Envy Cycle Elimination with Strategic Agents: Best Responses and Fairness Guarantees
Georgios Amanatidis, Georgios Birmpas, Rebecca Reiffenhäuser · 2026
Read Envy Cycle Elimination with Strategic Agents: Best Responses and Fairness Guarantees by Georgios Amanatidis, Georgios Birmpas, Rebecca Reiffenhäuser (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-31253.txt.
Introduction
Amanatidis, Birmpas and Reiffenhäuser study Envy Cycle Elimination when agents play to win. The plain rule gives each agent a share that is envy-free up to one item, for any head count. Little was known about its equilibria, though. When agents chase their own gain, the rule's clear logic falls apart, even with few agents and plain valuations. Small rule details suddenly loom large. Even so, pure Nash equilibria exist for several plain versions, and fairness holds in rough form for best responders with at most three agents.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Georgios Amanatidis, Georgios Birmpas, Rebecca Reiffenhäuser |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 82584 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.31253
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Envy Cycle Elimination with Strategic Agents: Best Responses and Fairness Guarantees Georgios Amanatidis, Georgios Birmpas, Rebecca Reiffenhäuser Abstract With strong evidence in the literature showing that fairness and truthfulness are incompatible, there is a recent line of work focusing on the fairness properties of equilibria of simple fair division mechanisms, especially Round-Robin. We consider the Envy Cycle Elimination (E-C-E) procedure of Lipton et al. [ 23 ] , one of the most versatile tools in fair division. While this simple and intuitive algorithm achieves allocations that are envy-free up to one item (EF1) for any number of agents and general monotone valuation functions, surprisingly little is known about its behavior when agents act strategically. We demonstrate how the presence of incentives, although highly natural and relevant for the majority of applications, completely removes the intuitive clarity in the algorithm’s execution, even for a few agents and very simple valuation functions. Additionally, while in the standard algorithmic setting there is great flexibility in how the details of E-C-E are implemented, here additional specifications are needed before the procedure is clearly defined, the choice of which has a potentially huge impact on the agents’ behavior. Despite these obstacles, for various natural versions of E-C-E, we give the first results on the existence of Pure Nash Equilibria of the resulting mechanisms, and show there exist versions where fairness guarantees are approximately preserved for agents who play best responses. 1 Introduction The fair allocation of resources is a central problem in Economics that has also attracted significant attention in Mathematics, Political Science, and Computer Science. Over, roughly, the last two decades, there is a flourishing literature defining and exploring a rich landscape of different settings. One of the most studied variants of the problem considers a set of indivisible, desirable resources ( goods ) that must be allocated to a set of agents, each of whom has an additive (or more general) valuation function over the resources. We study this setting under the assumption that agents are strategic . Although great progress has been made on its non-strategic counterparts, the strategic setting is much less explored. The main reason is that truthfulness and fairness are proven to be incompatible, even for restricted settings and across multiple fairness criteria [ 26 , 20 , 15 , 3 ] . More closely investigating the connection between fair division and incentives, some recent works explore the fairness guarantees of non-truthful mechanisms in their equilibria [ 5 , 4 , 10 ] or try to bound the gain an agent may obtain from non-truthful deviations [ 29 ] . Unsurprisingly, these attempts focus on very structured mechanisms, where agents have a somewhat restricted strategy space. The only relatively well-understood case is the renowned Round-Robin algorithm viewed as a one-shot mechanism (i.e., agents provide their whole input right from the beginning). Here, pure Nash equilibria always exist and best-response strategies induce allocations that are fair with respect to the real valuation functions [ 5 , 4 ] , with relaxed fairness results extending to agents with submodular valuation functions. However, focusing on Round-Robin severely limits the reach of these results in two ways. First, its proven fairness guarantees fail to extend beyond submodular valuation functions even in the non-strategic setting. Second, one isolated algorithm preserving fairness when strategic agents choose good reports does not suffice to reach a deeper understanding of the interplay between EF1 fairness and agents’ desire to maximize their utility. Due to these limitations, one of the most natural questions to ask next is whether (some version of) the celebrated Envy-Cycle-Elimination algorithm (E-C-E) of Lipton et al. [ 23 ] exhibits equally nice properties. Technically, E-C-E is not a single algorithm, but rather a whole family of them. Depending on how the next agent and the next item is chosen, or when envy cycles are resolved and in which order, one gets different variants that all output EF1 allocations for monotone valuation functions [ 23 ] , although some might have additional properties [ 9 , 14 ] . Unfortunately, even with additive valuations, given as input before the mechanism starts, the games induced by E-C-E variants are vastly more complicated than their counterparts for Round-Robin. The main reason is that an agent can affect the order in which the agents may receive goods by (un)blocking some of them for a number of rounds in the underlying envy graph. The effects of this complex behavior are also reflected in the infinite incentive ratio of such mechanisms. As recently shown by Tao and Yang [ 29 ] for two very natural E-C-E variants (Standard-E-C-E and Priority-E-C-E herein), there are instances for which an agent may arbitrarily improve her utility by deviating from her true bid. Despite this intricate behavior, we initiate the study of E-C-E and its fairness properties when an agent submits a valuation function that is a best response to the other agents’ bids. Of course, the more structured version of this question is to assume that all agents play a best response simultaneously, i.e., consider pure Nash equilibria. However, the existence of such equilibria is far from trivial and, as we show, not always guaranteed. Nevertheless, we prove that, for a small number of agents, even isolated best responses induce fair allocations from the (true) perspective of the corresponding agents. Our Contributions. To the best of our knowledge, our work is the first that studies the stable states of the celebrated E-C-E algorithm, under the setting of strategic agents. In particular, our paper focuses on the questions of whether pure Nash equilibria always exist, and whether the fairness properties of the algorithm are preserved for agents who play a best response to the other agents’ strategies. We consider several natural variants of E-C-E, and provide both positive and negative results, most of which demonstrate the limits of what can be guaranteed by the algorithm—viewed as a mechanism—in this setting. More specifically: • In Section 3 , we explore the frontier of (non-)existence of pure Nash equilibria. We show that for several versions of E-C-E, pure Nash equilibria always exist for very simple scenarios with two agents who have unary additive valuation functions. At the same time, if one considers more complex valuation functions, then the existence no longer holds, even for extremely simple cases with two agents and four items. • In light of this impossibility, we study whether the fairness properties of the algorithm are preserved for agents who play (pure) best response strategies. In Section 4.1 , we focus on two agents with additive valuation functions, and show that whoever plays a best response is guaranteed to see the resulting allocation as EF1 (according to her true valuation function!) for most versions of E-C-E considered. • Going beyond the case of two agents, in Section 4.2 , we show that for three agents with additive valuation functions, equilibria might fail to induce EF1 allocations even in the simplest E-C-E variant we consider. Nevertheless, we prove there is a version of E-C-E for which anyone playing a best response strategy, is guaranteed to see the resulting allocation as being \frac{1}{2} -EF1. This can be seen as the main technical result of our paper.