Relative invariant subalgebra rigidity for Thompson’s group F F

Tattwamasi Amrutam, Artem Dudko · 2026

Read Relative invariant subalgebra rigidity for Thompson’s group F F by Tattwamasi Amrutam, Artem Dudko (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-01268.txt.

Introduction

Amrutam and Dudko prove a rigidity result for Thompson's group F. They look at von Neumann subalgebras of the group algebra L(F). Some subalgebras stay fixed under conjugation by the commutator subgroup. The pair ask what form such subalgebras must take. Their answer is tight: each one is L(N) for some normal subgroup N of F.

Along the way they prove a general factoriality test. The test fits groups that are icc and simple. It also needs each faithful ergodic action to be essentially free. Thompson's group F meets those terms. The result pins down how symmetry limits subalgebra shape. It serves readers in operator algebras and group theory.

Catalog record

CREATORTattwamasi Amrutam, Artem Dudko
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.01268

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Relative invariant subalgebra rigidity for Thompson’s group F F Tattwamasi Amrutam, Artem Dudko Abstract . We prove that Thompson’s group F F satisfies the relative invariant subalgebra rigidity property with respect to its commutator subgroup: every von Neumann subalgebra of L ⁡ ( F ) L(F) that is invariant under conjugation by [ F , F ] [F,F] is of the form L ⁡ ( N ) L(N) for some normal subgroup N ​ ⊴ ​ F N\trianglelefteq F . Along the way, we establish a general factoriality criterion for invariant subalgebras whose hypotheses are met whenever the ambient group is i.c.c., simple, and every faithful ergodic measure-preserving action of it on a probability space is essentially free. 1. Introduction The interplay between geometric group theory and Popa’s deformation/rigidity paradigm [ 22 ] has driven substantial advancements in the structural classification of von Neumann algebras arising from countable discrete groups. Within this rich area of study, a prominent line of inquiry focuses on understanding the rigidity phenomena associated with von Neumann subalgebras \mathcal{A}\leq L(\Gamma) that are normalized by the full ambient group \Gamma . Inspired by the pioneering investigations of Chifan and Das [ 12 ] into negatively curved groups, as well as Alekseev and Brugger [ 1 ] on lattices, Kalantar and Panagopoulos [ 20 ] proved a striking structural result. They showed that for irreducible lattices inside higher-rank semisimple Lie groups, any \Gamma -invariant von Neumann subalgebra of L(\Gamma) is trivially generated by a normal subgroup of \Gamma . Building upon these discoveries, the first-named author and Jiang [ 4 ] formally defined the invariant subalgebra rigidity (ISR) property to systematically explore this phenomenon across broader classes of countable discrete groups. By definition, a group \Gamma exhibits the ISR property when every von Neumann subalgebra of L(\Gamma) that is invariant under the conjugation action of \Gamma is canonically of the form L(N) for a certain normal subgroup N\trianglelefteq\Gamma . This conceptual framework has proven highly successful, inspiring a wealth of subsequent generalizations and applications (see, for instance, [ 11 , 13 , 18 , 2 ] ; see also [ 5 ] for the C^{*} -version). In addition, recent contributions by Jiang, Li, and Liu [ 15 , 16 ] have initiated a thorough analysis of the structural behavior of invariant subalgebras even in environments where the ISR property does not hold (also see [ 17 ] ). A related, yet considerably more delicate, avenue of research examines whether such rigid behavior persists when the subalgebra is only assumed to be invariant under conjugation by a proper, non-trivial normal subgroup N\trianglelefteq\Gamma , instead of the entirety of \Gamma . This refined notion is captured by the following definition, recently introduced by the first-named author in [ 6 ] . Definition 1.1 . A countable discrete group \Gamma is said to have the relative ISR property if for every non-trivial normal subgroup N\trianglelefteq\Gamma and every von Neumann subalgebra \mathcal{M}\leq L(\Gamma) invariant under conjugation by N , one has \mathcal{M}=L(K) for some subgroup K\leq\Gamma . In the work [ 6 ] , the first-named author established the relative ISR property for torsion-free acylindrically hyperbolic groups possessing a trivial amenable radical, and irreducible lattices within higher-rank semisimple Lie groups (for example, \mathrm{SL}_{d}(\mathbb{Z}) where d\geq 3 is an odd integer). In both of these contexts, a pivotal feature is that the ambient group is C^{*} -simple. Specifically, in these earlier works, proving that the invariant von Neumann subalgebra is a subfactor (i.e., its center is trivial) constituted an essential intermediate step. This deduction relied fundamentally on the C^{*} -simplicity of the underlying group (see [ 3 ] ). However, when turning our attention to Thompson’s group F —the classic group composed of orientation-preserving piecewise linear homeomorphisms of the unit interval [0,1] with dyadic breakpoints and slopes strictly in \{2^{k}:k\in\mathbb{Z}\} —we encounter a significantly different landscape. It remains a celebrated, long-standing open question whether F is amenable [ 10 ] . We do not even know whether F is C^{*} -simple. As a result, the standard strategy of exploiting C^{*} -simplicity to force the invariant subalgebra to be a factor completely breaks down for this group. To overcome this barrier, we employ a different method. Instead of algebraic C^{*} -simplicity, our new approach relies heavily on topological dynamics, specifically, the notion of compressible actions. Despite its elusive amenability status, F possesses an exceptionally rich internal algebraic structure: its commutator subgroup [F,F] is an infinite simple group [ 8 ] that consists exactly of those homeomorphisms in F acting trivially near the endpoints of [0,1] , and the abelianization F/[F,F] is isomorphic to \mathbb{Z}^{2} . We notice that in [ 13 ] different topological and algebraic properties were used to prove the ISR property for the class of approximately finite groups. The main result of this paper is the following. Theorem 1.2 . Let F denote Thompson’s group, and let \mathcal{M}\leq L(F) be a von Neumann subalgebra invariant under conjugation by the commutator subgroup [F,F] . Then there exists a normal subgroup N\trianglelefteq F such that \mathcal{M}=L(N) . Stated differently, this establishes that Thompson’s group F enjoys the relative ISR property since every non-trivial normal subgroup of F contains its commutator subgroup. In particular, we show that F has the ISR property, a property that was not previously known. Observe that F has the nonfactorizable regular character property , defined in [ 13 ] . However, the results of [ 13 ] do not imply the ISR property for F , since it is not known whether F is non-amenable. The architecture of our proof integrates two primary components of differing natures. The first component is a broadly applicable criterion for factoriality of invariant subalgebras. We show that if \Gamma is any countable, infinite conjugacy class (i.c.c.), simple group where every faithful ergodic probability measure-preserving action happens to be essentially free, then any \Gamma -invariant von Neumann subalgebra of L(\Gamma) must necessarily be a factor (see Theorem 3.2 ). For the specific case of the commutator subgroup [F,F] , this essential freeness requirement is fulfilled by the deep results of the second-named author and Medynets [ 14 ] , who deduced it by proving that the natural topological action of [F,F] on the open interval (0,1) is compressible. This dynamical property serves as our crucial substitute for C^{*} -simplicity in establishing the subfactor condition. The second crucial component is an internal Fourier-analytic boundary technique executed within the algebra L(F) . By observing how elements of \mathcal{M} behave when conjugated by sequences in [F,F] whose spatial supports contract toward the boundary points 0 and 1 , we can express the standard conditional expectation \mathbb{E}_{L([F,F])} as a limit in the weak operator topology. This procedure directly implies that \mathbb{E}_{L([F,F])}(\mathcal{M}) is contained within \mathcal{M} . Consequently, the aforementioned factoriality principle guarantees that the intersection \mathcal{M}\cap L([F,F]) is a subfactor. Because [F,F] is simple, a sharp structural dichotomy emerges. Either L([F,F]) is contained in \mathcal{M} , or the intersection \mathcal{M}\cap L([F,F]) is trivial. In the former scenario, an appeal to the well-known Galois correspondence for intermediate subalgebras of the inclusion L([F,F])\subseteq L(F) swiftly concludes the argument. In the latter scenario, a GNS vanishing technique used in [ 13

Read the complete text