Inverse energy transfer in decaying MHD turbulence: A shell-to-shell analysis Preprint: APS/123-QED
Lenard Kasselmann, Philipp Grete, Pranjal Trivedi, Marcus Brüggen, Robi Banerjee · 2026
Read Inverse energy transfer in decaying MHD turbulence: A shell-to-shell analysis Preprint: APS/123-QED by Lenard Kasselmann, Philipp Grete, Pranjal Trivedi, Marcus Brüggen, Robi Banerjee (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-02617.txt.
Introduction
Kasselmann and co-authors dissect how energy moves to large scales in decaying plasma turbulence. In magnetohydrodynamic turbulence, energy can flow from small scales to large ones. This inverse transfer lacks a settled mechanism. Shell-to-shell transfer functions trace the flow. The team computes them for both magnetic and kinetic reservoirs.
Large magnetic scales draw energy directly from the integral scale. The transfer grows more non-local for larger receiving scales. Each scale's energy gain rate is proportional to its own energy. Growth is thus self-similar and multiplicative. The system is magnetically dominated, yet exchange terms match in size. Kinetic-magnetic and magnetic-magnetic contributions are similar. With zero net helicity, transfer stays within each helical sector. No cross-sector flow appears. The findings fit Hosking integral conservation. Inverse transfer reads as merging of magnetic islands with like-signed helicity.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lenard Kasselmann, Philipp Grete, Pranjal Trivedi, Marcus Brüggen, Robi Banerjee |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 55 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.02617
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Inverse energy transfer in decaying MHD turbulence: A shell-to-shell analysis Preprint: APS/123-QED Lenard Kasselmann, Philipp Grete, Pranjal Trivedi, Marcus Brüggen, Robi Banerjee Abstract Context. In decaying magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence, energy can be transported from small to large scales, known as inverse transfer. Historically, this was understood as a consequence of the conservation of magnetic helicity, a measure of the topology of magnetic field lines. However, using numerical simulations, inverse transfer was even found in systems where helicity is vanishing on average. Methods. We explore the mechanism behind inverse transfer by measuring shell-to-shell energy and helicity transfer functions from numerical simulations of non-helical and maximally helical decaying MHD turbulence. Results. Independent of magnetic net-helicity, large magnetic scales receive energy directly from the integral scale in both the magnetic and kinetic reservoirs, leading to increasingly non-local transfer for larger receiving scales. The resulting rate of energy increase in each receiving scale is proportional to its energy, resulting in self-similar, multiplicative growth. Even though the system is magnetically dominated, contributions from kinetic-magnetic and magnetic-magnetic energy-exchange are similar in magnitude. In the case of vanishing net-helicity, transfer functions between the positively and negatively helical parts of the field are computed. We find that inverse transfer only occurs within each helical sector, not across them. Conclusions. Our findings are broadly consistent with the theory underlying the conservation of the Hosking integral, which explains inverse transfer as merging of local magnetic islands with equal-signed helicity. I Introduction Decaying magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence has received considerable attention in recent years due to its crucial applications in cosmology and astrophysics Schekochihin 2022 . In cosmology, it is relevant for the evolution of primordial magnetic fields (PMF) Banerjee and Jedamzik 2004 ; Durrer and Neronov 2013 ; Subramanian 2016 . In astrophysics, it is used to describe the dynamics of the solar wind Chen et al. 2011 . In three-dimensional hydrodynamic turbulence, as originally formalized by Kolmogorov 1941 , energy is typically transported from large to small scales through scale-local interactions, a process known as a direct cascade. In MHD turbulence, however, additional conserved quantities can influence the dynamics. One of these is magnetic helicity , which measures the topology (i.e. linkage and self-twist) of magnetic field lines and is calculated as H=\int_{V}\mathbf{A}(\mathbf{x})\cdot\mathbf{B}(\mathbf{x})\>dV, (1) where \mathbf{B} is the magnetic field and \mathbf{A} is its vector potential. This quantity is conserved in ideal MHD, i.e. for vanishing magnetic resistivity Woltjer 1958 , but still approximately conserved if the magnetic Reynolds number is large enough. It is well known that strong magnetic helicity, i.e. H\sim E\cdot L where E is the total magnetic energy and L is the typical scale of magnetic eddies, can cause inverse energy transfer , i.e. transfer of energy from small to large scales, in a decaying magnetic field ( Kahniashvili et al. 2010 ; Pouquet et al. 1976 ; Christensson et al. 2001 ) . This is explained in terms of a selective decay argument: If helicity is better conserved than energy, then H\sim E\cdot L implies that, as E decays, L will grow. An alternative (somewhat more heuristic way) to understand inverse transfer in the case of maximally helical fields, is to imagine the magnetic field as a sea of localized magnetic structures or islands that merge into larger structures via reconnection. For the sake of completeness, we note that inverse transfer can also occur in driven systems, e.g. Müller et al. 2012 . More recently, it was found using numerical simulations that inverse transfer is possible even if helicity is absent on average, albeit weaker than in the fully helical case for a Batchelor spectrum (i.e. a magnetic energy power spectrum with a subinertial range that increases with wave number as k^{4} ) ( Brandenburg et al. 2015 ) . Since helicity is a signed quantity, a system with globally vanishing helicity can still contain patches of locally non-zero helicity density, see lower-right panel in Fig. 1 . Hosking and Schekochihin 2021 (hereafter referenced to as HS) used this fact to explain inverse transfer in systems where helicity is vanishing on average: Locally helical structures are stable, while locally non-helical structures are unstable. If two structures of equally-signed helicity merge, they form a larger structure, resulting in inverse transfer of energy and helicity. If two structures of oppositely-signed helicity merge, their helicities cancel out, resulting in a non-helical structures which decays away quickly. In other words, structures of opposite helicity annihilate. In this scenario, the selective-decay argument still applies, except the invariant that is driving the inverse transfer is now the Hosking integral , a measure of large-scale helicity fluctuations. The theory makes predictions about the scaling of certain global quantities, such as the integral scale and magnetic energy as a function of time, as well as the evolution of the energy-spectra, which have been tested ( Brandenburg et al. 2023 ) 1 1 1 For spectra with a shallower subinertial range, the dynamics may instead be controlled by other conserved quantities, such as the Saffman integral in the k^{2} case Brandenburg et al. 2023 . . A more detailed picture of the underlying turbulent dynamics can be obtained by analyzing the nonlinear terms in the MHD equations in terms of triad interactions in Fourier space, where energy or helicity at one scale is transferred to another via interactions mediated by a third scale. In incompressible MHD, there are two energy reservoirs, kinetic and magnetic, that can exchange energy. Furthermore, decomposing the magnetic field into positively and negatively helical sectors ( Waleffe 1992 ) allows one to directly track interactions between equally- and oppositely-signed helical structures. Transfer functions in the helical mode decomposition have been studied by Linkmann et al. 2016 in a purely analytical way, but have so far not been measured and analyzed directly for a decaying turbulence simulation. In this paper, we address this research gap by applying the shell-to-shell transfer formalism ( Alexakis et al. 2005 ; Dar et al. 2001 ; Teaca et al. 2011 ; Grete et al. 2017 ) to high-resolution simulations of decaying helical and non-helical MHD turbulence. This approach allows us to study in detail how energy is exchanged across scales in the kinetic and magnetic reservoirs and between the positively and negatively helical sectors of the magnetic field in the case of vanishing net helicity. In addition, we compute shell-to-shell transfer functions for magnetic helicity in order to investigate the relation between helicity transfer and energy transfer. These diagnostics allow us to assess the role of different scale interactions in mediating inverse transfer and directly test the dynamical picture of interacting helical structures underlying HS theory. The rest of the paper is structured as follows: in section II , we define the relevant quantities, such as magnetic helicity and the Hosking integral. In section III , we present the details of our simulations and the initial conditions. In section IV , we review the shell-to-shell energy transfer formalism. In section V , we present the results from our simulations and their analysis. In section VI , we discuss our results and end with a conclusion in section VII . Additional information is given in the Appendix. II Definitions In this section, we define the quantities