Partial Fairness Awareness: Belief-Guided Strategic Mechanism for Strategic Agents
Xinpeng Lv, Chunyuan Zheng, Yunxin Mao, Renzhe Xu, Hao Zou, Shanzhi Gu, Liyang Xu, Huan Chen, Yuanlong Chen, Wenjing Yang, Haotian Wang, [6pt] National University of Defense Technology, Changsha, China · 2026
Read Partial Fairness Awareness: Belief-Guided Strategic Mechanism for Strategic Agents by Xinpeng Lv, Chunyuan Zheng, Yunxin Mao, Renzhe Xu, Hao Zou, Shanzhi Gu, Liyang Xu, Huan Chen, Yuanlong Chen, Wenjing Yang, Haotian Wang, [6pt] National University of Defense Technology, Changsha, China (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-00826.txt.
Introduction
Lv and co-authors study fairness when people game a decision system in this 2026 paper. In strategic classification, applicants tweak their traits to win a good call. Fairness rules by group can clash with that gaming. If the rules are public, agents can exploit them and fairness can flip. If the rules stay secret, welfare can fall and honest effort can fade.
Their fix is partial fairness awareness. The system posts the candidate set of fairness rules but hides which one is in force. Agents keep a belief spread over the set. Round by round, feedback updates that belief toward the true rule. This belief-guided dance lets agents improve in ways the system wants. Tests on real and synthetic data show a smaller group fairness gap, the authors report. The work threads a path between full openness and full secrecy in fair design.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Xinpeng Lv, Chunyuan Zheng, Yunxin Mao, Renzhe Xu, Hao Zou, Shanzhi Gu, Liyang Xu, Huan Chen, Yuanlong Chen, Wenjing Yang, Haotian Wang, [6pt] National University of Defense Technology, Changsha, China |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.00826
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Partial Fairness Awareness: Belief-Guided Strategic Mechanism for Strategic Agents Xinpeng Lv, Chunyuan Zheng, Yunxin Mao, Renzhe Xu, Hao Zou, Shanzhi Gu, Liyang Xu, Huan Chen, Yuanlong Chen, Wenjing Yang, Haotian Wang, [6pt] National University of Defense Technology, Changsha, China Abstract Strategic machine learning investigates scenarios where agents manipulate their features to receive favorable decisions from predictive models. To address fairness concerns intrinsic to strategic classification, recent work has introduced group-specific fairness constraints. However, current fairness-aware approaches face a fundamental dilemma in the issue of fairness exposure: making these constraints public enables strategic manipulation and can lead to fairness reversal, while keeping them hidden may reduce social welfare and discourage genuine improvement. To fill this gap, we subsequently propose the problem of P artial F airness A wareness (PFA), as our theoretical analysis informs that such a dilemma can be mitigated by releasing the candidate set of fairness constraints and concealing the grounding constraint. To be specific, we introduce a belief-guided strategic mechanism , wherein agents iteratively interact with the decision system and maintain a belief distribution over the candidate set of fairness constraints. This belief-guided process enables agents, through iterative interaction and feedback, to update their belief distribution over the candidate set, thereby gradually aligning their belief with the grounding fairness constraint employed by the system. Extensive experiments on real-world and synthetic datasets demonstrate that PFA achieves lower group fairness gaps, higher acceptance of truly qualified individuals, and more stable outcomes compared to fully public or private fairness regimes. 1 Introduction Machine learning models are increasingly deployed in decision-making domains such as hiring 37 , credit scoring 22 , and college admissions 24 . In these scenarios, individuals (agents) often engage in strategic manipulation of their features to obtain favorable outcomes. As noted by Goodhart’s Law 42 , “ When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure ,” such gaming behaviors can undermine the reliability of decision models. For example, a loan applicant might temporarily inflate their reported income to appear more creditworthy. To ensure robustness towards the strategic manipulations, the strategic classification (SC) framework 17 has been developed to model Stackelberg-style interaction between model designers and strategic agents 14 ; 41 ; 6 , aiming to maintain predictive accuracy under adversarial conditions. Despite the remarkable progress of the SC framework in robustness, practical deployment also necessitates careful consideration of fairness for sensitive attributes or historically disadvantaged groups. In particular, a model resistant to gaming may still systematically disadvantage certain groups, i.e., exhibiting unfairness . For example, even if a hiring platform exhibits robustness to manipulation, historical biases embedded in the data might lead to unfair judgment towards female applicants, reflecting and reinforcing social inequities 54 ; 55 . To address the fairness concern in strategic-robust decision models , a growing body of work has incorporated group fairness constraints, such as demographic parity 54 , equality of opportunity 36 , and predictive parity 8 , into strategic classification, typically through fairness-aware decision rules adapted for different groups 55 ; 40 . (a) Public Fairness (b) Private Fairness (c) Partial Fairness with Belief-guided Figure 1 : An illustration for the fairness challenge in strategic classification. (a) Public fairness allows strategic behavior from advantaged agents, leading to fairness reversal (left) . (b) Private fairness avoids manipulation but rejects qualified individuals, causing social welfare loss (center) . (c) Our belief-guided strategic mechanism enables sequential learning for agents with partial fairness, improving group welfare and preventing fairness reversal (right) . However, most concurrent efforts focus on designing more effective fairness mechanisms which is fully public to agents, while overlooking a more fundamental consideration: whether and how fairness constraints should be exposed to agents . In practice, different exposure of the fairness constraints results in divergent subsequent fairness mechanism design, leading to different algorithmic choices and social welfare variation. On the one hand, in the case of fully public constraints, previous theories already point out the unexpected phenomenon of fairness reversal 12 (public fairness in Figure 1(a) ), where advantaged individuals manipulate based on the exposed fairness constraints. Hence, the reverse effect of fairness occurs, as the intended benefits for disadvantaged groups are conversely further undermined. On the other hand, when the fairness constraints are fully concealed (private fairness in Figure 1(b) ), our theoretical analysis proves that the social welfare, i.e., the acceptance rate of the qualified individuals, will decrease. Subsequently, reinforcing concealed fairness constraints leads to less incentivized model design, violating the principle of incentive alignment 15 . Combining the two sides, concurrent approaches on strategic fairness reveal a fundamental dilemma : Fully public constraints can lead to fairness reversals and exacerbate inequality, while fully private constraints risk reducing overall social welfare. To address this dilemma, we introduce the novel problem Partial Fairness Awareness (PFA), a trade-off that balances the extremes of full transparency and privacy in fairness-aware strategic classification. In PFA, only a candidate set of fairness constraints is released to agents while the grounding constraint remains concealed. To fill this gap, we design a belief-guided strategic mechanism , where agents sequentially interact with the decision system and maintain a belief distribution over the candidate fairness constraints. At each round of interaction, the agent selects its optimal manipulation strategy based on its current belief, and updates the belief distribution with the feedback from the system (as shown in Figure 1(c) ). As interactions proceed, this sequential learning process enables the agents to gradually infer and align with the actual (grounding) fairness constraint employed by the system. Our theory and empirical results demonstrate that this belief-guided mechanism effectively mitigates fairness reversal and improves social group welfare. Our main contributions are summarized as follows: • We conduct a systematic theoretical analysis of the fundamental dilemma between public and private disclosure of fairness constraints in strategic classification. To address the limitations of these two extremes, we formulate a novel problem of Partial Fairness Awareness (PFA) . • To tackle the PFA problem, we design a belief-guided strategic mechanism , formally modeled via Bayesian inference. We rigorously prove that, under this mechanism, agents’ beliefs converge to the true fairness constraint employed by the system, thereby improving both group fairness and overall social welfare. • Extensive experiments on both synthetic and real-world datasets demonstrate that the PFA mechanism significantly outperforms conventional approaches based on fully public or fully private fairness constraints, with respect to fairness, social welfare, and predictive accuracy. 2 Related Work 2.1 Strategic Machine Learning Strategic classification 17 studies settings where individuals manipulate their features to influence model outcomes 9 ; 39 ; 6 ; 19 ; 57 ; 44 ; 28 ; 27 ; 29 . Several works address challenges arising from unknown manipulations or limited agent information 38 ; 14 ; 50 . Recent studies incorporate causal reasoning into strategic learning 31 ; 5 ; 20 ; 45 ; 10 ; 4 ; 51 ; 47 ; 46 , distinguishing between manipulable and genuinely improvable features. This line of work emphasizes how strategic responses may reflect or distort true underlying qualifications. Relatedly, performative prediction 35 ; 16 ; 18 ; 30 ; 33 analyzes how predictive models influence the data distribution over time through repeated deployment. A complementary