglement may not be essential to capture mixed-state SSB orders. Motivated by these developments, an outstanding question is whether transitions between strong and weak symmetric phases can be understood within an MF framework with local order parameters. A natural setting to address this question is monitored quantum systems with conserved charges, where coherent dynamics generate charge fluctuations that are suppressed by measurements. Ultracold bosons in optical lattices, described by the Bose-Hubbard model 26 ; 7 , provide a natural experimental platform for realizing such dynamics. Quantum gas microscopes enable site-resolved measurements of local densities and have enabled studies of nonequilibrium many-body dynamics, correlation spreading, stochastic coherence dynamics 19 ; 12 ; 25 , and, most recently, strong-to-weak spontaneous symmetry breaking in a dephased Fermi gas 41 . These developments make monitored Bose-Hubbard systems a natural setting for studying charge sharpening and strong-to-weak spontaneous symmetry breaking (SWSSB) in interacting bosonic matter. In the presence of an abelian continuous symmetry, the competition between coherent dynamics and measurements gives rise to a charge-sharpening transition separating a charge-fuzzy phase with finite charge fluctuations from a charge-sharp phase with well-defined local charge 2 . Since its discovery, charge sharpening has been characterized through exact numerical simulations, analytically controlled dynamical limits, and field-theoretic approaches 2 ; 6 ; 5 ; 35 ; 32 ; 33 ; 1 ; 10 ; 21 ; 34 ; 17 . From an information perspective, the charge-sharpening transition can be viewed as a “learnability” transition: in the charge-sharp phase, measurement outcomes contain sufficient information to identify the charge sector of the system, whereas in the charge-fuzzy phase, they do not 6 ; 40 . Since the distinction between weak and strong symmetric states is intuitively tied to distinguishability of different symmetry-charge sectors, this perspective suggests a close connection between the charge sharpening and the SWSSB transitions 17 . Establishing such a connection in general would clarify the nature of SWSSB and place charge sharpening within a systematic framework of mixed-state symmetry breaking and critical phenomena. In this work, we develop a Gutzwiller mean-field (GMFT) framework for monitored interacting bosons and apply it to the three-dimensional (3D) monitored Bose-Hubbard model with local density measurements and Lindbladian dissipation. This approach naturally provides a local order parameter description of both charge sharpening and SWSSB while reducing the monitored many-body problem to self-consistent stochastic single-site dynamics. We identify a finite critical measurement rate separating a weakly symmetric charge-fuzzy phase from a strongly symmetric charge-sharp phase, both with and without dissipation. We show that the charge-sharpening transition and SWSSB occur at a close critical measurement rate with a Lorentz invariance dynamical exponent z=1 and a similar correlation-length exponent. Given ongoing advances in quantum gas microscopy, controlled dissipation, and site-resolved monitoring of ultracold atoms, our results provide concrete predictions for the observation of charge sharpening and strong-to-weak symmetry breaking in experiments on bosonic lattice systems. Figure 2 : Panels (a)–(c) show the configuration of the superfluid order parameter \Psi_{i}=|\Psi_{i}|e^{i\theta_{i}} with arrows for a single shot in the steady state t=50 with model parameter D=0 , U=J=1 , \alpha=0.2 and system size L=30 for various measurement rate \gamma . The norm |\Psi| sets the length of a single arrow, and the arrow direction is determined by the phase in the direction (\sin\theta,\cos\theta,0) . (a) \gamma=0 has broken symmetry with coherent phases \theta_{i}=\theta_{j} and \Psi_{i}=\Psi_{j} with a delta-function distribution in both variables over sites. (b) \gamma=0.1 in the weak symmetry (charge fuzzy) phase, where |\Psi_{i}|\neq 0 but with phases for each site that are randomly distributed. (c) \gamma=0.9 at criticality. To visualize the arrows, we enlarged the norm by a factor of 100 . Islands of weak symmetry at all scales occur at the criticality. Beyond the critical point \gamma>\gamma_{c} is the charge sharp (strong symmetry) phase where |\Psi_{j}|=0 as a result of each site being in a number eigenstate. (d) shows for finite \gamma , although |\Psi_{i}|\neq 0 , the averaged value \bar{|\Psi|}(t)=|\sum_{i}\Psi_{i}|/V\simeq\alpha e^{-\gamma t} decays exponentially as a result of the phase dissipation, shown as the dashed lines. (e) shows the variance of the phase evolving to