Partial Identification under High-Dimensional Potential Outcomes and Confounders via Optimal Transport

Yunfeng Wang, Zhiheng Zhang 🖂, Zijun Gao · 2026

Read Partial Identification under High-Dimensional Potential Outcomes and Confounders via Optimal Transport by Yunfeng Wang, Zhiheng Zhang 🖂, Zijun Gao (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-00847.txt.

Introduction

Wang, Zhang, and Gao bound cause and effect when exact answers are barred in this 2026 paper. Partial identification gives honest ranges for causal effects instead of false points. Optimal transport is a base tool for such bounds. But it breaks down when outcomes and confounders are both high-dimensional. Costs explode and rates turn poor.

Their estimator splits the transport task in two. A low-dimensional signal subspace carries the main flow. The rest is a high-dimensional residual subspace, whose lost energy past methods threw away. They recover that energy with the Sliced Wasserstein distance, which stays cheap and robust in high dimensions. Clear conditions bound the gap their split creates. A data-driven rule picks the signal size. In tests, the authors report, the method beats projection-only baselines. It yields tighter causal bounds and stays tractable at scale.

Catalog record

CREATORYunfeng Wang, Zhiheng Zhang 🖂, Zijun Gao
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE74 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.00847

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Partial Identification under High-Dimensional Potential Outcomes and Confounders via Optimal Transport Yunfeng Wang, Zhiheng Zhang 🖂, Zijun Gao Abstract Partial identification provides informative causal guarantees when point identification is impossible, but existing approaches based on optimal transport (OT) become computationally and statistically intractable in high-dimensional settings. This limitation is particularly severe when both potential outcomes and confounders are high-dimensional, where classical OT-based bounds suffer from the curse of dimensionality and unfavorable convergence rates. To address this challenge, we propose a novel estimator that decomposes the transport problem into a low-dimensional signal subspace and a high-dimensional residual subspace. Unlike existing projection-based methods that discard residual information, we recover the residual transport energy using the Sliced Wasserstein distance, which is computationally efficient and robust to high dimensions. We establish interpretable conditions controlling the approximation gap based on residual structure and provide a data-driven rule for signal dimension selection. Empirical results show that our estimator consistently outperforms projection-only baselines by recovering lost transport energy, yielding more informative causal bounds while remaining computationally tractable in high dimensions. 1 Introduction Causal inference aims to quantify the effect of interventions from incomplete data. In many settings, point identification is unattainable: causal estimands depend on the joint law of potential outcomes, while the observed data only reveal marginal or conditionally marginal distributions. This places a broad class of problems in the domain of partial identification (PI), where the goal is to characterize the set of causal effects consistent with observed information and minimal structural assumptions. Partial identification plays a central role in modern causal analysis, providing robustness against untestable assumptions and enabling principled decision-making under ambiguity. Pre-treatment covariates can substantially tighten PI sets by restricting the feasible dependence between counterfactual variables. Recently, a series of works has established a deep connection between covariate-assisted PI and optimal transport (OT). Model-agnostic inference frameworks based on OT duality deliver valid causal bounds even when conditional distributions are estimated imprecisely, and admit doubly robust extensions in observational studies ( 7 ) . Related work shows that covariate-assisted PI can be characterized through conditional optimal transport (COT), and that tight relaxations reduce COT to standard OT with explicit penalties, yielding increasingly sharp bounds ( 9 ) . A fundamental difficulty—discontinuity of COT under weak convergence—has been resolved by establishing continuity under adapted Wasserstein topologies, leading to consistent nonparametric estimation of optimal causal bounds ( 8 ) . Together, these results identify conditional transport discrepancies as the correct geometric objects for covariate-assisted PI. Despite this progress, a critical challenge remains. In modern applications, covariates and learned representations are often high-dimensional, while conditional OT functionals are notoriously difficult to estimate reliably in such regimes. Conditioning further reduces effective sample sizes, and direct plug-in estimation of conditional Wasserstein or COT quantities can be statistically unstable or computationally prohibitive. As a result, existing covariate-assisted OT methods face a common failure mode in practice: either the bounds become overly conservative due to coarse stratification, or they rely on modeling assumptions that undermine robustness. This reveals a key research gap: how to construct dimension-adaptive, statistically stable transport quantities that can be used within covariate-assisted PI frameworks without sacrificing theoretical validity . We address this gap by developing a conditioned, dimension-adaptive lower bound for quadratic Wasserstein distances in high-dimensional settings. Our approach is motivated by the observation that, in many causal problems, distributional differences between treatment and control are anisotropic and concentrated on a low-dimensional subspace, with the remaining high-dimensional variation behaving approximately isotropically. Building on this structure, we propose a conditioned subspace–slicing (CSS) decomposition. It combines a projected Wasserstein term on a learned low-dimensional signal subspace with a scaled sliced-Wasserstein correction on the residual space. This estimates the difficult transport component in low dimension while recovering residual energy through one-dimensional projections. Our first main result shows that this quantity yields a valid conditional lower bound. To formalize when the bound is informative, we introduce an extended spiked transport model (ESTM), which generalizes spiked covariance models to optimal transport. Under ESTM, transport energy concentrates on a low-dimensional signal subspace, and we show that Wasserstein projection pursuit (WPP) recovers this subspace as the optimizer of the CSS bound. The remaining gap between the true Wasserstein distance and the optimized lower bound is governed by a single residual anisotropy term. A key and somewhat counterintuitive insight is that, once appropriately scaled, random one-dimensional projections can recover the full residual transport energy when the residual component is close to isotropic. This yields a principled “free lunch”: replacing a high-dimensional transport problem with a combination of low-dimensional OT and inexpensive sliced computations, without loosening the bound under mild conditions. We complement the population theory with a finite-sample analysis. We propose a practical estimator based on WPP for the signal term and Monte Carlo sliced Wasserstein estimation for the residual, and derive nonasymptotic error bounds that depend on intrinsic transport dimension rather than ambient dimension. Our contribution is complementary to existing covariate-assisted PI frameworks: while prior work focuses on inferential robustness, relaxation tightness, and topological consistency, we provide a dimension-adaptive geometric primitive that can be plugged into these pipelines when high dimensionality makes direct conditional transport estimation fragile. Our main contributions are summarized as follows: • We introduce a conditioned subspace–slicing lower bound for quadratic Wasserstein distances, serving as the partial identification region, and yielding certified conditional and unconditional transport lower bounds in high dimensions. • We formalize an extended spiked transport model under which the bound is near-tight and the optimal subspace is identified by Wasserstein projection pursuit. • We develop finite-sample estimators with nonasymptotic error guarantees that scale with intrinsic rather than ambient dimension. Organization. Section 2 reviews Wasserstein distance, projection pursuit, and sliced Wasserstein distances. Section 3 develops the conditioned subspace–slicing bound and its structural properties, and further presents finite-sample estimators together with nonasymptotic error bounds. Section 4 presents the experiments on synthetic data. Section A collects proofs. 1.1 Literature Review and Positioning Partial identification and covariate assistance. Partial identification provides a principled response to the fact that many causal estimands depend on counterfactual joint laws that are not determined by the observed distribution. Classical work characterizes identified sets under minimal restrictions and highlights the role of auxiliary information in tightening bounds; see, e.g., 11 and 6 . In contemporary applications, covariate information is often rich and continuous, so “conditioning to tighten bounds” becomes an infinite-dimensional operation that must be handled with care: naïve stratification is conservative, while fully parametric modeling may sacrifice robustness ( 19 ; 18 ; 17 ; 16 ) . OT-based formulations of covariate-assisted causal bounds. A recent line of work has established that many covariate-assisted PI problems admit a natural representation in terms of optimal transport (OT) and its conditional variants. 7 develop a model-agnostic approach to inference for covariate-assisted partially identified effects, leveraging OT duality to obtain valid procedures that remain meaningful even when conditional nuisance components are difficult to estimate. Complementarily, 9 show that covariate-assisted sharp bounds can be characterized through conditional optimal transport (COT), and propose covariate-aware transport relaxations that reduce COT to standard OT with an explicit penalty, yielding systematically tighter causal bounds as the penalty increases. A further difficulty is that conditional transport functionals can behave pathologically under weak convergence; 8

Read the complete text