Through the PRISM: Principle-Aware, Interpretable, and Multi-Scale Evaluation of Visual Designs
Mona Gandhi*, K J Joseph, Srinivasan Parthasarathy, Sayan Nag · 2026
Read Through the PRISM: Principle-Aware, Interpretable, and Multi-Scale Evaluation of Visual Designs by Mona Gandhi*, K J Joseph, Srinivasan Parthasarathy, Sayan Nag (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-00592.txt.
Introduction
Gandhi and co-authors build a bench that grades visual design by its own rules, not one score. Good design rests on more than one rule at once. Read ease, contrast, line-up, overlap, and flow all play a part. Tools most oft crush those rules to one vague mark.
Their bench, PRISM, bends pro layouts from the Crello set by set rules. Each bent case breaks one named rule for a clean read. Huge train and check sets hold those bent cases. Top sight-word tools prove dull to the bent rules in tests. One big tool sees the whole yet can not split the parts. A three-scale grade frame is built on that base.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mona Gandhi*, K J Joseph, Srinivasan Parthasarathy, Sayan Nag |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.00592
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Through the PRISM: Principle-Aware, Interpretable, and Multi-Scale Evaluation of Visual Designs Mona Gandhi*, K J Joseph, Srinivasan Parthasarathy, Sayan Nag Abstract Effective visual communication stems from the harmony of multiple design principles, such as readability, contrast, alignment, overlap, and coherence, which collectively govern clarity and intent of the communicator. While human designers reason holistically over these principles, machine agents typically condense them into a single heuristic score, offering limited interpretability and diagnostic precision. To address this gap, we introduce PRISM ( PR inciple-aware, I nterpretable, and S tructure-guided Design M odifications), a benchmark that systematically perturbs professional layouts from the Crello dataset along measurable design principles. The benchmark comprises 100K perturbed training samples and 10K perturbed validation designs, each isolating a specific principle violation for controlled analysis of multimodal reasoning about design quality. We show that models like Qwen-2.5-VL and GPT-4o-mini are largely insensitive to targeted principle degradations, whereas GPT-4o exhibits global awareness without fine-grained disentanglement. Building on these insights, we propose a multi-scale evaluation framework that integrates lightweight scorers for quantitative assessment, instruction-tuned vision-language models for localised feedback, and prompt-based methods for global reasoning. Our framework provides interpretable explanations of design failures. Using these localised insights, we show targeted refinements that improve layout quality. Together, PRISM and our framework lay the foundation for interpretable design-literate multimodal reasoning systems. * * footnotetext: Work done at Adobe Research Figure 1 : We introduce PRISM , a benchmark that operationalizes design evaluation through measurable principles of visual composition. Derived from professional layouts, PRISM systematically perturbs examples along five principles: coherence , readability , contrast , alignment , and overlap , isolating targeted violations while preserving other attributes. These controlled perturbations enable interpretable and principle-specific evaluation of models’ sensitivity to localised design degradations and their holistic reasoning about visual quality. 1 Introduction Designing is inherently a process of reasoning about perception and communication. When evaluating a visual composition, human designers do not typically rely on a single notion of “good design”. They often weigh multiple interacting principles such as coherence , readability , contrast , alignment , balance , and many more such design principles 46 . A designer might praise a layout’s overall theme yet still adjust text spacing for legibility or modify color contrast for accessibility. This layered reasoning, which moves fluidly between global intent and local detail, enables designers to make targeted refinements preserving the composition’s purpose while enhancing clarity and aesthetics 19 . In contrast, existing computational evaluation methods reduce this multifaceted process to a single scalar score, such as aesthetic preference or layout similarity 13 ; 34 ; 38 . While convenient, these metrics cannot reveal which aspects of a design are successful or unsuccessful, and they offer little guidance for actionable improvement 30 ; 59 or provide end-to-end refiners 13 . Their aggregation of all principles into a single scalar is at odds with how human designers critique and refine, focusing on specific violations that can be iteratively addressed 30 ; 56 . Recent large language and multimodal models (LLMs and MLLMs) can produce free-form critiques that appear similar to human reasoning 30 ; 10 ; 56 . However, their evaluations are stochastic, qualitative, and non-reproducible. Given the same poster, such models often generate inconsistent feedback, sometimes suggesting unnecessary global edits for well-designed layouts. Further, their responses lack grounding in explicit design principles and provide judgments without measurable justification. Thus, they behave more like subjective critics than consistent evaluators. To bridge this gap, we introduce PRISM ( PR inciple-aware, I nterpretable, and S tructure-guided Design M odifications), a curated perturbation dataset that systematically degrades professionally crafted designs from the Crello corpus 52 along controlled dimensions of coherence , readability , contrast , alignment , and overlap (ref Fig. 1 ). Each perturbation isolates a targeted violation, for example, text color blending into the background for readability, or a mismatch between the headline and imagery for coherence, thus providing principle-specific supervision for multimodal evaluation. These controlled degradations reflect how humans perceive drops in design quality: localised changes in text or contrast disrupt readability, while global inconsistencies undermine coherence and intent. Analysis on PRISM reveals a gap in current models: architectures like Qwen-2.5-VL 1 and GPT-4o-mini 32 often fail to register these controlled degradations, while GPT-4o 20 shows broad semantic sensitivity but lacks consistent separation between fine-grained principles. Building on PRISM, we propose a structured evaluation framework with principle-specific scorers and localisers . PRISM-scorer is a lightweight classifier built on a SigLIP-v2 49 backbone fine-tuned on design data for each principle, trained to produce quantitative scores. For local principles such as readability, we pair these scorers with an instruction-tuned Qwen-2.5-VL model that not only detects issues but also explains where they occur, similar to how a designer highlights specific regions needing adjustment. For higher-level properties such as coherence, which involve semantic and thematic consistency, we use prompting-based evaluation with MLLMs. Finally, we illustrate how the scorer and localiser enable interpretable, iterative refinement using a lightweight beam search-based editing 44 . The editor proposes minimal adjustments that improve targeted principle scores while preserving the overall layout, offering controllable feedback beyond generative MLLMs 7 ; 20 that treat designs as static images. Figure 2 : PRISM-Scorer Performance. \Delta -score bar plot comparing the sensitivity of different models to PRISM perturbations. Each axis shows the change in principle-specific scores between the original and perturbed posters, as assigned by each scorer. Higher values indicate stronger discrimination of principle violations. Refer to Section 4.3 for further details. Unperturbed Coherence Readability Contrast Alignment Overlap Original composed layout from Crello. Text replaced with a different theme to break thematic consistency. Font attributes like size, color and line height modified to reduce legibility. Element colors adjusted to reduce perceptual contrast. Text boxes and icons displaced to disrupt alignment. Icons, texts and elements overlapped, to induce occlusion. Figure 3 : Illustration of PRISM perturbations. The composed layout (left) serves as the reference design. Each perturbed layout (right) isolates a violation of a specific design principle: coherence, alignment, readability, contrast, and overlap, while minimally affecting others. Descriptions below each image summarize the targeted modification. Bounding boxes highlight regions where local edits were applied, providing ground-truth supervision for principle-specific localisation. Our work makes three key contributions. We • Present PRISM, a controlled perturbation dataset that isolates principle-specific degradations in designs. • Propose a principled evaluation framework where each principle has a scorer for quantitative assessment and a localiser for spatially grounded feedback. • Demonstrate that our SigLIP-based scorers cleanly separate principle-specific degradations, outperforming GPT-4o in disentanglement (See Fig. 2 ) , and that our instruction-tuned Qwen-2.5-VL localiser aligns most closely with ground-truth annotations for local principles. These advances establish a principled and interpretable pipeline for evaluating and refining visual design. 2 Related Works Design Evaluation. Design evaluation has been extensively studied across domains and development stages. Early heuristic-based methods 2 ; 15 ; 31 ; 36 ; 54 struggled to capture semantic design attributes. Subsequent approaches 9 enhanced evaluation capabilities but lacked comparative scoring mechanisms, motivating siamese-based approaches 57 ; 13 . 23 trained a model for aesthetic assessment, while 48 perturbed layouts to synthesize poor designs for scoring. More recently, MLLM-based methods have focused on design generation 22 ,