Linear optimal protocol for physical constraints in weakly driven processes
Pierre Nazé · 2026
Read Linear optimal protocol for physical constraints in weakly driven processes by Pierre Nazé (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-01988.txt.
Introduction
Nazé finds the best way to drive a weak system with low waste. The aim is to cut lost work in the drive. Real limits bound how fast the drive can change. In the weak drive range, the task turns into an eigenvalue problem. That problem involves the system's relaxation function.
The relaxation kernel rests on time gaps alone. It is even, so it sits on a symmetric span. A periodic form restores smooth shift invariance there. The operator turns diagonal in a Fourier basis. The best choice is the zero mode of that basis. It gives a constant speed and a straight-line drive. The best work rests only on the summed relaxation function.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Pierre Nazé |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.01988
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Linear optimal protocol for physical constraints in weakly driven processes Pierre Nazé Abstract The minimization of irreversible work in weakly driven systems within linear response under physical constraints on the protocol derivative is studied. The problem reduces to a shifted eigenvalue equation involving the relaxation function. Owing to its dependence on time differences and its evenness, the relaxation kernel is naturally defined over a symmetric interval, where a periodic representation arises as a consistent closure that restores continuous translational invariance. Also, it shows how the irreversible work is defined in practice. Within this framework, the operator becomes diagonal in a Fourier basis. The global optimal solution is the zero mode, yielding a constant driving speed and a linear protocol. The corresponding optimal work depends only on the integrated relaxation function. Numerical results obtained via genetic programming confirm the robustness of this solution across different kernels. I Introduction The control of thermodynamic processes at small scales has become a central topic in nonequilibrium physics, where fluctuations and dissipation play a dominant role Deffner and Bonança 2020 ; Blaber and Sivak 2023 ; Alvarado et al. 2026 . A fundamental question in this context is how to design external protocols that drive a system between two states while minimizing energetic costs. Within the regime of weak driving, linear response theory provides a general and powerful framework to address this problem, expressing the irreversible work in terms of equilibrium correlation functions Nazé and Bonança 2020 . A number of studies have shown that optimal protocols may exhibit nontrivial features, such as sharp variations near the boundaries of the process Schmiedl and Seifert 2007 ; Gomez-Marin et al. 2008 ; Nazé 2024 ; Nazé 2025 . While such behaviors can reduce dissipation, they are often not physically realizable, as they may require arbitrarily large driving rates. This motivates the introduction of constraints that reflect realistic limitations on the control parameters Muratore-Ginanneschi and Sanders 2026 . In this work, we consider a constrained optimization problem in which the derivative of the protocol is bounded through a quadratic condition, while the total variation of the control parameter is fixed. Within linear response, this leads to a variational problem for the irreversible work functional, whose stationarity condition takes the form of a shifted eigenvalue equation involving the relaxation function, which encodes the memory of the system. A central aspect of this formulation concerns the structure of the relaxation kernel in finite time processes. The irreversible work depends on the function \Psi_{0}(t-u) , which is determined by equilibrium correlations. This dependence on time differences implies that, even though the protocol is defined over the interval [0,\tau] , the kernel is naturally defined over the symmetric domain [-\tau,\tau] . In addition, the relaxation function is even, reflecting the symmetry of equilibrium correlations. These two properties together define the natural domain and symmetry of the operator associated with the variational problem. When the dynamics is restricted to a finite interval, however, boundary effects break the translational invariance that is implicit in the dependence on time differences. The appropriate way to restore this structure is not to impose an external condition, but to consistently complete the kernel on its natural domain. This is achieved by extending the relaxation function periodically over [-\tau,\tau] . Such a construction preserves both the dependence on time differences and the evenness of the kernel, while ensuring continuity at the boundaries and restoring translational invariance. From this perspective, the periodic representation of the relaxation function should not be viewed as a mathematical artifact, but as a direct consequence of its intrinsic structure. Once this representation is adopted, the integral operator becomes a convolution operator on a periodic domain, and the Fourier basis emerges as its natural spectral representation. The diagonalization of the problem then follows directly from these structural properties. From an operational perspective, the periodic representation of the relaxation function can be understood as a natural consequence of how irreversible work is defined in practice. The averaged work is obtained as an ensemble average over many realizations of the same finite-time protocol, each performed over the interval [0,\tau] and starting from an identical initial statistical state. After each realization, the system is effectively reset, and the protocol is applied again. In this sense, the ensemble of realizations introduces a block structure in time, where each block corresponds to a single execution of the protocol. Since the relaxation function depends only on time differences, and all realizations are statistically equivalent, there is no distinguished origin of time across the ensemble. As a result, time differences are represented on a periodic domain, leading to an effective periodic representation of the kernel. Within this framework, the optimization problem can be analyzed in terms of the eigenmodes of the relaxation kernel. The positivity of the kernel plays a decisive role, as it selects the zero mode as the unique minimizer under the imposed constraints. As a consequence, the optimal protocol corresponds to a constant driving speed, leading to a linear control parameter in time. This result is not imposed, but follows from the symmetry and spectral properties of the operator. Similar results have already been found in other contexts, such as slowly varying limit using geometric framework approach Sivak and Crooks 2012 , and Markovian systems with low-noise limit Monter et al. 2026 . While linear protocols are known to arise in linear-response frameworks under specific conditions, such as constant thermodynamic metric or slow driving, in those cases linearity follows from the locality of the functional or geometric arguments. In contrast, here linearity emerges from the spectral structure of a nonlocal quadratic functional, where the positivity of the relaxation kernel selects the zero mode as the global minimizer under constraints. To assess the generality of these findings, we complement the analytical treatment with numerical optimization based on genetic programming Koza 1994 . This approach allows us to explore a broad class of admissible protocols and relaxation functions, including kernels with distinct temporal structures. In all cases examined, the optimal protocol converges to a linear form, and the corresponding work agrees with the analytical prediction with high precision, indicating that the result is robust and not dependent on specific features of the kernel. This paper is organized as follows. We first introduce the irreversible work functional and discuss the structural properties of the relaxation function in finite time processes. We then formulate the constrained variational problem and derive the associated Euler-Lagrange equation. Next, we solve the resulting shifted eigenvalue problem using a spectral decomposition. Finally, we present numerical results that support the analytical findings and discuss their implications. II Preliminaries We consider a system driven by an external control parameter \lambda(t) over a finite time interval t\in[0,\tau] . In the regime of weak driving, linear response theory provides an expression for the irreversible work in terms of equilibrium fluctuations. Defining the driving speed as v(t)\equiv\dot{\lambda}(t) , the irreversible work functional can be written as W_{\mathrm{irr}}[v]=\frac{1}{2}\int_{0}^{\tau}\int_{0}^{\tau}\Psi_{0}(t-u)\,v(t)\,v(u)\,du\,dt. (1) The relaxation function \Psi_{0}(t) encodes the temporal correlations of the generalized force conjugate to \lambda . It is assumed to be even and positive definite, as required by equilibrium linear response theory Nazé and Bonança 2020 . If the system starts from the thermal equilibrium,