Electronic screening of the friction acting on ions and water molecules in narrow carbon nanotubes
A.W.C. Lau 1, J.B. Sokoloff 1,2 · 2026
Read Electronic screening of the friction acting on ions and water molecules in narrow carbon nanotubes by A.W.C. Lau 1, J.B. Sokoloff 1,2 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-00314.txt.
Introduction
Lau and Sokoloff explain why flow in thin carbon tubes shifts with the tube's wire traits. Tests found protons and water flow faster in tubes that conduct. Those tubes are of nanometer width. Potassium ions, by clash, flow near the same in both tube kinds under a field.
The pair give a plain tale based on screen effects. Free charges in a wire tube screen the bumps that slow a flow. That screen cuts drag on protons and water in the tube. It shapes their push from salt pull as well. Ions under a set field feel the screen in a way that keeps rates matched. The tale fits the split seen in lab runs for each flow kind.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | A.W.C. Lau 1, J.B. Sokoloff 1,2 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.00314
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Electronic screening of the friction acting on ions and water molecules in narrow carbon nanotubes A.W.C. Lau 1, J.B. Sokoloff 1,2 Abstract Li et al. have observed a larger flow rate, resulting from osmotic pressure, of protons and water molecules in nanometer scale diameter metallic carbon nanotubes compared to that in semiconducting carbon nanotubes. The flow rate of potassium ions, however, under an applied electric field is almost the same in metallic and semiconducting nanotubes. We propose a simple physical picture to understand these experimental results by examining the effects of screening by conduction electrons in electrically conducting carbon nanotubes on the friction experienced by protons, water molecules, and ions flowing through the nanotube. I Introduction Understanding the physics at the nanoscale for device applications, such as filtration devices hummer ; noy2 ; corry , fuel cells schuster ; hummer2 ; hummer3 , and sensing devices dellago1 requires an understanding of the flow of ions, protons and water molecules through confined narrow tube-like structures. An important aspect is to elucidate the role of electronic degree of freedom in determining the transport properties of carbon nanotubes (CNTs) quantum ; cui . Whereas these references deal with ions and water in nanotubes with radii greater than a nanometer, our treatment deals with nanotubes with diameters less than 1.3\,\mbox{nm} . Recently, Li et al. Noy-Nature-Mat have experimentally studied the effects of the electron conductivity of a CNT on the flow of ions and water through a subnanometer diameter nanotube. They have found that the mobility of water and hydronium and hydroxide ions is larger in metallic nanotubes than its value in semiconducting nanotubes, but the mobility of ions is about the same. In order to interpret their experimental results, molecular dynamics simulations have been performed in which the effects of polarization of the nanotube due to conduction electrons of the tube are treated using the Thole tensor thole . It takes into account for the interaction between the dipole moments induced in the carbon atoms due to the electric field of the water and the ions in the nanotube. The polarization of a metallic nanotube is treated by choosing the parameters in the Thole tensor to produce a large value of the component of the polarizability of the nanotube parallel to its axis. In this paper, we discuss the experimental results of Ref. Noy-Nature-Mat and related issues, in the context of the screening of the interaction of the water molecules and ions in the nanotube with the carbon atoms in electrically conducting nanotubes. We treat the screening within the Thomas-Fermi approximation, which is valid when electron density is sufficiently high ashcroft ; TF-sim . Since the band gaps in semiconducting carbon nanotubes are relatively small, it should give qualitatively correct results for semiconducting nanotubes as well. In Section II , the experimental methods used to study the flow of ions, protons and water molecules through carbon nanotubes are summarized and an explanation is proposed for why the mobility of ions is almost the same in metallic and semiconducting nanaotubes. In Section III , we argue that the screening due to conduction electrons in semiconducting and in metallic CNTs can account for the larger mobility of protons and water molecules in metallic CNTs than in semiconducting CNTs. Section IV discusses the contribution to the friction acting on protons due to electronic excitations in the nanotube. In Section V , it is shown that the interaction between a proton or ion with nanotube due to the polarization of the carbon atoms by the electric field of the proton or ion is able to lower their energy sufficiently to allow them to reside in the tube. Section VI discusses what we can learn from the existence of proton conductivity in nanotubes containing water wires. In Section VII , it is shown that it is possible for charged defects in a water wire, such as hydronium or hydroxide ions to be prevented from flowing with a water wire that is pushed through a nanotube by an applied pressure or osmotic pressure. II Summary of the experimental methods used to measure ion, proton, and water flow through metal and semiconductor nanotubes Let us examine the experimental situation by which the flow of ions, of protons, and of water is measured in Ref. Noy-Nature-Mat . The conduction from hydronium ions is determined by surrounding a pH sensitive material by a lipid membrane penetrated by several nanotubes. Hydronium ions are added to the region outside of this membrane by adding acid. The number of these ions that have flowed through the nanotubes is determined by measuring the pH inside the lipid membrane. See Fig. 3a in Ref. Noy-Nature-Mat . The method of measuring the electrical conduction due to ions is illustrated in Fig. 1c in Ref. Noy-Nature-Mat . Two lipid enclosed droplets are connected by a nanotube. An electrical potential between the droplets is created by placing an electrode connected to a battery in each of the droplets. If the nanotube is an electrical conductor, the region inside the tube is an equipotential region. In the Appendix A , we estimate that the time required for the semiconducting nanotube to become an equipotential region once an electric field is applied is only of the order of 10^{-5}\,\mbox{s} . Therefore, it is reasonable to assume that the nanotube is an equipotential region during the experiment. Then, the electric field inside the tube is zero for semiconducting in addition to metallic nanotubes. If the applied electric field points from left to right, the left side is negatively charged and the right side is positively charged. Therefore, ions on the left side will be pulled towards the opening of the tube, enter the tube and then drift through the inside of the tube, where they are subject to zero electric field. Friction might initially stop the ion in the tube, but it can still diffuse (in both directions) and it can be pushed along if another ion enters the tube and collides with it. Therefore, it is resonable that the ionic conduction is the same for both metallic and semiconducting nanotubes, because as long as the electronic conductivity of the nanotube is nonzero, the tube is an equipotential, and hence, the ion is only acted on by the electric field when the ion is outside the nanotube. A possible model for the motion of ions through the nanotube is presented in Appendix B. The mechanism proposed in Ref. Noy-Nature-Mat to study the flow of protons through the nanotubes is based on the diffusion of protons from a region of high concentration (i.e., low pH) to a region of low concentration (i.e. high pH). Since what is reported in Ref. Noy-Nature-Mat is diffusion of protons, the measured mobilities must actually be the mobilities calculated from the Nearnst-Einstein equation. On the other hand, the water flow rate reported in Ref. Noy-Nature-Mat is measured by osmotic pressure created by placing sugar molecules in the solution outside of the membrane, which pulls water molecules out of a region surrounded by a lipid membrane through nanotubes that are inserted in the membrane. Note that sugar molecules were chosen in the experiment because they are too big to pass