A Per-Component Diagnostic Protocol for Neural HJB-PIDE Solvers under Control-Dependent Lévy Jumps

R. Drissi · 2026

Read A Per-Component Diagnostic Protocol for Neural HJB-PIDE Solvers under Control-Dependent Lévy Jumps by R. Drissi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-01122.txt.

Introduction

Drissi offers a protocol to catch quiet bugs inside neural PDE solvers in this 2026 paper. A learned solution can match headline scores while miscomputing an operator inside its own loss. Longer training and finer grids will not reveal such a flaw. His target is solvers for Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equations with jumps, where the control itself shapes the Lévy jumps.

The protocol runs five steps. Each neural solve pairs with a from scratch reference solver. The Hamiltonian splits into drift, diffusion, compensator, and nonlocal parts, compared piece by piece. Value functions and their low derivatives face off on a grid before any control is compared. On a stock finance benchmark, the hunt isolates a missing half mixture factor. It had scaled the nonlocal integral by exactly half. With the bug fixed, four unlike solvers agree on the optimal control to within about two percent.

Catalog record

CREATORR. Drissi
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE90 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.01122

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Per-Component Diagnostic Protocol for Neural HJB-PIDE Solvers under Control-Dependent Lévy Jumps R. Drissi Abstract We propose a five-step diagnostic protocol for residual-trained neural HJB-PIDE solvers with control-dependent Lévy jumps, targeting a general failure mode of neural PDE methods: a learned solution can match headline scalar diagnostics while miscomputing an operator inside its training loss. The protocol pairs each neural solve with at least one from-scratch independent reference, decomposes the Hamiltonian into drift, diffusion, compensator, and nonlocal-integral components across a u u -grid, and compares the value function and its low-order derivatives over a ( t , x ) (t,x) grid before any argmax comparison. Applied to a standard CRRA-Merton-Variance-Gamma benchmark, it isolates a missing 1 2 \tfrac{1}{2} -mixture factor in the neural method’s importance-proposal density that scaled the nonlocal integral by exactly half — a textbook signature of a constant proposal scale error, invisible to longer training, grid refinement, and truncation sweeps. With the bug corrected, four references — two finite-difference solvers with disjoint discretizations, the neural solver, and a semi-analytic scalar baseline obtained from CRRA homogeneity — agree on the optimal control to within ∼ 2 % \sim 2\% . The constant-coefficient CRRA benchmark collapses by homogeneity to a scalar maximization, so the scalar baseline is the efficient method here; the contribution is the protocol, applicable in principle to non-homogeneous and higher-dimensional settings where neural HJB-PIDE solvers are genuinely needed. The episode is a concrete instance of a broader neural-PDE verification failure: pointwise agreement of a learned value or control can coexist with a systematically wrong nonlocal operator, so per-component and surface-level checks are needed before trusting the argmax policy. Scope of Contribution. This paper makes a methodological contribution: a diagnostic protocol for catching nonlocal-integral failures in neural HJB-PIDE solvers, demonstrated end-to-end on a Variance Gamma portfolio benchmark by isolating and fixing a real bug in our own implementation. We do not claim a general high-dimensional HJB theory, a viscosity-solution convergence proof, a novel neural architecture, an empirical downside-protection result, or a fresh truncation/MC-sample convergence study. The constant-coefficient CRRA-Merton-VG benchmark used here reduces by homogeneity to a scalar maximization (§ 2.4 ); we present neural and FD solutions of this benchmark only as the test object for the diagnostic protocol, and explicitly do not advocate them as efficient methods for this problem class. 1 Introduction Residual-trained neural solvers are increasingly used for Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman partial integro-differential equations (HJB-PIDEs) under Lévy jump dynamics, where classical grid-based methods scale poorly with state dimension and require off-grid evaluation of the value function inside the nonlocal integral ( 4 ; 1 ) . A persistent difficulty in evaluating such solvers is that the natural diagnostic — does the method recover the diffusion-only Merton ratio? — is necessary but far from sufficient: it leaves the entire control-dependent jump term uncovered. This paper proposes a per-component diagnostic protocol that does cover that term, and demonstrates on a standard Variance Gamma portfolio benchmark that single-method diagnostics (longer training, finite-difference grid refinement, truncation sweeps, training-loss curves) can leave a real bug in the nonlocal-integral build undetected, while a per-component comparison against an independent reference catches it cleanly. This places the problem in the broader scientific-machine-learning literature on failure modes of physics-informed and residual-trained neural PDE solvers ( 10 ) : the issue is not only whether a network class is expressive enough, but whether the residual loss correctly represents the operator being optimized and whether standard scalar diagnostics can detect operator-level errors. When the controlled state process includes jumps, the HJB equation becomes a partial integro-differential equation (PIDE): \partial_{t}V+\sup_{u\in\mathcal{U}}\left\{\mathcal{L}^{u}V+\mathcal{I}^{u}V\right\}=0 (1) where \mathcal{L}^{u} is the differential operator (drift and diffusion) and \mathcal{I}^{u} is the nonlocal integral operator . Throughout this paper the state is wealth X_{t} with multiplicative jump dynamics (§ 2 ), so \mathcal{I}^{u} takes the compensated multiplicative form \mathcal{I}^{u}V(t,x)=\int_{\mathbb{R}\setminus\{0\}}\left[V(t,x(1+uz))-V(t,x)-xuz\,\partial_{x}V(t,x)\right]\nu(\mathrm{d}z), (2) representing the expected change in value from jumps. Here \nu is the Lévy measure characterizing the jump structure, and the multiplicative shift x\mapsto x(1+uz) reflects the wealth dynamics: a relative jump z in the risky asset moves wealth by factor (1+uz) , scaling with the position u . The integral ( 2 ) poses significant computational challenges: 1. Infinite activity : For processes like Variance Gamma (VG) or Normal-Inverse Gaussian (NIG), \nu(\mathbb{R})=\infty —infinitely many small jumps occur in any time interval. The neural method and the FD-PIDE baseline both work with a small-jump truncation |z|\geq z_{\min} ; we discuss the resulting truncation bias and its analytic decay rate in § 3.3 , but do not report a fresh z_{\min} convergence sweep — the audited solver and reference comparison are both fixed at the bankruptcy-safe truncation |z|\in[0.01,0.99] , and a controlled z_{\min} sensitivity study is left for follow-up work. 2. Control dependence : The jump displacement x\mapsto x(1+uz) depends on the control u , coupling the optimization with the integral 3. Grid dependence : Classical methods require repeated off-grid evaluation of the value function, and this becomes especially difficult once the control enters the jump displacement Why control-dependent jumps are hard. The displacement x\mapsto x(1+uz) in ( 2 ) couples the control u with the nonlocal operator, creating difficulties for classical methods: (i) Grid-based schemes require interpolating V(t,x(1+uz)) at off-grid points for each control candidate, destroying the banded structure of finite-difference matrices. (ii) Finite-difference Jacobians for the coupled system become dense, as the jump integral links all grid points. (iii) Standard PINNs need to evaluate the shifted argument x(1+uz) inside the residual loss; when u is itself a learned function, this shifted argument is a state-and-parameter-dependent point at which V_{\theta} must be queried, and the corresponding gradient flows through both the network and the policy. Our neural approach handles this directly: the network V_{\theta} is evaluated at arbitrary (t,x(1+uz)) via forward pass, and the control u_{\phi} is jointly optimized through the shared loss. Our contribution is a methodological one: a per-component diagnostic protocol that catches nonlocal-integral failures in residual-trained neural HJB-PIDE solvers. The protocol does not depend on any specific solver architecture; we demonstrate it on one residual-trained neural solver and one FD-PIDE benchmark, and use it to discover and fix a real bug in our own implementation. The same protocol is designed to transfer to other Lévy specifications (NIG, CGMY) and to non-homogeneous problems where neural HJB-PIDE solvers are genuinely needed (consumption with utility, transaction costs, regime-switching); we do not claim to have demonstrated transfer here. Protocol 1 (Per-component diagnostic for neural HJB-PIDE solvers). 1. Same equation. State the HJB-PIDE, admissible set \mathcal{U} , and Lévy truncation |z|\in[z_{\min},z_{\max}] explicitly; require all solvers under comparison to share them exactly. 2. Independent reference. Build at least one from-scratch reference implementation with disjoint numerical choices (different coordinate system, time integrator, quadrature rule, argmax routine, boundary handling). Unit-test on closed-form integrands. 3. Per-component decomposition. Tabulate the Hamiltonian’s drift, diffusion, compensator, and nonlocal-integral terms separately as functions of the candidate control u . A constant ratio \neq 1 between solvers in any one component is the textbook signature of a proposal-density scale error. 4. Surface comparison before argmax. Compare V , \partial_{x}V , \partial_{xx}V over a (t,x) grid against the reference before comparing argmax controls. Headline-only matching can hide \partial_{xx}V errors that dominate the diffusion term of \mathcal{H} . 5. Trust

Read the complete text