Probing kinetic enhancement of fusion reactivity in turbulent hot spots Preprint: APS/123-QED
Yao Guo, Dong Wu, Jie Zhang · 2026
Read Probing kinetic enhancement of fusion reactivity in turbulent hot spots Preprint: APS/123-QED by Yao Guo, Dong Wu, Jie Zhang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-01860.txt.
Introduction
Guo and co-authors probe how turbulence may boost fusion rates in hot spots. Fusion rates are often computed with a Maxwellian ion spread. Recent theory says turbulence can reshape that spread. Tails beyond the Maxwell form could lift reactivity. The team tests this idea with shear flow simulations.
They compare two collision models on a sine-shaped flow. The BGK model gives a larger boost to reactivity. The Fokker-Planck model gives a much smaller one. Under typical fusion terms, the boost is near halved. Particle-in-cell runs add nuclear reactions to the mix. Those runs show ion heating can amplify the boost. It can even pass the steady-state forecast, they report.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yao Guo, Dong Wu, Jie Zhang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 61 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.01860
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Probing kinetic enhancement of fusion reactivity in turbulent hot spots Preprint: APS/123-QED Yao Guo, Dong Wu, Jie Zhang Abstract Traditionally, fusion reactivity in thermonuclear plasmas has been calculated by assuming a local Maxwellian ion distribution. However, recent theoretical work [Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 155101 (2025)] suggests that turbulence in plasmas can generate non-Maxwellian tail distributions, thereby enhancing reactivity. In this paper, we investigate this effect through numerical simulations of a sinusoidal shear flow. By comparing steady-state distributions obtained with the Bhatnagar–Gross–Krook (BGK) and Fokker-Planck (FP) collision operators, respectively, we demonstrate that the BGK model overestimates the reactivity enhancement while the FP operator gives a much more modest enhancement that is nearly halved under typical ICF parameters. Particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations incorporating nuclear reactions are also conducted, which reveal that the combined effects of preferential ion heating during shear flow dissipation and tail enhancement can even amplify the reactivity enhancement to be larger than the steady-state prediction. I Introduction Inertial confinement fusion (ICF) is a scheme in which fuel targets are irradiated, heated and compressed by intense lasers to form a dense hot spot and achieve fusion ignition Nuckolls et al. 1972 ; Lindl et al. 2004 ; Betti and Hurricane 2016 . Traditionally, the evolution of the fuel target has been primarily modeled using single-fluid radiation-hydrodynamic (rad-HD) approaches Marinak et al. 2001 ; Clark et al. 2019 . This framework rests on the assumption that the fuel plasma achieves thermal equilibrium (i.e. relaxes to a Maxwellian distribution) on a timescale much shorter than any other relevant dynamical timescales Spitzer 2006 . Under this assumption, fusion reactivity within the hot spot is a local function dependent solely on reactant densities and temperatures; thus, maximizing the conversion of laser energy into thermal energy is, in principle, optimal for fusion. Consequently, any residual kinetic energy (in this paper, kinetic energy refers to the macroscopic kinetic energy of the fluid) in the hot spot is considered wasted and non-productive for fusion reactivity Kritcher et al. 2014 . Furthermore, remnant kinetic energy often results from hydrodynamic instabilities in the compression process, such as Richtmyer-Meshkov (RM) and Rayleigh-Taylor (RT) instabilities Zhou 2017a ; Zhou 2017b ; Guo et al. 2024 . These instabilities can reduce the hot spot symmetry and lead to deformation, breakup, and radiative cooling Springer et al. 2018 , which are destructive to hot spot formation and confinement. Accordingly, for years, the National Ignition Facility (NIF) campaigns Kline et al. 2019 , as well as various alternative ignition schemes (e.g., fast ignition Tabak et al. 2005 and double-cone ignition Zhang et al. 2020 ), have striven to suppress hydrodynamic instabilities and the resultant turbulence. Substantial progress has been made in this direction, with fusion gains exceeding unity having been achieved several times at NIF Zylstra et al. 2022 ; Abu-Shawareb et al. 2024 . Despite these successes, single-fluid simulations frequently fall short of accurately predicting experimental observations. These discrepancies are often attributed to kinetic and multi-species effects Rinderknecht et al. 2014 ; Rinderknecht et al. 2018 ; Yin et al. 2019 ; Hartouni et al. 2023 ; Higginson et al. 2025 that lie beyond the single-fluid approximation. Specifically, single-fluid models consistently fail to explain the apparent ion temperature anomalies (e.g., inferred T_{DD}<T_{DT} Murphy 2014 ; Mannion et al. 2023 ) and anomalous neutron yield Taitano et al. 2018 observed in experiments. This arises partly because HD models calculate reactivity assuming a local Maxwellian distribution based solely on local temperature and density. In contrast, kinetic theory determines fusion reactivity by integrating over the full velocity distribution, where the most significant contribution comes from the high-energy tail. Because these supra-thermal ions are weakly collisional, they are highly susceptible to non-Maxwellian distortions. Consequently, incorporating such kinetic effects can lead to yield predictions that deviate significantly from standard HD models. Notable efforts in this direction include studies of Knudsen-layer loss Petschek and Henderson 1979 ; Molvig et al. 2012 ; Albright et al. 2013 ; Schmit et al. 2013 and \alpha -particle knock-on effects Fisher et al. 1994 ; Ballabio et al. 1997 ; Xue et al. 2025 . Recently, Fetsch and Fisch (FF hereafter) Fetsch and Fisch 2025a ; Fetsch and Fisch 2025b proposed that turbulence and shear flows within ICF hot spots may counter-intuitively favor fusion ignition through the spatial transport of tail ions. This mechanism is actually analogous to collisionless shear acceleration, which was proposed decades ago in the astrophysical context Rieger and Duffy 2004 . In collisionless shear flows, particles randomly traverse the shear and scatter off magnetic islands, thereby gaining a velocity difference and being accelerated as the process repeats. In a strongly collisional environment like ICF hot spots, this effect is inhibited for most particles since their mean free path \lambda is much shorter compared to the velocity gradient length L , i.e. the Knudsen number \text{Kn}\equiv\lambda/L\ll 1 is small. However, since \lambda\propto v^{4} , a few fast tail particles can break this constraint and surf across the shear. Consequently, these tail particles gain a relative velocity increase and march further into the high-velocity region of the phase space (more precisely, approximately half of the tail particles are accelerated across the shear, while the remaining half are decelerated). Building on this, FF developed an analytical theory to describe the shear flow reactivity enhancement (SFRE) in subsonic turbulent flows. By employing a perturbation expansion in Mach number on a modified Bhatnagar–Gross–Krook (BGK) equation, they derived explicit expressions for the perturbed ion distribution up to the second order. These perturbed distributions are then used to derive an explicit (though complicated) formula for the reactivity enhancement factor \Phi . Their calculations demonstrate that under typical ICF parameters, the reactivity can be enhanced several-fold compared to that of the local Maxwellian distribution. Crucially, the SFRE reactivity can exceed the values obtained under the assumption of complete thermalization of turbulent kinetic energy (TKE). This in principle enables novel ICF designs with lower ignition temperatures, smaller hot spot radii, and in consequence, smaller driving energy, as long as turbulence in the hot spot can be driven at a lower expense. Despite these profound insights, the impact of SFRE on the dynamic evolution of a realistic hot spot remains an open question. Firstly, the analysis in FF relies on a modified BGK operator, which oversimplifies the phase-space scattering process. Energy diffusion and pitch-angle scattering in reality can suppress the formation of anisotropic high-energy tails, hindering SFRE. Secondly, FF assumes a static background flow, relying on the assumption of an infinite timescale separation between the fast tail ions and the bulk flow evolution. In a real hot spot, however, the viscous dissipation of turbulence, the thermalization of the plasma, and the self-heating from \alpha -particles occur on finite and comparable timescales. This necessitates a fully time-dependent, self-consistent evaluation of the flow decay and feedback loops. These unresolved issues motivated this work. In this paper, we investigate the SFRE effect in a systematic way. The paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II , following FF, we provide a brief review of the theoretical basis underlying this problem. In Sec. III , we investigate the steady-state tail distribution with both the BGK operator and the Fokker-Planck (FP) operator, where it is