The gravitational wave-black hole imaging correspondence for modified black holes

David Díaz-Guerra, Ángel Rincón, Diego Rubiera-Garcia, Diego Saez-Chillon Gomez · 2026

Read The gravitational wave-black hole imaging correspondence for modified black holes by David Díaz-Guerra, Ángel Rincón, Diego Rubiera-Garcia, Diego Saez-Chillon Gomez (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-01915.txt.

Introduction

Díaz-Guerra and co-authors link black hole imaging to gravitational wave signals. Imaging probes the near-static geometry around a hole. Light bending in the strong field gives that view. Waves probe the dynamic response of space-time instead. Inspiral, merger, and ringdown phases carry that signal.

Both channels access the same narrow region. It lies between the horizon and the photon region. Past work tied quantities across the two channels. That link holds in the eikonal limit of optics. The team extend the correspondence to modified black holes. Such holes depart from the standard general relativity form. The work clarifies what each messenger can reveal.

Catalog record

CREATORDavid Díaz-Guerra, Ángel Rincón, Diego Rubiera-Garcia, Diego Saez-Chillon Gomez
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE57 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.01915

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The gravitational wave-black hole imaging correspondence for modified black holes David Díaz-Guerra, Ángel Rincón, Diego Rubiera-Garcia, Diego Saez-Chillon Gomez Abstract Black holes (BHs) can be studied via fundamentally different observational channels that probe complementary aspects of their physics. While BH imaging provides access to the quasi-static space-time geometry via the strong bending of light rays, gravitational wave (GW) observations probe the dynamical response of the space-time to time-dependent processes in the inspiral, merger and ringdown phases. Both messengers – electromagnetic imaging probes and ringdown GW spectroscopy –, provide access to essentially the same region – the one between the BH event horizon and the photon region –, but they do it via conceptually different methods, encoding different physical information. However, it has been shown in the literature that physical quantities supposedly exclusive of each such messenger are actually tightly related to each another via a correspondence that occurs in the eikonal limit (i.e. large values of the multipole number ℓ \ell ) of the geometric-optics approximation. In this paper we clarify the actual identification of observables within such a correspondence and test its accuracy for a bunch of modified spherically symmetric BH geometries proposed in the literature. We find that even for low values of ℓ \ell the correspondence is surprisingly accurate in relating the real and imaginary parts of quasi-normal modes in the GW ringdown phase with the critical impact parameter and Lyapunov exponent of nearly-bound light trajectories for every such model analyzed. We discuss the applicability of such a result both for each messenger individually, and also for foreseeable tests of BHs combining both messengers. I Introduction The existence of black holes (BHs) is one of the pivotal predictions of our theories of the gravitational field. Within Einstein’s General Relativity (GR), such BHs are described by the Kerr solution Kerr:1963ud : the most general asymptotically-flat, stationary, axi-symmetric, vacuum solution of Einstein’s field equations, solely described by mass and angular momentum Robinson:1975bv . However, BHs departing from the Kerr solution can be found via the introduction of additional “charges”, such as electromagnetic Newman:1965my or scalar Herdeiro:2014goa fields, or by enlarging the framework of GR within modified theories of gravity Sotiriou:2008rp ; Olmo:2011uz ; Clifton:2011jh ; Nojiri:2017ncd . Some of such modified BHs are capable of displaying theoretically consistent physical features while at the same time can be studied using the same tools employed for the Kerr metric Berti:2015itd ; Yunes:2013dva . Currently, the two main messengers at our disposal for testing whether the nature of BHs is accurately described by the Kerr solution or instead traces of non-Kerrness are present, are sensitive to the same BH parameters but they do it via observational routes that differ substantially. On the one hand, BH imaging (BHI) tests the background space-time geometry under quasi-stationary conditions, focusing on the images brought by highly-bent trajectories near the photon region Cunha:2018acu . On the other hand, gravitational waves (GWs) probe the temporal evolution of the space-time, appealing to the highly non-linear dynamics of the horizon formation and relaxation into the BH final stationary state, reaching their appex in BH ringdown spectroscopy Berti:2009kk . From this perspective, one could say that while BHI provides a snapshot of the BH geometry, GWs supply a movie of the space-time in evolution. With the detection of GWs out of binary BH mergers by the LIGO-Virgo Collaboration LIGOScientific:2016aoc ; LIGOScientific:2017vwq , and with the successful imaging of the light emitted by the hot material orbiting M87 ∗ EventHorizonTelescope:2019dse and Sgr A ∗ EventHorizonTelescope:2022wkp by the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT), we have opened a window allowing us to probe the strong-field regime of BHs via the above two messengers. Further planned observatories, including the next-generation EHT Tiede:2022grp , the BH Explorer Johnson:2024ttr , LISA Barausse:2020rsu , or the Einstein Telescope ET:2025xjr , engender further promises for high-precision BH physics. Within this context, ideas about combining information from BHI and GWs probes for investigating both stationary and dynamical aspects of BHs using tools from each messenger are currently gaining traction. One such idea was suggested decades ago Ferrari:1984zz ; Cardoso:2008bp but it has recently re-emerged with renewed vigor, and for the sake of this paper we shall dub it as the quasi-normal modes-black hole imaging (QNM-BHI) correspondence. It is grounded on the fact that not only do BHI and GWs (in the ringdown phase) probe essentially the same space-time region – the one comprised between the BH event horizon and the photon (shell) region – but they do it using a description in terms of effective potentials that closely resemble one another. In fact, in the geometrical-optics approximation given by the eikonal limit – that is, large values of the multipole number \ell – such a correspondence is exact. On the one end of such a correspondence are the real and imaginary parts of the QNMs of GWs found in the relaxation (ringdown) phase after the coalescence has taken place, and which are physically interpreted as the frequency and damping rate of the QNMs, respectively. On the other end we find the critical impact parameter and the Lyapunov index of nearly-bound geodesics of highly-bent light rays, whose physical meaning can be linked with the central dark region and bright photon ring features appearing in the image, respectively. The main aim of the present paper is to test the actual usefulness of the correspondence to provide the correct numbers of such quantities from one of its ends to the other (and the other way round) for modified BH configurations. The latter correspond to static spherically symmetric configurations supported by modifications of the Schwarzschild solution of GR either via the introduction of additional matter fields or framed with modified gravity theories. Nonetheless we shall remain agnostic about their origin, but instead focus on the way the correspondence is realized for different values of \ell . Surprisingly, we find that the correspondence works remarkably well even for low values of \ell . This means that starting from (say) the computation of QNM frequencies we get the quantities characterizing the BHI side (critical impact parameter and Lyapunov exponent) with little loss of accuracy as compared to their values found through usual ray-tracing procedures of the BHI field. We shall elaborate on the caveats regarding the connection between these theoretical quantities against the actual modeling and observational difficulties in measuring them for each messenger. It should be pointed out the existence of previous works on the relation between QNMs and BHI for different specific models, see e.g. Jusufi:2020odz ; Liu:2020ola ; Okyay:2021nnh ; Campos:2021sff ; Pantig:2022gih ; Atamurotov:2022nim ; Pedrotti:2024znu ; Lambiase:2024lvo ; Bonanno:2025dry ; Borah:2025tvw ; Feng:2025iao . This paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II we discuss the physical origin and interpretation of QNMs as well as the numerical methods employed to find them. In Sec. III we consider the process of generation of BH images and the quantities associated to nearly-bound geodesics. The QNM-BHI correspondence is introduced in Sec. IV , where we supply a physical interpretation to quantities on each side and across the divide between them, clarifying some misunderstandings in the literature of the topic. In Sec. V we introduce a bunch of non-Schwarzschild geometries, and compute their BHI observables and

Read the complete text