Dynamical Sauter-Schwinger pair creation process from Feynman perspective: Comparison of boundary- and initial-value approaches
J. Z. Kamiński, A. Bechler, M. M. Majczak, K. Krajewska · 2026
Read Dynamical Sauter-Schwinger pair creation process from Feynman perspective: Comparison of boundary- and initial-value approaches by J. Z. Kamiński, A. Bechler, M. M. Majczak, K. Krajewska (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-00236.txt.
Introduction
Kamiński and co-authors weigh two routes to pairs born from a strong field in empty space. A fierce field can pull pairs of bits and anti-bits from the void. One route leans on Feynman's view of anti-bits as time-flipped kin. It writes the odds as an endless sum of clash terms.
The team shows that sum can be closed by a shift in edge rules. Set the edge rules right and the route matches known clash math. A next route starts from set start states in the Dirac sea tale. Swapped spread tools mark that shift. Tests on a smooth pulse of field show both routes near-match on broad counts. Fine spin splits still part ways in clear marks.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | J. Z. Kamiński, A. Bechler, M. M. Majczak, K. Krajewska |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 88 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.00236
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Dynamical Sauter-Schwinger pair creation process from Feynman perspective: Comparison of boundary- and initial-value approaches J. Z. Kamiński, A. Bechler, M. M. Majczak, K. Krajewska Abstract We investigate the dynamical Sauter-Schwinger pair creation process from the vacuum by an electromagnetic background field using two alternative approaches. The first one is based on the Feynman interpretation of positrons and the space-time description of Quantum Electrodynamics, which leads to the spin and momentum probability amplitudes expressed as the infinite Born series with respect to the background field. We demonstrate that in order to sum up this series exactly, the problem can be reduced to solving the Dirac equation with uniquely defined Feynman or anti-Feynman boundary conditions. The use of these boundary conditions leads to the results that are equivalent to the scattering matrix theory and consistent with the worldline formalism. Alternative way of investigating the dynamical Sauter-Schwinger process consists in solving the Dirac equation with normalized initial (final) conditions. It is shown that this method follows from the suitably modified Feynman space-time approach, in which the Feynman propagators are replaced by the retarded (advanced) propagators. By doing so it is implicitly assumed that negative energy solutions describe electrons filling the Dirac sea (i.e., representing the Dirac vacuum) and the process of pair creation consists in the excitation of these electrons to the positive energy states. For both the boundary- and initial-value approaches the helicity-entangled momentum distributions are discussed and compared. Predictions of the two approaches are illustrated numerically for the homogeneous electric field pulse and for parameters such that for the spin summed up distributions both methods lead to nearly the same, although not identical, results. It is shown that even in such cases the spin- or helicity-resolved momentum distributions exhibit significant differences. I Introduction We start our discussion by quoting the Bjorken and Drell textbook Bjorken and Drell 1964 : “The propagator approach to a relativistic quantum theory pioneered in 1949 by Feynman has provided a practical, as well as intuitively appealing, formulation of quantum electrodynamics and a fertile approach to a broad class of problems in the theory of elementary particles. The entire renormalization program, basic to the present confidence of theorists in the predictions of quantum electrodynamics, is in fact dependent on a Feynman graph analysis, as is also considerable progress in the proofs of analytic properties required to write dispersion relations. Indeed, one may go so far as to adopt the extreme view that the set of all Feynman graphs is the theory”. The subsequent development of relativistic quantum field theories, starting from Quantum Electrodynamics (QED) and culminating in the formulation of the Standard Model, seems to confirm this point of view (see, e.g., ’t Hooft and Veltman 1974 ; Veltman 1994 ; Itzykson and Zuber 1980 ; Álvarez-Gaumé and Vázquez-Mozo 2012 ; Kleiss 2021 ; D’Auria and Trigiante 2016 ), at least from computational and practical perspectives. In fact, the first proof of the renormalizability of the electroweak unification theory Glashow 1959 ; Salam and Ward 1959 ; Weinberg 1967 utilized the Feynman diagrammatic approach (see, e.g., ’t Hooft and Veltman 1972 and references therein), as described for instance in Weinberg 1994 . Therefore, in this paper we also use the Feynman space-time approach Feynman 1949a ; Feynman 1949b ; Feynman 1998 (for historical notes see, e.g., Schweber 1986 ; Schweber 1994 ; Wüthrich 2010 ). More specifically, we discuss what conclusions it leads to if applied to the dynamical Sauter-Schwinger process – generalization of the pair creation process by a constant electric field, that was originally investigated by Sauter Sauter 1931 and Schwinger Schwinger 1951 . Dynamical Sauter-Schwinger pair creation is a fundamental quantum process in Strong Field QED (SFQED), an area investigating processes driven by electromagnetic background fields that are descibed by classical four-vector potentials A^{\mu}(x) . These fields either modify existing QED processes (e.g., Compton or Mott scattering) or induce entirely new phenomena, such as a field-driven pair creation. Even though some SFQED processes have been studied just after the theoretical formulation of QED (see, e.g., Sauter 1931 ; Heisenberg and Euler 1936 ; Schwinger 1951 ), a revival of interest in this subject occurred with the discovery of very strong magnetic fields in the Universe (see, e.g., Treumann et al. 2014 ; Enoto et al. 2019 and references therein) and the development of experimental methods that allow generation of strong electromagnetic fields in laboratory conditions. The latter can be accomplished, for example, as a result of heavy ion collisions Greiner et al. 1980 , channeling of the high-energy charged particles (possibly protons or antiprotons from the Large Hadron Collider) through crystals or thin foils Gemmell 1974 , or by amplifying and shortening the time duration of many laser pulses Bulanov et al. 2010 . Let us also mention a new direction related to the bound-free electron-positron pair production scenario discussed recently in Remme et al. 2026 . The bibliography of this subject is nowadays enormous, hence, we cite only some selected books and review articles Fradkin et al. 1991 ; Grib et al. 1994 ; Khalilov 1996 ; Ritus 1985 ; Nikishov 1985 ; Rafelski et al. 1978 ; Roshchupkin 1996 ; Mourou et al. 2006 ; Salamin et al. 2006 ; Ehlotzky et al. 2009 ; Ruffini et al. 2010 ; Di Piazza et al. 2012 ; Gelis and Tanji 2016 ; Cajiao Vélez et al. 2019 ; Sun et al. 2022 ; Gonoskov et al. 2022 ; Brodin and Zamanian 2022 ; Fedotov et al. 2023 ; Popruzhenko and Fedotov 2023 ; Sarri et al. 2025 . Historically (see, e.g., Schweber 1994 and the Feynman’s lecture in Feynman and Weinberg 1987 ), the development of QED occurred in two steps, which were inextricably linked to the existence of negative energy solutions of the free Dirac equation and their physical interpretation. At first, the Dirac interpretation was adopted. In this approach, the negative energy solutions described electrons, which, thanks to the Pauli exclusion principle, filled the so-called Dirac sea Dirac 1930a . Additionally, the absence of an electron in it was interpreted as a positron, following the discovery of this particle in cosmic rays by Anderson Anderson 1933 . This point of view, which one can call the pre-Feynman approach, sufficiently well described many quantum processes (e.g., the Dirac Dirac 1930b and Breit-Wheeler Breit and Wheeler 1934 processes, or the creation of pairs by quantum tunneling, first investigated by Sauter Sauter 1931 ) until radiative corrections began to be studied Schweber 1994 . Moreover, the Dirac interpretation was exclusively applicable to fermions. It was not applicable to bosons with zero spin, for which one also encounters negative energy solutions of the free Klein-Gordon equation. To solve these problems, Feynman interpreted negative energy solutions as those describing antiparticles, introduced a new type of Green’s functions (also present in the earlier work by Tomonaga Tomonaga 1946 ; see also Rivier and Stuecklberg 1948 and references therein), which are now commonly called the Feynman propagators Bjorken and Drell 1964 , and proposed the diagrammatic way of determining the radiative corrections. The Feynman approach led to the development of modern renormalizable QED, in which the Dirac sea no longer appears. Independently of Feynman research, using other equivalent