Subjective Time Deformation in Intertemporal Choice: A Functional Data Analysis Approach

Fabrizio Maturo, Salvador Cruz Rambaud, Vincenzo Li Calzi, Andrea Mazzitelli, Annamaria Porreca · 2026

Read Subjective Time Deformation in Intertemporal Choice: A Functional Data Analysis Approach by Fabrizio Maturo, Salvador Cruz Rambaud, Vincenzo Li Calzi, Andrea Mazzitelli, Annamaria Porreca (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-31265.txt.

Introduction

Maturo and colleagues study how people value money over time, looking at whole discount curves rather than single rates. Most studies boil each person down to one discount rate, but the shape of the curve may hold clues that a single number misses. Monetary equivalence answers from 107 participants become discount curves, smoothed into implicit subjective-time trajectories. Two functional principal components explain 97.44 percent of the variation, and clustering finds three stable profiles of temporal deformation. Standard parametric models fit many individuals well but miss the clustering structure.

Catalog record

CREATORFabrizio Maturo, Salvador Cruz Rambaud, Vincenzo Li Calzi, Andrea Mazzitelli, Annamaria Porreca
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE117931
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.31265

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Subjective Time Deformation in Intertemporal Choice: A Functional Data Analysis Approach Fabrizio Maturo, Salvador Cruz Rambaud, Vincenzo Li Calzi, Andrea Mazzitelli, Annamaria Porreca Abstract Intertemporal choice data are often summarized through scalar discount-rate parameters or fitted by predetermined parametric discount functions. However, when individual choices are observed across several time horizons, relevant information may lie in the shape of the whole discounting trajectory rather than in a single parameter. This paper proposes an applied Functional Data Analysis framework for reconstructing and analyzing implicit subjective-time trajectories from discrete intertemporal equivalence judgments. Monetary equivalence responses collected through a multilingual questionnaire are transformed into individual discount curves, regularized by monotone smoothing, and used to recover normalized implicit subjective-time trajectories. These trajectories are examined through derivative-based summaries, Functional Principal Component Analysis, and clustering on standardized functional principal component scores. The empirical application, based on 107 participants, shows that heterogeneity in intertemporal choice is not fully captured by scalar discount-rate variation. The first two functional principal components explain 97.44% of the variability of the centered trajectories, indicating a low-dimensional functional structure. Functional clustering identifies three stable profiles of temporal deformation. Bootstrap stability analysis and extensive sensitivity checks, involving retained components, clustering algorithms, functional distances, derivative-based semi-metrics, smoothing-basis specifications, and outlier treatment, support the robustness of the main clustering structure. Parametric benchmarks based on exponential, Weber–Fechner, and Stevens specifications show that classical subjective-time models provide accurate fits for many individuals, but do not fully recover the functional clustering structure. The comparison with explicit subjective-time perception measures reveals only partial alignment between implicit trajectories reconstructed from choices and directly reported temporal perception. The results indicate that Functional Data Analysis provides a useful applied statistical framework for representing intertemporal choice heterogeneity as variation in functional shape, complementing scalar discount-rate and parametric subjective-time models. Keywords : intertemporal choice, subjective time, Functional Data Analysis, time distortion, discount curves, clustering. 1 Introduction Intertemporal choices represent a fundamental class of decision-making processes in behavioral economics and the psychology of decision-making. When individuals are required to compare alternatives that differ both in value and in the time at which they are realized, the evaluation of future outcomes depends crucially on the temporal dimension [ 8 ] . In this context, time does not constitute a mere external frame of the decision, but directly enters the evaluation process, since an outcome available in the future is generally perceived as less attractive than an outcome available immediately. The classical formulation of this problem is based on the discounted utility model, in which time is treated as an objective and linear variable and the loss of value of future outcomes is represented through an exponential discount function [ 15 ] . This framework has long represented the main theoretical reference in the study of intertemporal preferences, due to its formal simplicity and the possibility of summarizing decision behavior through a single discount parameter [ 15 , 8 , 2 ] . However, a large body of empirical evidence has shown that observed behavior often deviates from the predictions of the exponential model [ 7 , 17 ] . Thus, individuals may exhibit preference reversals, decreasing impatience, the immediacy effect, and other forms of dynamic inconsistency that can not be explained under the assumption of a constant discount rate. From this perspective, anomalies in intertemporal choices should not necessarily be interpreted as simple violations of rationality, but may instead reflect the way individuals perceive and subjectively organize temporal distance. Indeed, the perception of time may not coincide with chronological time. Objectively equal intervals may be experienced as longer or shorter depending on the time horizon considered, the decision context, and certain individual characteristics [ 7 , 17 , 19 , 3 ] . A unifying explanation of these behaviors refers to subjective time perception. In effect, individuals do not experience time as a uniform physical dimension, but rather internally transform it in a nonlinear way [ 19 ] . Within this perspective, a natural way to formalize this idea consists in maintaining the exponential structure of discounting, but applying it not to chronological time t , but to a subjective transformation of time [ 19 ] . In general terms, the discount function can be expressed as F(t)=\exp\{-kg(t)\} , where k represents the discount intensity and g(t) describes the subjective transformation of time [ 3 ] . When g(t)=t , the classical exponential model is recovered as a special case. When, instead, g(t) is nonlinear, the discounting dynamics observed with respect to objective time may take forms consistent with compression, expansion, or local variations in temporal sensitivity. In this sense, the central object of analysis is not only the scalar parameter k , but the temporal transformation itself, which in the empirical part of this study is reconstructed at an individual level as \tau_{i}(t) [ 19 , 3 ] . Despite the theoretical relevance of this perspective, many empirical approaches to subjective time perception rely on predetermined parametric specifications, such as logarithmic or power transformations. These forms are parsimonious and easily interpretable, but they impose a priori a functional structure that may not be sufficiently flexible to represent the variety of individual profiles. In particular, the subjective time derived from the process of deformation may exhibit regions with different curvature, local changes in speed, and heterogeneous configurations across the entire time horizon. Consequently, an approach based exclusively on a few parameters may conceal a relevant portion of the information contained in individual trajectories. In this context, Functional Data Analysis provides a methodological framework particularly suited to address this problem, as it allows discrete observations to be treated as realizations of a smooth function defined over a continuous domain. Rather than analyzing separately the observed values at individual time horizons, the functional approach considers the entire trajectory as the statistical unit. This makes it possible to reconstruct individual curves, impose constraints consistent with theory, compute derivatives, apply Functional Principal Component Analysis, and identify groups of subjects characterized by similar forms of temporal deformation. In this way, individual variability is not reduced to a single measure of intensity, but instead is studied as heterogeneity in shape along the temporal domain [ 14 , 9 , 18 ] . The present study proposes a framework that integrates intertemporal choice theory and Functional Data Analysis in order to reconstruct and analyze subjective time as a functional object starting from empirical discounting trajectories. The central idea is that the subjective transformation of time, \tau_{i}(t) , derived from the equivalence judgments expressed by each individual, can be represented as a continuous function describing how chronological time is internally reorganized into perceived temporal distance. Accordingly, \tau_{i}(t) represents subjective time as inferred from choice behavior, and should not be interpreted as a pure psychophysical measure of perceived duration. Rather, it corresponds to an implicit subjective time trajectory reconstructed from intertemporal equivalence judgments. From an empirical perspective, the analysis is based on a multilingual questionnaire administered in Italian, English, and Spanish. Participants provide monetary equivalence judgments across different time horizons, together with explicit measures of subjective time perception, psychometric items related to the perception of time speed, and sociodemographic information. This structure allows for the comparison between an implicit measure of subjective time, derived from intertemporal

Read the complete text