A tunable feedback-controlled magnetic trap for a magnet in free fall
Changhao Xu, Alexander Heidt, Mohammadreza Nematollahi, Christoph Lotz, Ernst Maria Rasel, Yan Liu, Wei Ji, Dmitry Budker · 2026
Read A tunable feedback-controlled magnetic trap for a magnet in free fall by Changhao Xu, Alexander Heidt, Mohammadreza Nematollahi, Christoph Lotz, Ernst Maria Rasel, Yan Liu, Wei Ji, Dmitry Budker (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-01056.txt.
Introduction
Xu and co-authors trap a falling magnet with feedback control in this 2026 physics paper. A free ferromagnet should show pure Larmor precession in near zero field. That motion could serve fine magnetometry and gyroscopy, and probe deep physics. No one has yet seen it in a macroscopic particle. True free fall is needed, since clamps leak energy and skew the read.
The trap must be weak enough to fake free fall yet tough enough to survive launch. Their design pairs a PID controlled coil set with a master control coil. It flew in the Einstein-Elevator drop tower. In the microgravity phase, the trap held a ferromagnetic particle steady against shocks up to 1.5 g and tracked its motion in both trials. One trial ran a low field setup, and one ran pure free fall. The work is a step toward free fall ferromagnetic sensors in space.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Changhao Xu, Alexander Heidt, Mohammadreza Nematollahi, Christoph Lotz, Ernst Maria Rasel, Yan Liu, Wei Ji, Dmitry Budker |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 25 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.01056
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A tunable feedback-controlled magnetic trap for a magnet in free fall Changhao Xu, Alexander Heidt, Mohammadreza Nematollahi, Christoph Lotz, Ernst Maria Rasel, Yan Liu, Wei Ji, Dmitry Budker Abstract Ferromagnets in free space are predicted to exhibit pure Larmor precession at near-zero magnetic fields and provide exceptional sensitivity for magnetometry and gyroscopy. Notably, pure Larmor precession has not been observed in a macroscopic ferromagnetic particle, despite its fundamental importance and potential for probing relativistic effects and dark-matter interactions. Realizing such dynamics requires true free fall to eliminate clamping losses and trap-induced systematics. A central challenge is designing a tunable trap that is weak enough to permit near-free evolution yet robust enough to withstand the disturbances of launch and release. Here, we propose and demonstrate a novel master proportional-integral-differential magnetic trap (MPIDMT) combining a PID-controlled coil system with a master control coil system. Implemented in the third-generation drop tower - Einstein-Elevator, during the microgravity phase the system stably levitates a ferromagnetic particle against shock accelerations up to 1.5 g and resolves its motion in both a low-field (0.4 g) configuration and in pure free fall. These results represent a key step toward free-fall ferromagnetic magnetometry, the long-sought direct observation of macroscopic Larmor precession, and future space-based experiments. Introduction – Precision measurement of magnetic fields is crucial across a wide range of sciences, from life sciences—such as detecting brain activities and cardiac signals Boto et al. 2018 ; Cohen 1972 ; Aslam et al. 2023 —to fundamental physics, including searches for phenomena beyond the Standard Model Wei et al. 2023 ; Xu et al. 2024 ; Ji et al. 2018 ; Cong et al. 2025 . Ferromagnetic sensors have been predicted to achieve unprecedented sensitivity because the strong spin correlations within a ferromagnet can substantially suppress spin-projection noise, which is the fundamental noise source limiting atomic magnetometers Kimball et al. 2016 ; Band et al. 2018 ; Vinante et al. 2021 ; Ni et al. 2025 . Moreover, a ferromagnetic magnetometer can operate under ambient conditions Ji et al. 2025 , unlike the highly-sensitive spin-exchange-relaxation-free (SERF) magnetometers that require stringent magnetic shielding, or superconducting quantum interferometer devices (SQUID) that must be cooled to cryogenic temperatures Allred et al. 2002 ; Clarke and Braginski 2006 . In order to achieve the optimum performance of the magnet, the ferromagnet must be mechanically isolated from its surroundings so that it can move freely without clamping or contact forces. On Earth, this necessitates levitation, achieved by counteracting gravity through techniques such as superconducting levitation Wang et al. 2019 ; Vinante et al. 2020 ; Ahrens et al. 2024 , diamagnetically stabilized magnetic levitation Simon et al. 2001 ; Ji et al. 2025 ; Leng et al. 2024 , or magnetic Paul-trap levitation Perdriat et al. 2023 . Each approach, however, introduces unwanted effects—such as residual magnetic fields or dynamical noise from the trap itself. To reach the sensitivity limit of the magnet, it must ideally operate in a free-fall or near-free-fall state, where the trapping field and trap-induced noise are minimized Kimball et al. 2016 . The free-fall condition further enables the observation of the precession of a macroscopic particle whose angular momentum is dominated by quantum-mechanical spin Kimball et al. 2016 ; Fadeev et al. 2021a ; Fadeev et al. 2021b . Thus far, only indirect evidence of this effect has been reported Ahrens and Vinante 2025 . A free-falling magnet also provides an opportunity to probe tidal effects induced by gravitational waves on spin systems Domcke et al. 2025 in a genuine transverse–traceless (TT) gauge, and to experimentally examine the corresponding geodesic deviation predicted in the TT framework. Achieving such conditions presents two major challenges. First, creating and sustaining a microgravity environment is far more demanding than a tabletop setup. Second, the system must remain stably confined in the presence of residual random accelerations and noise introduced by free-fall platforms such as drop towers, sounding rockets, and space stations. Magnetic traps based on a PID-controlled coil were previously used to levitate magnets on Earth Yadav et al. 2016 ; El Hajjaji and Ouladsine 2002 ; Saitoh et al. 2020 ; Morikawa et al. 2004 . However, such a configuration cannot operate under free-fall conditions, as we discuss here. In this work, we design and demonstrate a composite magnetic trap, a master-PID magnetic trap (MPIDMT) combining a PID-controlled coil system with a master control coil system. The system operates reliably under accelerations ranging from microgravity (free fall) to 2.5 g (effectively, simulated in the lab) and can be finely tuned to compensate for acceleration shocks as high as 1.5 g, with the potential for even higher stability in future experiments. We carried out the first free-fall tests of this system using a third-generation drop-tower facility, the Einstein-Elevator in Hannover Lotz 2022 . During the microgravity phase, the magnet was successfully trapped and remained stable in a weak filed configuration (effectively 0.4 g). Unlike mechanical methods, which may introduce electrostatic effects when releasing the magnet, the MPIDMT approach enables the magnet to enter pure free fall by removing the trapping fields without inducing a noticeable transient impulse. These results demonstrate the robustness of the trapping scheme and confirm that it operates reliably under both free-fall and high-acceleration–noise conditions. This achievement represents an important milestone toward next-generation magnetic sensing and paves the way for future demonstrations in space-based platforms. PID controlled magnetic trap – A PID-based magnetic trap is a widely used approach for achieving magnetic levitation Yadav et al. 2016 ; El Hajjaji and Ouladsine 2002 ; Saitoh et al. 2020 ; Morikawa et al. 2004 . Compared with passive schemes, active PID control enables much faster stabilization of the magnet and offers precise, flexible tuning of key trapping parameters, including the resonance frequency, damping rate, and trap-center position. Such rapid and programmable stabilization is especially crucial in free-fall experiments, for instance, in the drop tower, where the system must endure a 5 g acceleration and braking phase for each 0.5 s. We used a conventional PID-controlled magnetic trap illustrated in Fig. 1 (with an additional lower master coil, which is specific to our composite-trap configuration). The upper PID-controlled (slave) coil is used to generate a vertical magnetic field to orientate the magnetic moment of the levitated magnet, while its field gradient exerts an upward magnetic force that balances gravity. A laser beam with a diameter larger than the magnet is directed onto the magnet so that the transmitted portion reaches a position-sensitive quadrant photodetector (QPD). The magnet casts a shadow on the transmitted beam, and any displacement of the magnet results in a corresponding change in the light intensity pattern on the QPD. The resulting voltage signal is therefore sensitive to the position of the magnet. Figure 1: Experimental setup in the Einstein-Elevator . (a) Schematic of the setup with the master-PID magnetic trap (MPIDMT). A magnet is levitated between an upper slave coil and a lower master coil. The quadrant photodetector (QPD) is for position feedback. (b) Top: a photograph of the experimental setup inside the Einstein-Elevator. The optical and PID control units and the silver-colored cylindrical magnetic shield are mounted on the carrier and are shown at the center. Bottom: side view of