Teleocosmology and quantum post-selection

Paul C. W. Davies, João Magueijo · 2026

Read Teleocosmology and quantum post-selection by Paul C. W. Davies, João Magueijo (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-02514.txt.

Introduction

Davies and Magueijo propose a quantum cause for cosmic acceleration. The acceleration of the universe is well established. Its physical origin stays contentious. Most accounts invoke vacuum energy or new fields. The pair invoke neither. Quantum theory allows both initial and final boundary conditions on a state. They extend that idea to the wave function of the universe.

A warm-up case makes the point. A free particle in a wave packet can peak along an accelerating path. A classical observer would infer a fake force. The cosmic version uses connection variables and unimodular time. A radiation packet is post-selected by a Chern-Simons soliton state. The peak leaves the radiation path and enters an accelerating regime. The forward Hamiltonian keeps zero cosmological constant. A classical mimic needs a contrived extra component. It drifts toward phantom behavior. The authors read acceleration as a boundary-condition effect.

Catalog record

CREATORPaul C. W. Davies, João Magueijo
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE66 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.02514

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Teleocosmology and quantum post-selection Paul C. W. Davies, João Magueijo Abstract Abstract: Although it is widely accepted that the expansion of the universe is accelerating, the mechanism underpinning it, usually described as dark energy, remains contentious. Most explanations appeal to either a non-zero vacuum energy (i.e. a cosmological constant) or various novel fields. In this paper we offer an alternative explanation for the cosmological acceleration stemming purely from quantum mechanics itself, without any additional physical constants or fields. The possibility arises because of the basic property of quantum indeterminism, which permits one to postulate both initial and final conditions on a quantum state–in the case considered here, that being the “wave function of the universe”. The study of quantum systems subject to both pre- and post-selection in laboratory physics is long-established, both theoretically and experimentally, and we here extend the subject to cosmology, applying it to a minisuperspace model of quantum cosmology. First we illustrate the basic idea of quantum post-selection mimicking a force, by considering the motion of a free non-relativistic particle: conditioning an initially semiclassical wave packet on a final quantum state can make the intermediate peak accelerate, even though the underlying dynamics remains free. A semiclassical observer of this phenomenon at an intermediate time would regard the acceleration as preposterous if attributed to a classical force. Such a phenomenon might then be regarded as evidence for quantum post-selection. We implement the analogous construction in minisuperspace quantum cosmology, using connection variables and unimodular time. A forward semiclassical packet (describing pure radiation for simplicity) is post-selected by a normalizable Chern–Simons soliton. The resulting two–boundary amplitude has a peak which leaves the radiation trajectory and enters an accelerating regime, while the forward Hamiltonian has Λ = 0 \Lambda=0 . A classical model can mimic this trajectory only through a contrived effective component, resembling w ≃ − 1 w\simeq-1 near the transition and evolving towards strongly “phantom” behaviour ( w < − 1 w<-1 ) when extrapolated. The acceleration is therefore more naturally interpreted as a quantum boundary-condition effect rather than as a local classical source. We close by discussing the rationale for post-selecting with a Chern–Simons soliton and possible tell-tale signatures of the model. I Introduction: post-selection and pre-cognition It has been noted that, for closed systems such as the universe, quantum mechanics may be more naturally formulated in terms of both initial and final boundary conditions Aharonov1964 ; Aharonov2008 . In such a framework, probabilities are conditioned on both endpoints, and cosmological evolution is more appropriately viewed as a boundary-value problem rather than a purely initial-value problem. The purpose of this paper is to explore a concrete implementation of this idea in minisuperspace, using for final states normalizable Chern–Simons states, and to clarify how such boundary data feed into effective cosmological dynamics. Relevant literature includes Alexandre:2022npo ; Gielen:2022dhg . The ultimate purpose is to obtain acceleration without inserting a cosmological constant into the semiclassical Hamiltonian, and hence without inheriting its associated fine-tuning problem (for related literature see Anastopoulos2024 ). Previous approaches to the cosmological constant problem include mechanisms in which global classical constraints effectively know about the spacetime history as a whole, as in vacuum-energy sequestering Kaloper:2013zca ; Kaloper:2014dqa ; Padilla:2015aaa . In this sense they involve a form of classical pre-cognition. Here we replace classical pre-cognition by quantum post-selection, re-examining the same issues. The mechanism is simple in outline. A forward-evolved semiclassical state defines a classical-looking trajectory without acceleration. A backward-evolved final state supplies an additional amplitude bias. The intermediate, conditioned state is obtained from the product of the two amplitudes and it may remain semiclassical. However, if the relative widths of the two states evolve differently, its peak motion need not coincide with the classical trajectory of the forward state. The selected peak can accelerate. Importantly, this acceleration is not produced by adding a local force, a new fluid, modified gravity or a cosmological constant to the Hamiltonian. It is produced by the final boundary condition alone. A classical theory engineered to reproduce the same peak motion can be concocted, but it may be abstruse. We first demonstrate this point in the elementary case of a non-relativistic free particle. An initial semiclassical Gaussian packet evolves according to the free Hamiltonian. If it is conditioned on a final quantum state (for example a delta function at a position not intersecting the classical trajectory), the peak of the intermediate conditional distribution is displaced from the free classical trajectory. In a suitable regime the displacement is large enough to produce acceleration while the packet remains semiclassical. The corresponding classical force required to reproduce the same peak motion would follow an esoteric time-dependent and velocity-dependent law, hard to motivate physically. This model has an interest in its own right, and we believe an experimental verification would be clarifying. For the purposes of this paper it provides a perfect analogy for what we shall seek in cosmology. A simple quantum boundary condition can look, to a semiclassical observer, like an awkward classical modification of the equations of motion. To implement the idea in cosmology we use the quantum-unimodular construction of Alexandre:2022npo ; Gielen:2022dhg ; Magueijo:2021pvq . In this framework the cosmological constant is a priori treated as a variable, while its conjugate provides a physical time Magueijo:2021rpi . Classically, the constancy of \Lambda is then an equation of motion, derived from the independence of the Hamiltonian from this physical time. Quantum mechanically, however, one may superpose different values of \Lambda . This allows the construction of normalizable wave packets centered on a given \Lambda_{0} (namely zero), but also of normalizable states without a sharply defined cosmological constant. The same construction may be expressed either in metric variables, where it is naturally related to Hartle–Hawking states, or in connection variables, where the corresponding states are Chern–Simons states (also called Kodama states Kodama:1988 ; Smolin:2002 ; Magueijo:2020ugp ; Alexander:2022ocp ). We use the latter representation, since the relevant states take a particularly simple form. A further benefit of the unimodular formulation is that the Wheeler–DeWitt equation is recast as a Schrödinger-like equation, with unimodular time playing the role of the evolution parameter. The forward state will be a semiclassical radiation-dominated universe, written in connection space and evolved using the unimodular time T conjugate to \phi=3/\Lambda . (For simplicity we will ignore the matter epoch in this toy model.) We recall that the connection variable b , which on-shell satisfies b=\dot{a} (i.e., the inverse comoving Hubble length), decreases for a decelerating universe (for example a radiation-dominated one) but increases for any accelerating universe. Hence, a turn-around in b(T) is the relevant signal of the onset of acceleration. We take the final state to be a normalizable Chern–Simons soliton: a quantum state localized in the connection b , but with no definite value of \Lambda . Such a state is natural on dimensional grounds, but it is not a state with a definite value of \Lambda ; rather, it has no well-defined semiclassical cosmological constant. The central claim is that the product of the forward radiation packet and this backward-evolved final state can have a peak which turns around and enters an accelerating regime, even while the forward Hamiltonian remains arbitrarily close to that of a

Read the complete text