Distribution and Evolution of the Debris Cloud from the Fragmentation of Intelsat 33E
Peng Shu, Meng Zhao, Yu-Yan Wu, Zhen Yang, Yu-Qiang Li · 2026
Read Distribution and Evolution of the Debris Cloud from the Fragmentation of Intelsat 33E by Peng Shu, Meng Zhao, Yu-Yan Wu, Zhen Yang, Yu-Qiang Li (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-01878.txt.
Introduction
Shu and co-authors track the debris cloud from a broken satellite. Intelsat 33E broke up on 19 October 2024. The event posed a risk to geostationary orbit craft. The team studies how the fragments spread and evolve. They use a probabilistic model for the cloud.
A NASA breakup model gives the first fragment spread. It yields 4,393 fragments larger than one centimeter. Fragments form dense ring structures in the equatorial plane. Those rings arise from 24 hours to 28 days out. Orbits of 36 cataloged fragments are checked too. Monte Carlo runs validate the fast analytic model. Collision risk for top satellites reaches up to 10^-8.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Peng Shu, Meng Zhao, Yu-Yan Wu, Zhen Yang, Yu-Qiang Li |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.01878
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Distribution and Evolution of the Debris Cloud from the Fragmentation of Intelsat 33E Peng Shu, Meng Zhao, Yu-Yan Wu, Zhen Yang, Yu-Qiang Li Abstract The breakup of Intelsat 33E on 19 October 2024 posed a potential risk to satellites in the Geostationary Earth Orbit (GEO). This study analyzes the evolution and distribution of these fragments using a probabilistic approach. The initial distribution of the fragments, derived from the NASA Standard Breakup Model, indicates the generation of 4,393 fragments larger than 1 centimeter. The spatial propagation of these fragments is modeled analytically in the Earth-Centered Earth-Fixed reference frame, showing the formation of high-density ring structures in the equatorial plane from 24 hours to 28 days after the breakup. The orbits of 36 cataloged fragments are retrieved and compared with the probability density. Furthermore, Monte Carlo simulations validate the probabilistic model and highlight its efficiency in capturing low-probability events. Collision risks to other GEO satellites are assessed, showing that the top 10% of satellites encounter a collision probability of up to 10 − 8 10^{-8} after 28 days. Satellites near the equatorial plane are at higher risk, whereas those with higher inclinations are less affected. These findings underscore the need for enhanced monitoring and mitigation strategies for GEO breakup events, given the challenges in detecting small fragments. Keywords: space debris; in-orbit fragmentations; probability density; collision risks 1 Introduction Many valuable satellites are deployed in the Geostationary Earth Orbit (GEO) due to their ability to maintain a fixed position relative to the Earth’s surface. However, the majority of these satellites are confined to a narrow orbital ring above the equator, typically separated by only \pm 0.1^{\circ} in longitude. Furthermore, the growing number of GEO satellites has exceeded the availability of designated slots, forcing multiple satellites to share a single longitudinal position ( 14 ) . The high concentration of satellites in the GEO region renders it particularly vulnerable to space debris ( 30 ) , a situation further compounded by the absence of natural mechanisms for debris removal ( 34 ; 20 ) . Recently, Intelsat 33E experienced an anomaly on 19 October 2024 that caused a loss of power and service, and Intelsat reported on 21 October 2024 that the event had resulted in the total loss of the satellite ( 4 ) . The event was then identified as an on-orbit fragmentation in NASA’s Orbital Debris Quarterly News ( 22 ) , highlighting the potential for significant pollution of the GEO region. The primary method for detecting objects in geostationary orbit is optical imaging, as radar effectiveness decreases significantly at such distances ( 31 ; 7 ) . However, tracking fragments from breakup events poses a greater challenge, since most are too small to be detected reliably ( 6 ; 15 ) . Typically, only objects larger than 1 meter are cataloged by the US Space Surveillance Network ( 17 ) . The population of GEO objects may exceed the cataloged count by a factor of four, as indicated by a European Space Agency (ESA) survey 3 . As of February 2026, only 36 cataloged fragments from Intelsat 33E have been published by the US Space Surveillance System, which is a small fraction of the expected population from such an event. Public optical tracking reports indicate that the actual fragment cloud is substantially larger; for example, ExoAnalytic Solutions reported more than 700 debris pieces by 10 December 2024, even though only a much smaller subset had cataloged orbital elements available publicly ( 25 ) . Nevertheless, the hazard of untracked fragments is not negligible due to their extremely high speeds ( 24 ) . Dynamic models are a powerful tool to provide valuable insights into the evolution and risk of GEO debris, particularly when observations are limited or incomplete. Early researchers often utilized simple Monte Carlo methods to simulate the breakup fragments in GEO ( 34 ; 35 ) . However, constrained by the computational resources available at the time, these models incorporated significant simplifications and typically operated with a limited number of samples. Nowadays, some high-fidelity models have been developed to better simulate the evolution of space debris. 27 developed the Space Debris Mitigation program (SDM) to analyze the debris environment. 13 developed the Debris Analysis and Monitoring Architecture for the Geosynchronous Environment (DAMAGE) to study the mitigation and removal of space debris. The Harbin Institute of Technology in China established the Space Debris Environment Engineering Models (SDEEM), which simulates debris from Low Earth Orbit (LEO) to GEO ( 16 ) . The latest version of SDEEM incorporates interfaces for modeling large constellations and sudden breakup events. Beyond the models developed in academia, specialized aerospace agencies have also established their own models for engineering purposes. NASA developed the Orbital Debris Engineering Model (ORDEM) as the primary tool to provide a timely, validated model of the human-made orbital debris environment ( 19 ) . ORDEM generates a set of representative fragments from breakup events, and then propagates them to the future moment. Similarly, ESA developed the Meteoroid and Space Debris Terrestrial Environment Reference (MASTER) model ( 9 ) . The foundational modeling philosophy of MASTER involves simulating all known debris-generating events in space to establish a synthetic population. This population can then be used to derive the corresponding space debris flux for a given satellite mission, thereby enabling risk assessment. These models characterize the evolution of debris fragments by generating random samples and propagating them forward in time. However, due to stochastic variability, each simulation may yield different outcomes. Thus, repeated simulations are necessary to draw statistically reliable conclusions ( 28 ) . By representing fragments through probability distributions, continuous methods have been introduced to model the evolution of breakup debris. Letizia et al. proposed an analytical model to describe the evolution of fragments based on the continuity equation ( 11 ; 12 ) . Subsequently, 1 developed a fully probabilistic framework that transforms initial fragment distributions into a continuous space. More recently, 32 derived the medium-term distribution of fragments using inverse mappings of three orbital elements. This work presents a high-resolution analysis of the post-breakup evolution of the Intelsat 33E debris population, with the goal of quantifying the secondary collision risk to other satellites. The initial fragments were described using a probability density function (PDF) derived from the NASA SBM. The PDF of the entire population was then propagated over time using a fully probabilistic method. The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 describes the details of the fragments generated from the breakup of Intelsat 33E. Section 3 describes the distribution of fragments over time. Section 4 evaluates the risk of secondary collisions to other GEO satellites. And the conclusions are drawn in Section 5 . 2 Fragments Generated from the Breakup Intelsat 33E was a high throughput communications satellite manufactured by Boeing on the Boeing 702MP platform ( 26 ) . It orbited the Earth at a height of 35,780 km. Launched on 24 August 2016 with a satellite mass of 6575 kg, it was positioned at 60 ∘ E longitude and had an expected operational lifespan of over 15 years ( 26 ) . On 19 October 2024, the satellite experienced an anomaly that