The Information Content of Quasar Variability Light Curves: How Well Can we Infer Stochastic Model Parameters?

Brendon J. Brewer, Geraint F. Lewis, Xiang Yu (Ryan), Yuan Li (Cher) · 2026

Read The Information Content of Quasar Variability Light Curves: How Well Can we Infer Stochastic Model Parameters? by Brendon J. Brewer, Geraint F. Lewis, Xiang Yu (Ryan), Yuan Li (Cher) (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-01496.txt.

Introduction

Brewer, Lewis, Yu, and Li ask what quasar light curves really reveal. Quasar variability stems from multi-scale processes in accretion disks. Stochastic time series models capture that variability. The simplest is the Damped Random Walk model. Fitting it with a fixed mean is the typical approach. That choice leads to overconfident timescale estimates, they show. Uncertainties on the timescale get substantially underestimated. The short-term volatility parameter is far better constrained.

Simulations with entropy and mutual information confirm the split. Light curves carry much more information about volatility than timescale. Future studies should focus on volatility, they recommend. A hierarchical Bayesian fit tests 570 light curves over decades. Volatility falls as luminosity and rest wavelength rise. It also falls with redshift more steeply than time dilation suggests.

Catalog record

CREATORBrendon J. Brewer, Geraint F. Lewis, Xiang Yu (Ryan), Yuan Li (Cher)
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE66 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.01496

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Information Content of Quasar Variability Light Curves: How Well Can we Infer Stochastic Model Parameters? Brendon J. Brewer, Geraint F. Lewis, Xiang Yu (Ryan), Yuan Li (Cher) Abstract ABSTRACT Quasar variability, driven by multi-scale physical processing within a relativistic accretion disk, is commonly modelled with stochastic time series models. The simplest of these is the Damped Random Walk (DRW), also known as the Ornstein-Uhlenbeck (OU) process. Here, we demonstrate that, when fitting such a model to quasar light curve data, the mean of the light curve, μ \mu , should not be fixed (which is the typical approach), as this leads to overconfident inferences about the variability timescale τ \tau , with substantially underestimated uncertainties. However, the short term volatility parameter η \eta is typically very well constrained from short light curves. Through simulations, we compute information theoretic quantities such as the conditional entropy and the mutual information, confirming that light curves provide much more information about η \eta than about τ \tau . As a result, we recommend that future quasar variability studies focus on η \eta rather than τ \tau . To demonstrate this approach, we fit a hierarchical Bayesian regression model for η \eta as a function of bolometric luminosity and rest wavelength to a dataset of 570 light curves measured over decades. We perform the fit using a likelihood function that uses the light curves directly, rather than using intermediate η \eta values from individual light curve fits. We find that volatility decreases as a function of both bolometric luminosity and rest wavelength. The volatility also decreases more steeply with redshift than time dilation alone would suggest, pointing to an increase in intrinsic volatility as quasars evolve over cosmic time. keywords quasars: general, methods: statistical 1 Introduction Quasars are among the most luminous and dynamic objects in the Universe, their prodigious energy output powered by the accretion of matter onto supermassive black holes residing in the centres of galaxies ( 25 , see) . They exhibit variability across essentially all observed wavelengths and on timescales ranging from hours to decades. This variability is widely understood to arise from the intricate and highly non-linear physics operating within relativistic accretion discs, where turbulent magnetohydrodynamic flows, radiation transport, thermal instabilities, and strong gravitational effects combine to produce complex and evolving emission signatures ( 11 , e.g.) . The resulting variability provides a unique observational window into physical processes occurring on scales otherwise inaccessible to direct imaging. Given the physical complexities, ab initio modelling of quasar light curves presents a significant challenge ( 12 , e.g.) . Hence, quasar variability is often represented as a statistical process described by a few parameters. It has been established that a Damp Random Walk (DRW) approach, in particular the CAR(1) process (continuous autoregressive process of order 1), represents quasar variability well ( 19 ) . Whilst there is some evidence that the quasar variability might depart from this model ( 35 , e.g.) , with more sophisticated models being available ( 20 ) , it remains a useful approximation with a relatively simple set of parameters including a characteristic timescale \tau . However, to accurately determine the CAR(1) parameters, sufficiently long temporal observations of quasar light curves are essential, with durations exceeding the typical time scale by a factor of at least ten ( 23 ) . However, the statistical characteristics of variability feed into other quasar studies, such as reverberation mapping and using quasars as cosmological probes. Extensive samples of quasar light curves are now becoming available, with 31 , hereafter S22, presenting multiband variability and estimates of \tau (with uncertainties) for a sample of almost 200 quasars over a two decade period. Assuming that the timescale parameter \tau can be used as a clock to time quasar variability, 24 and 5 used the 31 estimates to confirm the expected presence of cosmological time dilation in the variability timescales. However, the robustness of this cosmological measurement is dependent upon robustness of the measurement of the timescale \tau , and hence it is essential to investigate the reliability of the inference processes involved in determining \tau from the light curves. This will form the focus of this paper. The layout of this paper is as follows: Section 2 covers the background required for fitting CAR(1) models including details about the parameters, the prior distributions, the likelihood function, and the computational approach. In Section 3 , we demonstrate the issues involved in fitting CAR(1) models to light curve data, based on a simulated dataset as an example. In Section 4 , we use information theory to quantify the amount of information light curves typically contain about the stochastic model parameters. Section 5 extends this analysis to quantify the cost of certain modelling choices in terms of the reliability of the inferences about \tau . The results of these sections lead us to focus on a short term volatility parameter \eta as it is much better constrained than \tau . In Section 6 we fit a hierarchical regression model to the S22 sample of quasars to determine how quasar volatility \eta depends on redshift, luminosity, and the rest wavelength of the observations. Finally, we conclude in Section 7 . 2 Bayesian CAR(1) Fitting Typical light curve data for a particular quasar in a particular waveband consists of a series of timestamps \boldsymbol{t}=\{t_{1},...,t_{N}\} , a corresponding sequence of brightness measurements \boldsymbol{y}=\{y_{1},...,y_{N}\} (which we will take to be in magnitudes), and error bars \boldsymbol{s}=\{s_{1},...,s_{N}\} which indicate the uncertainty on the brightness measurements. Our notation for the magnitude measurements uses a subscript (e.g., y_{i} ) for the observed values including measurement error. When we discuss the underlying error-free continuous curve, we still use the symbol y but with parentheses; i.e., y(t) . 2.1 Bayesian Inference To fit a stochastic variability model to such data, we must identify the model parameters \boldsymbol{\theta} , specify their prior distribution p(\boldsymbol{\theta}) , and also specify the sampling distribution 1 1 1 Sampling distribution is the traditional term, but the sampling distribution is best understood as a representing prior information about the relationship between the data and the parameters ( 9 ; 10 ) . for the data p(\boldsymbol{y}\,|\,\boldsymbol{\theta}) , describing what data we would expect to observe as a function of the parameters. Bayes’s theorem then gives the posterior distribution for the model parameters \displaystyle p(\boldsymbol{\theta}\,|\,\boldsymbol{y}) \displaystyle=\frac{p(\boldsymbol{\theta})p(\boldsymbol{y}\,|\,\boldsymbol{\theta})}{p(\boldsymbol{y})}, (1) where p(\boldsymbol{y}\,|\,\boldsymbol{\theta}) is the likelihood function (obtained by substituting the observed data into the expression for the sampling distribution) and the denominator is the marginal likelihood or evidence value, given by \displaystyle p(\boldsymbol{y}) \displaystyle=\int p(\boldsymbol{\theta})p(\boldsymbol{y}\,|\,\boldsymbol{\theta})\,d\boldsymbol{\theta}. (2) The posterior distribution is often characterised by generating samples from it using Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) techniques ( 29 ) . If required, marginal likelihoods and posterior samples can also be computed simultaneously using Nested Sampling ( 30 ) . In this paper, we use Diffusive Nested Sampling ( 6 ) , as implemented in the DNest4 package ( 3 ) , to sample from posterior distributions and compute marginal likelihoods. 2.2 CAR(1) Likelihood Function The likelihood function for the CAR(1) model can be obtained in two equivalent ways — using the state space representation ( 19 ) or using Gaussian processes ( 33 ) .

Read the complete text