Theory for the Rydberg states of helium: quantum defect extensions and comparison with experiment up to n = 102 n=102 for the singlet and triplet P P -states
G. W. F. Drake 1,∗, Aaron T. Bondy 2 · 2026
Read Theory for the Rydberg states of helium: quantum defect extensions and comparison with experiment up to n = 102 n=102 for the singlet and triplet P P -states by G. W. F. Drake 1,∗, Aaron T. Bondy 2 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-00814.txt.
Introduction
Drake and Bondy refine the theory of helium's Rydberg states in this 2026 physics paper. Rydberg states place one electron far from the core. The pair compute energies with high-precision variational methods in Hylleraas coordinates. They blend quantum defect expansions for the base energy with series for relativistic and QED shifts.
Direct work up to principal quantum number 35 lets them project singlet and triplet P-state energies up to n of 102. The error stays under one kilohertz. They then mix the values with 28 measured transition frequencies. This pins the ionization energy of a key triplet state at a sharp value. That value sits 0.474 megahertz from theory, with a small error bar. The gap backs a prior 9-sigma clash between theory and experiment. The paper also justifies the quantum defect method from first principles. It traces recoil terms that fall as one over n squared.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | G. W. F. Drake 1,∗, Aaron T. Bondy 2 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 80 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.00814
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Theory for the Rydberg states of helium: quantum defect extensions and comparison with experiment up to n = 102 n=102 for the singlet and triplet P P -states G. W. F. Drake 1,∗, Aaron T. Bondy 2 Abstract High precision variational calculations for helium in Hylleraas coordinates are used to obtain a combination of quantum defect expansions for the nonrelativistic energy and 1 / n 1/n expansions for the relativistic and quantum electrodynamic (QED) corrections. The extrapolations based on direct calculations for the singlet and triplet P P -states up to principal quantum number n = 35 n=35 provide ionization energies of the 1 s n p 1 P 1 1snp\;^{1}P_{1} and P c 3 {}^{3}P_{c} (centroid) states up to n = 102 n=102 with accuracies better than ± \pm 1 kHz. The calculated ionization energies are combined with 28 measured transition frequencies to obtain values for the ionization energy of the 1 s 2 s 3 S 1 1s2s\;^{3}S_{1} state. The final result of 1152 842 742.705(16) MHz differs from theory by 0.474 ± 0.052 0.474\pm 0.052 MHz, and provides a strong confirmation of the 9 σ \sigma disagreement between theory and experiment obtained previously by quantum defect extrapolation of experimental data to the series limit. An analysis of the quantum defect method is presented, and second-order mass polarization (recoil) terms are identified that vary as 1 / n 2 1/n^{2} in lowest order. The nonrelativistic part provides a theoretical justification for the effective reduced-mass Rydberg R M ( + ) R_{M}^{(+)} based on the phenomenological model of a Rydberg electron scattering from a He + core. The Ritz expansion for the nonrelativistic energy is verified to an unprecedented 20-figure accuracy. pacs 31.15.ap, 31.15.ac, 32.10.Dk I Introduction Recent high precision measurements of transition frequencies to the high-lying singlet and triplet P -states of helium as high as principal quantum number n=102 Clausen2021 ; Clausen2025 have confirmed a 9\sigma disagreement between theory Pachucki2017 ; Patkos2021 and experiment for the ionization energy of the metastable 1s2s\;^{3}S_{1} state. The origin of the discrepancy remains unexplained, even though helium is a fundamental three-body problem for which high precision calculations are available, including electron correlation, relativistic and quantum electrodynamic (QED) corrections for the ground and low-lying excited states 1s2s\;^{3}S_{1} state Yan1995 ; Pachucki2012 ; Pachucki2010 ; Zheng2017 ; Kato2018 . These measurements have stimulated a wave of theoretical work to develop computational methods capable of matching spectroscopic accuracy at the 1 kHz level Bondy2025 ; Drake2026 ; Chi2025 ; Fang2026 for the high-lying Rydberg states. Complete calculations in Hylleraas coordinates are now available up to up to n=35 Drake2026 . The original measurements and analysis of Clausen et al. Clausen2021 ; Clausen2025 were based on quantum defect extrapolations of the 1s2s\;^{1}S_{0}-1snp\;^{1}P_{1} and 1s2s\;^{3}S_{1}-1snp\;^{3}P_{J} transition frequencies to the series limit, using a combination of theoretical data for low- n and measured transition frequencies for high- n (along with the accurately known 1s2s\;^{1}S_{0}-1s2s\;^{3}S_{1} intercombination transition frequency Rengelink2018 ; Steinebach2026 ), to determine the absolute ionization energy of the lower 1s2s\;^{3}S_{1} state. Although the quantum defect method is well-established and widely used, it is still a semi-empirical theory not fully derivable from fundamental atomic physics. Especially the Ritz expansion, which includes only even powers of 1/(n-\delta(n)) (where \delta(n) is the quantum defect), is questionable since relativistic and QED corrections do not satisfy the conditions for its validity DrakeAdv . Our previous work circumvented the need for quantum defect extrapolations by providing direct high-precision calculations of the ionization energies of the 1snp\;^{1}P and {}^{3}P states, including relativistic and QED corrections, for n up to 35. This considerably extended the range of n beyond the previous limit of 10 DrakeYan92 for which high precision calculations are are available. The extended range is made tractable in Hylleraas coordinates for the wave functions by the use of triple basis sets in which each combination of powers in the basis set members of the form \displaystyle\phi_{i,j,k}^{(p)}({\bf r}_{1},{\bf r}_{2}) \displaystyle= \displaystyle r_{1}^{i}r_{2}^{j}r_{12}^{k}\exp(-\alpha_{p}r_{1}-\beta_{p}r_{2})\cos(\theta_{2}) (1) \displaystyle\mbox{}\pm\mbox{exchange} is included three times with independently optimized nonlinear parameters \alpha_{p} and \beta_{p} ( p=1,2,3 ) Drake87 ; DrakeMakowski88 . Here {\bf r}_{1} and {\bf r}_{2} are the coordinates of the two electrons relative to the nucleus, and r_{12}=|{\bf r}_{1}-{\bf r}_{2}| is the inter-electron separation. The claimed final accuracy of \pm 1 kHz or better for n\geq 24 is achievable because the QED contributions, (which may indeed be responsible for the discrepancy for the low-lying states), decrease in proportion to 1/n^{3} , and so are suppressed by a factor of approximately 2000 at n=24 . The theoretical ionization energies therefore provide reliable fixed reference points for transitions to lower-lying states. The above calculations provide reliable reference points for the 11 measured transitions for the P -states up to n=35 , but they do not provide comparison data for the remaining three triplet- P measurements ( n=40,\,50\,\,55 ) and 14 singlet- P measurements up to n=102 Clausen2021 ; Clausen2025 . The aim of the present work is to cover this higher range up to n=102 by a combination of quantum defect extrapolations for the nonrelativistic energy and 1/n expansions for the remaining relativistic and QED corrections. This approach only makes use of QDT under conditions where it is rigorously justified, as further discussed in this article, and avoids possible complications due to relativistic and QED corrections. The 1/n expansions for the latter corrections yield useful insights into the choice of parameters for a quantum defect to atomic energy levels, and especially for the choice of an effective Rydberg constant. The balance of the paper is organized as follows. Section II provides a brief summary of the overall plan of the calculation, and the computational methods used to generate the nonrelativistic wave functions in Hylleraas coordinates. Especially important are the truncated triple basis sets needed to maintain high accuracy for the high-lying Rydberg states up to n=35 . Section III summarizes the operators needed for the relativistic and QED contributions to the energy of order \alpha^{2} and \alpha^{3} Ry respectively, including relativistic recoil terms. Section IV is the main part of the paper where quantum defect expansions are obtained for the nonrelativistic energies and 1/n expansions for all the other matrix elements needed to calculate the relativistic and QED contributions. This section identifies second-order mass polarization (recoil) terms that have a leading 1/n^{2} dependence with state-independent coefficients. They provide a formal justification for the phenomenological model of an electron scattering from a He + core in calculating the reduced electron mass. Section V presents the results for the calculated ionization energies of the Rydberg P -states, and their combination with the measured transition frequencies to determine the ionization energies of the metastable 2\;^{1}S_{0} and 2\;^{3}S_{1} states. Section VI presents the conclusions and a discussion of the results. II Calculations The overall plan of the calculation is: (i) generate high-precision nonrelativistic wave functions and energies, including the effects of mass polarization, for the helium P -states up to n=35 (ii) obtain quantum defect expansions for the nonrelativistic energies, (iii) use the wave functions to calculate the matrix elements needed for the relativistic and QED corrections, (iv) obtain 1/n expansions for the relativistic and QED corrections,