Frequency-time-resolved Imaging Spectroscopy of Fine Structures in a Solar Radio Noise Storm

Daniel L. Clarkson, Eduard P. Kontar · 2026

Read Frequency-time-resolved Imaging Spectroscopy of Fine Structures in a Solar Radio Noise Storm by Daniel L. Clarkson, Eduard P. Kontar (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-31450.txt.

Introduction

Clarkson and Kontar present imaging spectroscopy of a noise storm observed by LOFAR between 30 and 40 MHz, with scattering simulations. The continuum forms a bright, compact source drifting across the disk. Across the band, its size is less than half that of typical type III burst sources. Type I bursts, S-bursts and spikes tucked inside share identical apparent sizes, suggesting a common mechanism. Simulations show compact sizes arise inside closed magnetic structures, where turbulence directs radiation away from the observer. Densities, gradients and turbulence matter only secondarily.

Catalog record

CREATORDaniel L. Clarkson, Eduard P. Kontar
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61312
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.31450

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Frequency-time-resolved Imaging Spectroscopy of Fine Structures in a Solar Radio Noise Storm Daniel L. Clarkson, Eduard P. Kontar Abstract Solar radio noise storms are common phenomena, composed of broadband continuum emission embedded with diverse fine structures, yet their unusually compact apparent sizes remain unexplained. We present frequency-time-resolved imaging spectroscopy of a near-disk-center noise storm observed by LOFAR between 30–40 MHz, together with anisotropic radio-wave scattering simulations. The continuum forms a bright, spatially compact source that drifts across the solar disk over tens of minutes. Across the band, the measured apparent major axis is ∼ 8.0 ​ ′ \sim 8.0\arcmin to ∼ 4.3 ​ ′ \sim 4.3\arcmin between 31.3 and 38.4 MHz, less than half the size of typical type III burst sources at comparable frequencies. Embedded type I bursts, S-bursts, and spikes exhibit a range of dynamic spectra appearances, yet share nearly identical apparent sizes within uncertainties, suggesting a common size-determining mechanism. Using anisotropic scattering simulations, we show that compact apparent source sizes naturally arise for emission embedded within closed magnetic field structures, where anisotropic turbulence directs radiation away from the observer’s line of sight. Additional modifications arise from enhanced coronal densities, steeper density gradients, reduced turbulence levels, and strong fluctuation anisotropy, but these exert secondary influence. Our results provide a unified explanation for the similar apparent sizes of diverse fine structures in noise storms, and demonstrate that the compactness of type I storm sources is governed primarily by the large-scale coronal environment rather than intrinsic differences in emission processes, where the magnetic topology plays a crucial role in determining the observed source size. I Introduction Solar radio noise storms are a common, yet puzzling type of radio emission. They are strongly circular polarized and composed of a broadband continuum overlaid with numerous short-lived fine-structures called type I bursts (see Kai et al. 1985 , as a review) . Noise storms can last for hours to days and are often associated with large, complex sunspot groups ( Payne-Scott & Little 1951 ; Kai 1970 ; Stewart 1985 ; Kai et al. 1985 ) , with the storm source observed to lie within coronal loops that can span two active regions ( Kai 1970 ; Kai et al. 1985 ; Mondal & Oberoi 2021 ) . Individual type I bursts often appear in clusters, are typically sub-second in duration, and have bandwidth ratios between 2%–3% ( Elgaroy & Ugland 1970 ; Chernov et al. 1972 ; de Groot et al. 1976 ; Kattenberg & van der Burg 1982 ; Kai et al. 1985 ; Habbal et al. 1989 ; Thejappa & Kundu 1991 ; Sundaram & Subramanian 2004 ; Yang et al. 2025 , e.g.) . Type I bursts are distinct from other types of fine structure such as S-bursts and spikes. At decameter frequencies, S-bursts appear in groups and have instantaneous bandwidths of in the hundreds of kilohertz range ( McConnell 1982 ; Melnik et al. 2010 ) covering total bandwidths of a few megahertz, clear negative frequency drift rates of a few megahertz per second, and durations \sim 0.5 s ( Melnik et al. 2010 ; Morosan et al. 2015 , e.g.) . Decameter spikes are narrower with bandwidth ratios between 0.1%–0.6% and durations \lesssim 1 s ( Melnik et al. 2014 ; Clarkson et al. 2023 ) , and typically have absolute frequency drift rates near zero up to tens of kilohertz per second at 30–50 MHz ( Clarkson et al. 2021 ; Clarkson et al. 2023 , e.g.) . The emission mechanism of type I bursts remains uncertain, with numerous proposed models. Their high brightness temperatures and polarization, along with a lack of observable harmonic component, suggest fundamental plasma emission due to the coalescence or decay of Langmuir waves and low-frequency turbulence (e.g. ion-sound waves). Melrose 1980 suggests that the required generation of Langmuir waves is associated with a loss-cone distribution of trapped electrons in closed magnetic structures, while the low-frequency turbulence is likely present where the corona is being heated, particularly over active regions. However, this scenario does not explain why no harmonic emission is observed. Lyubchyk et al. 2017 propose that in the low beta plasma of active regions, imbalanced turbulence of inertial Alfvén waves can facilitate the growth of Langmuir waves, leading to fundamental radio emission. In this model, no harmonic emission is generated since Landau damping remains strong for the negative wavenumber Langmuir waves. Ratcliffe & Kontar 2014 show that negative wavenumber Langmuir waves can be suppressed due to strong turbulence in coronal loops when the diffusive timescale becomes shorter than the quasilinear timescale. Other suggestions involve moving magnetic features, including small-scale magnetic reconnection ( Bentley et al. 2000 ; Li et al. 2017 ) . Figure 1: Radio, X-ray, and EUV observations. (a) NDA observed 8 hour dynamic spectrum. Time (UT) is shown in 30-minute intervals. The black box shows the times and frequencies observed by LOFAR. (b) LOFAR observed dynamic spectrum across 105 minutes between 30–80 MHz, overlaid with the GOES X-ray flux (white curves) between 0.5–4 Å (lower) and 1–8 Å (upper). Time (UT) is shown in 15-minute intervals. The vertical white dashed lines show the times and frequencies imaged in Figure 7 (see also Figure B1 ). (c) LOFAR time profiles at 30, 40, and 50 MHz, reduced to a time resolution of 5.2 s. (d) Degree of polarization (DoP) observed by the Nançay Decameter Array (NDA) reduced to 5 s time resolution. (e) RHESSI count rates in various energy bands. The red bars indicate times of flaring activity, and the brown dashed lines denote times where the spacecraft leaves and enters the South Atlantic Anomaly (SAA). SDO/AIA images at different wavelengths are shown near 11:53 UT (f-i) and 12:12 UT (j-m) . The red and blue contours represent the HMI magnetogram at 450 and -450 G, respectively. Imaging analysis ( Lang & Willson 1987 ; Dulk & Nelson 1973 ; Mercier et al. 2015 ; Mondal et al. 2024 ; Mondal et al. 2025 , e.g.) , indicates that type I storm source sizes are smaller than type III source sizes Kai 1970 . This is puzzling, given that radio-wave scattering, which dominates the apparent source size, does not differentiate between burst types ( Kontar et al. 2019 ) . Moreover, studies investigating the spatial variation of frequency-time structures in noise storms are virtually non-existent, as most observations are conducted at a single frequency. At decimeter frequencies, Lang & Willson 1987 observed sizes of 40^{\mathit{\prime}\mathit{\prime}} for four compact sources within an elongated source, using the VLA with 9^{\mathit{\prime}\mathit{\prime}} angular resolution at 328 MHz. At 333 MHz, Zlobec et al. 1992 used 4^{\mathit{\prime}\mathit{\prime}} resolution VLA imaging and found source sizes no smaller than 30^{\mathit{\prime}\mathit{\prime}} , with typical sizes between 40 and 90 arcseconds. More recently, Mercier et al. 2015 combined Nançay Radioheliograph and Giant Meterwave Radio Telescope (GMRT) visibilities to achieve 20\arcsec resolution at 236 and 327 MHz, finding compact cores with minimum sizes between 31″–35″. Using the upgraded GMRT, Mondal et al. 2024 observed source sizes between approximately 9″–20″ in the 221–251 MHz range. The small sizes of noise storms are of particular interest when considering the minimum observable sizes of radio sources limited by radio-wave scattering. Kontar

Read the complete text