Comment on “QCD-factorization amplitudes from flavour symmetries: beyond the 𝑺 ​ 𝑼 ​ ( 𝟑 ) SU(3) symmetric case” Preprint: UdeM-GPP-TH-26-309

Bhubanjyoti Bhattacharya, and David London · 2026

Read Comment on “QCD-factorization amplitudes from flavour symmetries: beyond the 𝑺 ​ 𝑼 ​ ( 𝟑 ) SU(3) symmetric case” Preprint: UdeM-GPP-TH-26-309 by Bhubanjyoti Bhattacharya, and David London (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-02538.txt.

Introduction

Bhattacharya and London write a Comment defending a set of relations in B-meson physics. A recent fit to B decays into pairs of light mesons found a good fit. It combined topological diagrams with QCD factorization. The pair's own fit, using flavour SU(3) symmetry, fit very poorly. The clash turns on EWP-tree relations, or ETRs. The other team called ETRs invalid.

The Comment argues that this claim is wrong. ETRs are rigorous results of group theory. If SU(3) is unbroken and small Wilson coefficients are neglected, ETRs follow on their own. No hadronic computation enters that step. The authors also list weaknesses in the rival formalism. The dispute decides which fits to B decay data can be trusted.

Catalog record

CREATORBhubanjyoti Bhattacharya, and David London
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE15 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.02538

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Comment on “QCD-factorization amplitudes from flavour symmetries: beyond the 𝑺 ​ 𝑼 ​ ( 𝟑 ) SU(3) symmetric case” Preprint: UdeM-GPP-TH-26-309 Bhubanjyoti Bhattacharya, and David London Abstract Recently, a fit to B → P ​ P B\to PP decays ( P ∈ { π , K , η , η ′ } P\in\{\pi,K,\eta,\eta^{\prime}\} ) was performed ( “QCD-factorization amplitudes from flavour symmetries: beyond the S ​ U ​ ( 3 ) SU(3) symmetric case” ) using a formalism that combines topological diagrams with QCD factorization, and a good fit was found. We also recently performed such a fit, under the assumption that the B → P ​ P B\to PP amplitudes are related by flavour SU(3) symmetry, but we found a very poor fit. The two results therefore disagree with one another. The source of this disagreement is that we applied EWP-tree relations (ETRs). These were derived ∼ 30 \sim 30 years ago, and relate different topological diagrams or reduced matrix elements, thus reducing the number of unknown parameters in the fit. In their paper, it is asserted that ETRs are invalid, so that analyses that use them are unreliable. We are writing this Comment to explain why this assertion is incorrect. The key point is that ETRs are mathematically rigorous, group theoretically. If SU(3) is unbroken, and the small Wilson coefficients c 7 , 8 c_{7,8} in the weak effective Hamiltonian are neglected, ETRs follow automatically and are exact. That is, this is a group theory result – no hadronic calculations are involved. In this Comment, we also point out several weaknesses of their formalism. In Ref. 12 , Neubert and Rosner established a relation between the electroweak penguin (EWP) and tree topological diagrams of Ref. 6 . Following this, in Ref. 7 , Gronau, Pirjol, and Yan rederived the Neubert-Rosner EWP-tree relation (ETR), and derived another, previously unknown ETR. They used a rigorous group-theoretical method relating the reduced matrix elements (RMEs) of flavour SU(3) symmetry to topological diagrams. Both the Neubert-Rosner and Gronau-Pirjol-Yan ETRs apply to charmless B\to PP decays. Two assumptions were made in deriving these relations: (i) the decays are related by unbroken SU(3), and (ii) the Wilson coefficients c_{7,8} are neglected. In Refs. 2 ; 3 , with collaborators, we performed a fit to charmless B\to PP decays under the same assumptions. A very poor fit was found. Later, in Ref. 4 , we rederived the SU(3) ETRs, this time purely at the level of group theory using SU(3) RMEs. At the same time, we derived ETRs with isospin as the underlying symmetry, and demonstrated that these new isospin-based ETRs are different from the previously-known SU(3)-based ETRs. The key point here is that these results are completely rigorous. As long as the underlying symmetry is unbroken, and c_{7,8} are neglected, the ETRs are exact. And if c_{7,8} are not neglected, we showed in Ref. 4 that the ETRs are modified by only \mathcal{O}({10\%}) . Note that, since isospin is an almost exact symmetry of QCD, large isospin-breaking effects are not expected in the SM. This implies that large violations of the isospin-based ETRs are also unexpected. Recently, following our analysis, Ref. 10 quantified the effect of isospin breaking in the direct CP asymmetry of B^{+}\to\pi^{+}\pi^{0} . In “QCD-factorization amplitudes from flavour symmetries: beyond the SU(3) symmetric case,” by W.-S. Fang, T. Huber, X.-Q. Li, E. Malami and G. Tetlalmatzi-Xolocotzi 5 , a fit to charmless B\to PP decays was performed using a different formalism than ours, and an acceptable fit is found. The problem is that this paper contains numerous incorrect and misleading statements about ETRs and our analysis. We are writing this Comment to set the record straight. As discussed above, ETRs have been around for almost 30 years, and they are rigorous mathematical results, using only group theory. Despite this, the authors of Ref. 5 take great pains to argue that there are problems with ETRs. The main reason is that, when ETRs are taken into account, the number of independent SU(3) RMEs in B\to PP decays is reduced from 10 to 7 in the SU(3) limit. This is what was used in our fits of Refs. 2 ; 3 . On the other hand, in Ref. 5 , they take all 10 RMEs to be independent. With more unknown parameters, it is not surprising that they find a good fit. To justify the use of 10 independent parameters in their fit, they claim that ETRs are unreliable. For example, in the introduction, the authors of Ref. 5 write 1 1 1 Note that, when a reference appears within a quotation in this Comment, we use the reference number as it appears in our list of references, rather than that in the source. Thus, Ref. [99] of Ref. 5 is cited here as Ref. 13 even when it appears within a quotation. “We argue that these relations do not withstand quantum or power corrections (see the derivation in 13 ), and therefore advocate to use the complete set of independent amplitudes for phenomenology.” The problem here is that Ref. 13 says nothing of the sort – there is no derivation that would signify any quantum or power corrections. On the contrary, the authors of Ref. 13 agree with us: in their Sec. IV, they derive the ETRs in terms of their topological diagrams. They conclude with “The three RMEs that are neglected in Ref. 2 arise from the contributions from the electroweak penguin operators O_{7,8} . Since the Wilson coefficients for O_{7,8} are small in the standard model, neglecting these contribution may not have sizable impact in phenomenological analysis.” Since the topological diagrams of Ref. 13 are the same as those of Ref. 5 , there is no justification for asserting that ETRs are unreliable. In fact, following what was actually said in Ref. 13 , these ETRs should have been used in the analysis of Ref. 5 . There is more. In Sec. 6.4 of Ref. 5 , “Scrutinizing the EWP–tree relations,” it is stated that “the EWP–tree relations can be derived under the strict leading-order (LO) QCDF limit, with two non-trivial implicit assumptions: (i) all non-factorizable QCD corrections, including vertex, penguin, hard-spectator scattering, and weak annihilation contributions, are neglected; (ii) the strong-interaction dynamics of EWP amplitudes are identical to those of tree amplitudes, such that their hadronic matrix elements share a common factorizable structure.” But look at the ETRs derived in this way, their Eq. (6.10). These are the isospin-based ETRs! This is very strange. Did they consider all B\to PP decays under the assumption of SU(3) and somehow derive the isospin-based ETRs? Or did they consider only B\to\pi K decays with isospin symmetry, and forget to tell us? Whatever the answer, this puts into doubt this derivation, and raises serious questions about the research in this paper in general. Let us take this result at face value, i.e., they are somehow able to derive the isospin-based ETRs within QCDF. They then go on to say that, if the ratios of diagrams are computed using the favoured values of the diagrams found in their fit, these disagree by a factor of 20-30 with the ratios as computed using the ETRs. They

Read the complete text