Certificates without Electrons? Theory and Evidence on Impacts from AI-Driven Power Demand
Dana Golden, Aruna Balasubramanian, Niranjan Balasubramanian · 2026
Read Certificates without Electrons? Theory and Evidence on Impacts from AI-Driven Power Demand by Dana Golden, Aruna Balasubramanian, Niranjan Balasubramanian (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-00811.txt.
Introduction
Golden and co-authors ask if green claims by data centers hold up on the grid in this 2026 paper. Data centers now use 4.4 percent of U.S. electricity. Big firms claim carbon neutrality through renewable certificates and power purchase deals.
Their game-theoretic model lets a data center pick certificates, purchase deals, or on-site generation. Power firms choose entry under shifting finance costs. A timing wedge stands out: use and credited green power peak at unlike hours. That gap can hurt reliability, lift prices, and raise emissions, even at full certificate cover. Tests use the staggered release of large AI models as a natural experiment. Near data centers, fossil output, prices, and outages all rise, the authors find. Prices climb up to 25 percent in treated PJM zones. Sites with on-site power flip the power-quality effect, as the model predicts.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dana Golden, Aruna Balasubramanian, Niranjan Balasubramanian |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 82 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.00811
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Certificates without Electrons? Theory and Evidence on Impacts from AI-Driven Power Demand Dana Golden, Aruna Balasubramanian, Niranjan Balasubramanian Abstract Data centers now account for 4.4% of United States electricity demand, yet the grid-level effectiveness of the renewable energy certificates (RECs) and power purchase agreements (PPAs) hyperscalers use to claim carbon neutrality remains unclear. We develop a game-theoretic model in which a data center operator chooses among RECs, PPAs, and behind-the-meter colocation while generators make entry decisions under endogenous financing costs. The model identifies a timing wedge—the mismatch between consumption and credited renewable generation—as a central mechanism through which AI demand degrades reliability, raises prices, and increases emissions even when RECs cover 100% of annual consumption. Colocation with storage addresses this wedge directly and induces the greatest renewable entry by eliminating generator revenue risk. We test these predictions by exploiting the staggered release of large language models as a natural experiment, using difference-in-differences on a novel dataset linking AI activity to local grid outcomes. AI demand significantly increases fossil generation, wholesale prices (up to 25% in treated PJM zones), and outage frequency (0.5–1 additional outages per year) near data centers, with impacts scaling in model size. Data centers with on-site generation exhibit a sign reversal in power-quality effects, consistent with the model’s prediction that behind-the-meter capacity absorbs demand spikes. Counterfactual analyses show that edge inference, spatial reallocation, and colocated storage each substantially mitigate grid impacts, while REC-only strategies do not. Together, our results demonstrate that the externalities of AI to the grid are tightly coupled to procurement design and the spatial organization of data center infrastructure. mode = titleCertificates without Electrons † † highlights: First causal estimates of AI model releases on U.S. power grid stability using staggered difference-in-differences AI activity degrades power quality equivalent to 0.5–1 additional outages per year and increases fossil fuel demand by hundreds of GWh Wholesale electricity prices increase up to 25% in treated PJM zones during AI model activity periods On-site colocated generation and distributed edge inference substantially mitigate grid impacts keywords Artificial intelligence ,Power grids ,Electricity markets ,Reliability ,Power quality ,Econometrics ,Difference-in-differences † † credit: Conceptualization, Methodology, Software, Data Curation, Formal Analysis, Writing – Original Draft, Writing – Review & Editing, Visualization † † credit: Conceptualization, Writing – Review & Editing, Supervision † † credit: Conceptualization, Writing – Review & Editing, Supervision † † corresponding: Corresponding author 1 Introduction Figure 1: Projected data center growth over time. Source: DOE. Over the past six years, data centers have expanded from consuming 1.9% to 4.4% of total U.S. electricity demand (Figure 1 , DOE). This rapid growth—driven largely by artificial intelligence—follows two decades of flat electricity consumption and coincides with nationwide efforts to electrify transport and heating. The combination poses a challenge: grid infrastructure was planned for stable demand, not simultaneous load growth from multiple sectors. Recent anecdotal evidence points to data centers reducing local power quality and raising prices 50 , yet systematic empirical evidence on these grid-level impacts remains scarce. Existing work does not provide causal estimates of how AI deployments affect power systems at the grid level . Techno-economic assessments from international organizations broadly characterize rising AI workloads in the data center market 27 ; 18 . Micro-level studies examine energy performance of AI accelerators and identify workload management opportunities 63 ; 55 . A large computer science literature quantifies the compute, energy, and environmental costs of model development and deployment 66 ; 62 ; 71 ; 5 ; 47 . These provide a foundation for understanding datacenter-level dynamics, but do not address the externalities experienced by other grid users—impacts on power quality, prices, and reliability that matter for energy security. Quantifying and understanding these power grid level impacts is critical from the perspectives of energy reliability and security. In this paper, we ask seek to answer four specific questions: 1) What are the effects of AI model releases on local power quality and power frequency? 2) How do AI training and inference affect electricity consumption around data centers owned by model developers? 3) How do these impacts translate into price effects in the wholesale and retail markets? Additional demand will likely increase prices, but understanding the magnitude of these price increases is important to determining the severity of the issue. 4) How will these impacts be different based on counterfactual scenarios articulating different technical evolutions of AI computing at scale? These scenarios include a shift away from cloud-based inference to edge-based computing, a geographic realignment of data centers away from population clusters, an evolution towards primarily inference-based or primarily training-based workloads, and a significant improvement in overall energy efficiency. One way to answer the above questions is to extrapolate from energy usage measurements (micro measures) within a datacenter to system-level (macro measures) impacts on the grid. This is however, is near infeasible because it requires a great deal of specific internal information that isolates what is run within the datacenter and when. While this data with level of detail is not available (for proprietary and other practical reasons), there are data sources that provide high-level observational data about various aspects of power consumption and quality at the grid-level over the time periods when models were trained and released. How can we answer specific questions about the impact of AI models with this high-level observational data alone? We can draw upon econometric approaches for addressing this problem. In particular, we focus on the Difference-in-Differences (DiD) models which allows us to estimate the causal effects of AI model deployments on power systems, even when some contributing factors are unobservable. By comparing areas around data centers running AI models against control areas, and partitioning observations into pre- and post-release periods, we isolate AI-specific impacts while controlling for temporal and geographic factors. There are multiple technical challenges in applying this standard DiD approach in our setting: (i) There is a lack of specific information about when and where models are trained and released. Further model releases can be staggered, affecting the validity of the standard model which only uses one timepoint. (ii) The DiD method at its core relies on the parallel trends assumption i.e. we would know what would happen if the AI model were not run; in other words the estimates are valid only if we have a fairly accurate estimate of the trend of the variable of interest over time. (iii) There could be other confounding factors contributing to change in the variable of interest (e.g. extreme weather events coinciding with model release times could also cause increased power demand). (iv) No one clean dataset exists including all data useful for analysis. Often data are at different scales, lack linking tables, or require significant processing prior to use for analysis. In some cases, this requires significant efforts for manual mapping, combination, and labeling. Our solution methodology addresses the above challenges: 1) Addressing Inexact Information and Staggered Releases We use a Staggered DiD approach with multiple horizons, which has been used to overcome similar challenges in other applications 10 ; 16 . Staggered DiD with multiple horizons extends the standard two-period (pre/post), two-group setup to settings where treatment activates for different units at different times, leveraging this variation in rollout timing to assess different