A Massive Hot-Jupiter Companion that Disfavors Giant Planet Formation Beyond the Water-Ice Line astropy ( 3 ) , dynesty ( 50 ) , jaxoplanet ( 20 ) , gaiascanlaw ( 19 ) , smplotlib ( 33 )

Eritas Yang (杨晴), Tiger Lu (陆均), Daniel A. Yahalomi (丹雅浩), Joshua N. Winn (温乔书) · 2026

Read A Massive Hot-Jupiter Companion that Disfavors Giant Planet Formation Beyond the Water-Ice Line astropy ( 3 ) , dynesty ( 50 ) , jaxoplanet ( 20 ) , gaiascanlaw ( 19 ) , smplotlib ( 33 ) by Eritas Yang (杨晴), Tiger Lu (陆均), Daniel A. Yahalomi (丹雅浩), Joshua N. Winn (温乔书) (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-02705.txt.

Introduction

Yang and co-authors find a heavy companion that limits where a hot Jupiter could have formed. KELT-20 hosts an ultra-hot Jupiter transiting an A2-type star. Astrometric accelerations and transit timing variations reveal a second body. Its mass is about 34 Jupiter masses, in the brown dwarf range. The companion's present orbit constrains the Jupiter's birthplace.

The star's water-ice line should sit near 8 to 15 astronomical units. The companion's pericenter is only a few units out. A planet formed at the ice line would cross orbits or destabilize. If the companion formed early and stayed put, tighter bounds follow. The young Jupiter must have formed within about 3.7 units to avoid crossing. Within about 1.5 units, it stays stable over the system lifetime. Formation beyond the ice line is disfavored. Inward migration after a closer birth fits better.

Catalog record

CREATOREritas Yang (杨晴), Tiger Lu (陆均), Daniel A. Yahalomi (丹雅浩), Joshua N. Winn (温乔书)
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.02705

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Massive Hot-Jupiter Companion that Disfavors Giant Planet Formation Beyond the Water-Ice Line astropy ( 3 ) , dynesty ( 50 ) , jaxoplanet ( 20 ) , gaiascanlaw ( 19 ) , smplotlib ( 33 ) Eritas Yang (杨晴), Tiger Lu (陆均), Daniel A. Yahalomi (丹雅浩), Joshua N. Winn (温乔书) Abstract We report evidence for a brown-dwarf companion with mass 34 − 11 + 30 ​ M J 34^{+30}_{-11}~M_{\rm J} in the KELT-20 system, in which an ultra-hot Jupiter transits an A2-type star. The companion’s properties are inferred from a joint analysis of astrometric accelerations and transit timing variations, and its present-day orbit imposes dynamical limits on where the hot Jupiter could have formed. Given the star’s current luminosity, the water-ice line is expected at ∼ \sim 8–15 au, but the companion’s inferred pericenter distance of a few au would lead to orbit crossing or long-term instability for any planet formed at such distances. If the companion formed early and remained near its current orbit over the system’s lifetime, the proto–hot Jupiter must have formed within ∼ \sim 3.7 au to avoid orbit crossing, and within ∼ \sim 1.5 au to remain dynamically stable over the system’s lifetime. These results disfavor formation beyond the ice line and point instead to formation at smaller orbital distances followed by inward migration. I Introduction The origin of hot Jupiters remains an open problem. One possibility is that they form in situ , near their present-day orbits, either through gravitational instability – the fragmentation of the protoplanetary disk into bound clumps ( 9 ) – or through core accretion, in which a solid core grows and accretes a massive gaseous envelope ( 41 ; 44 , e.g.,) . Although both of these in situ formation mechanisms are physically plausible ( 5 ; 8 , e.g.,) they are generally disfavored. The problem with gravitational instability at small orbital separations is that the disk is expected to be too hot and diffuse to satisfy the Toomre criterion for instability ( 53 ) . Even if the disk were massive enough to become gravitationally unstable, any fragments that form close to the star would likely be disrupted by shear before they could cool and contract ( 46 ) . Formation via core accretion faces a different challenge: forming the \sim 10\,M_{\oplus} core needed for runaway gas accretion requires both a sufficient reservoir of solids and a growth time shorter than the gas-disk lifetime. At small orbital separations, these conditions are difficult to meet ( 31 ; 13 ) . The prevailing view is therefore that most hot Jupiters form beyond the water-ice line and subsequently migrate inward to their present-day orbits ( 35 ; 7 ; 26 ; 13 ) . Disk-driven migration can transport a giant planet from beyond the ice line to the inner disk edge within the \sim Myr lifetime of the protoplanetary disk ( 25 ; 4 ; 21 , e.g.,) . Alternatively, high-eccentricity migration can occur when dynamical interactions with exterior companions excite large eccentricities that are later damped by tides, shrinking and circularizing the orbit ( 55 ; 15 ; 56 ; 6 , e.g.,) . KELT-20 b, also known as MASCARA-2 b, is an ultra-hot Jupiter transiting a 1.9 M_{\odot} A2 star with an orbital period P_{b}=3.474 days, semi-major axis a_{b}=0.054 au, radius R_{b}=1.7~R_{\rm J} , and mass upper limit m_{b}<3.4~M_{\rm J} ( 38 ; 52 ) . Its sky-projected obliquity is \lambda=3.4\pm 2.1^{\circ} , suggesting that the planetary orbit is closely aligned with the stellar spin axis ( 38 ) . With an age of 58\pm 5 Myr ( 14 ) , KELT-20 is among the youngest known hot Jupiter systems, offering an unusually early view of the processes that shape the orbits of close-in giant planets. The host star shows a significant astrometric acceleration, suggesting the presence of an additional companion. In this work, we use long-term trends in astrometric and transit timing data to confirm the presence of the distant companion and estimate its properties. Our fits favor a brown dwarf on a {\sim} few au orbit. We discuss some implications for the planet’s formation and migration history given the presence of this companion. II Data II.1 Astrometric acceleration We adopted absolute astrometry for KELT-20 from the Hipparcos-Gaia Catalog of Accelerations ( 10 ) , which places measurements from Hipparcos ( 42 ) and Gaia ( 18 ) onto a common reference frame. The catalog provides three independent estimates of the proper motion: one measured by Hipparcos, one by Gaia, and a long-term average proper motion obtained from the displacement vector that joins the Hipparcos and Gaia mean positions over their \sim 25-year baseline. KELT-20 exhibits a 7\sigma discrepancy ( \chi^{2}=62 for 2 degrees of freedom) between the Gaia proper motion and the long-term average proper motion, indicating a significant sky-projected acceleration of the star (see Figure 1 for a schematic). We interpret this acceleration as evidence for an unseen companion. Figure 1: Possible sky-projected orbit of KELT-20 induced by a companion, shown for the best-fit solution (Section II.3 ). Left: Motion of the host star between the Hipparcos and Gaia epochs (1991–2016), color-coded by time. The axes show right ascension (RA; \alpha*\equiv\alpha\cos{\delta} ) and declination (Dec; \delta ), with the origin at the center of mass. Right: Illustration of proper-motion vectors from Hipparcos (blue), Gaia (orange), and Hipparcos–Gaia (HG; red). The HG vector points along the displacement vector between Hipparcos and Gaia epochs (gray dashed line). It is much shorter than the others because it is based on the net displacement over \sim 25 years, during which the star completed several orbits and returned to nearly its original position as shown in the left panel. II.2 Transit timing variations In the presence of a long-period massive companion, the center of mass of the star and hot Jupiter accelerates, leading to a gradual change in the observed interval between successive transits due to the changing light-travel-time (the Rømer effect). We analyzed the transit timing variations (TTVs) to seek such a signal and to further constrain the properties of the unseen companion. We used observations from the Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS; 48 ), which captured 44 transits of KELT-20 b between 2019 and 2024. We retrieved the SPOC PDCSAP TESS light curves from MAST using lightkurve 1 1 1 https://github.com/lightkurve/lightkurve ( 34 ) and processed them with the code presented by 27 . In brief, for each sector, we retained only the data within 1.5 transit durations of each expected transit midpoint. We discarded transits with insufficient in-transit or out-of-transit coverage. Each remaining transit was locally detrended by fitting the out-of-transit data with a polynomial of degree 1–3, selected by the Bayesian Information Criterion. We then fit the phase-folded light curve with the analytic transit model of 39 to determine the transit-shape parameters for each sector. Individual transits were subsequently fit with these shape parameters fixed, allowing only the mid-transit time and the parameters of a linear detrending function to vary. Transits for which the best-fit model had an excessively high \chi^{2} ( p<0.01 ) were disregarded. Figure 2: Individual detrended transit light curves of KELT-20 b observed by TESS. Each row shows a representative detrended

Read the complete text