Digital Maturity and Technical Efficiency in NHS Acute Trusts: Cross-Sectional Evidence from England
Ari Ercole, [0.5em] Cambridge Centre for AI in Medicine, University of Cambridge, UK · 2026
Read Digital Maturity and Technical Efficiency in NHS Acute Trusts: Cross-Sectional Evidence from England by Ari Ercole, [0.5em] Cambridge Centre for AI in Medicine, University of Cambridge, UK (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-01137.txt.
Introduction
Ercole links digital maturity to hospital efficiency in England in this 2026 paper. Whether digital health spending lifts hospital productivity is a live policy question. Past evidence is mixed, and causal claims are hard to pin down. He studies NHS acute trusts, the big hospital groups of the English health service, with a Bayesian stochastic frontier model.
The model fits a four input production function to 111 acute non specialist trusts for 2024/25. Inputs come from audited NHS accounts, from clinical staff to capital. A digital maturity score enters the inefficiency side, with controls for deprivation, teaching status, and finances. Higher maturity goes with lower inefficiency, at high posterior confidence. Top quartile trusts operate at 98.0 percent of their production frontier in the estimates. The bottom quartile sits at 93.2 percent for the lowest quartile in the same model. The gap is worth about 20 million pounds per trust, he estimates.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ari Ercole, [0.5em] Cambridge Centre for AI in Medicine, University of Cambridge, UK |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 55 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.01137
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Digital Maturity and Technical Efficiency in NHS Acute Trusts: Cross-Sectional Evidence from England Ari Ercole, [0.5em] Cambridge Centre for AI in Medicine, University of Cambridge, UK Abstract Whether investment in digital health technology is associated with differences in hospital productivity is a question of substantial policy relevance, yet interpretation is constrained by challenges in causal identification and prior evidence is mixed. Technical efficiency in NHS acute hospital trusts in England is estimated using Bayesian stochastic frontier analysis. A four-input Cobb–Douglas production function incorporating clinical full-time equivalents, administrative full-time equivalents, non-labour expenditure, and physical capital derived from audited NHS accounts is fitted to 111 acute non-specialist trusts in 2024/25. Digital maturity, measured by the NHS Digital Maturity Assessment, is included in a trust-specific inefficiency equation alongside population deprivation, teaching status, and financial position controls. The composite digital maturity score is estimated to be negatively associated with technical inefficiency ( γ ^ = − 0.612 \hat{\gamma}=-0.612 , 95% credible interval [ − 1.289 , + 0.005 ] [-1.289,+0.005] , P ( γ < 0 ) = 0.974 P(\gamma<0)=0.974 ). Trusts in the highest digital maturity quartile are estimated to operate at 98.0% of their production frontier compared with 93.2% for the lowest quartile. This gap corresponds to approximately £20 million of additional cost-weighted activity per trust at mean output levels, or £1.1 billion in aggregate. Estimates are robust to functional form but are sensitive to the most conservative prior specification. Pillar-level analysis suggests that population health management and care pathway optimisation domains exhibit stronger associations with efficiency than other domains. Catchment deprivation is not estimated to have an independent association with efficiency after controlling for digital maturity. Keywords: stochastic frontier analysis, digital health, NHS, hospital efficiency, Bayesian inference JEL codes: I10, I18, O33, C11 1 Introduction NHS acute hospitals face sustained pressure to improve productivity within constrained budgets. Capital investment in digital health technology is frequently proposed as a route to efficiency gains, and NHS England’s Digital Transformation programme commits substantial resources on this premise ( 5 ) . Whether such investment translates into measurable productivity improvements at the trust level remains, however, poorly quantified. The theoretical mechanisms through which digital maturity might improve efficiency are well established. Digitally integrated clinical workflows reduce duplicated effort; electronic prescribing reduces medication errors and associated costs; real-time patient flow data supports better bed management; and population health analytics enable preventive pathways that reduce emergency demand. Technology adoption is nonetheless costly, implementation disrupts existing workflows, and benefits may accrue unevenly across organisational contexts. Prior evidence on hospital digital maturity and efficiency is modest and methodologically heterogeneous. Studies from the United States report positive associations between health information technology adoption and financial performance and care quality outcomes ( 2 ) , but the UK context differs substantially in funding mechanisms, incentive structures, and the nature of digital investment. NHS-specific evidence is largely limited to descriptive analyses and aggregate productivity indices that do not control for input usage ( 12 ) . In this paper, the association between digital maturity and technical efficiency is estimated for all NHS acute non-specialist trusts in England in 2024/25 using Bayesian stochastic frontier analysis (SFA). The Battese-Coelli one-stage approach ( 3 ) is adopted to estimate the efficiency equation simultaneously with the production function, avoiding the two-stage bias that arises when efficiency scores are regressed on covariates post-estimation. The model is estimated in a Bayesian framework, allowing prior information and full posterior uncertainty quantification for all parameters. Three contributions are made. First, fully audited financial data from NHS Trust Annual Accounts are used to construct production function inputs, avoiding the cost-approximation assumptions of prior NHS efficiency studies. Second, physical capital is explicitly included as a production function input and its orthogonality to digital maturity is demonstrated empirically, directly addressing a potential confound. Third, a hierarchical Bayesian model is employed for pillar-level digital maturity effects, enabling differential returns across the seven Digital Maturity Assessment domains to be estimated with appropriate uncertainty quantification. 2 Data and Methods 2.1 Sample The analytical sample comprises 111 acute non-specialist NHS trusts in England in 2024/25. Two categories of trust are excluded. Acute specialist trusts (16 organisations) are excluded because their output mix is not comparable to general acute hospitals; such trusts focus on single clinical domains and their cost-weighted activity cannot be placed on a common frontier with general acute providers. Acute multi-service trusts (7 organisations) are excluded because they provide integrated acute and community care services under a single organisational structure. Their total operating expenditure, as recorded in NHS Trust Annual Accounts, therefore encompasses community nursing, social care liaison, and other non-acute activities, while the CWA captures only acute hospital activity. This creates a systematic input-output mismatch: inputs are inflated by community service costs that generate no measured output, producing spuriously low efficiency estimates that reflect the accounting structure rather than productive performance. A ratio of total operating expenditure to cost-weighted activity of up to 2.1 is observed in this group, compared with approximately 1.0–1.1 for standard acute trusts. Both exclusions are defined a priori on grounds of comparability rather than on observed results. The remaining sample covers all acute large, medium, small, and teaching trust subtypes as classified by the NHS England Oversight Framework ( 8 ) . 2.2 Output The output measure is MFF-adjusted cost-weighted activity (CWA) from the NHS National Cost Collection 2024/25 ( 7 ) . CWA aggregates healthcare resource group activity weighted by national reference costs and adjusted for the Market Forces Factor to account for input price variation across geographies. It is a standard output measure in NHS productivity analysis ( 4 ) . 2.3 Inputs Four inputs are included in the production function. Clinical full-time equivalents (FTE) comprises medical staff plus professionally qualified clinical non-medical staff, sourced from NHS Electronic Staff Records (ESR) September 2024 ( 10 ) . Administrative FTE comprises support to clinical staff and NHS infrastructure support from the same source. Non-labour expenditure (NLE) is computed as total operating expenditure minus actual staff costs, with both components derived from NHS Trust Annual Accounts (TAC) 2024/25 ( 9 ) , ensuring that a common accounting framework is used for both numerator and denominator. Physical capital is the sum of property, plant and equipment and right-of-use assets from TAC balance sheet data. All inputs are log-transformed and centred at their sample means; centring improves sampler geometry without affecting the elasticity interpretation of coefficients. 2.4 Digital Maturity Digital maturity is measured by the NHS Digital Maturity Assessment (DMA) 2025 ( 6 ) , a structured self-assessment covering seven domains (‘pillars’): Well-Led, Smart Foundations, Safe Practice, Support Workforce, Empower People, Improve Care, and Healthy Populations. Domain scores are averaged to form a composite score, which is standardised to zero mean and unit variance before inclusion in the model. It is acknowledged that the DMA is a survey instrument and may not fully capture operational digital capability. In particular, organisations with long-standing clinical system investment may be underscored relative to externally validated measures such as the HIMSS Electronic Medical Record Adoption Model, potentially attenuating estimated efficiency effects toward zero. A previous Digital Maturity Assessment was conducted in 2023/24. The 2024/25 assessment is used here as it incorporated revised question sets