Preventing the Breakdown of Tight-Binding Waveguide Optics by Löwdin Orthogonalization
Konrad Tschernig, Florian H. Huber, Janik Wolters, Jasmin Meinecke · 2026
Read Preventing the Breakdown of Tight-Binding Waveguide Optics by Löwdin Orthogonalization by Konrad Tschernig, Florian H. Huber, Janik Wolters, Jasmin Meinecke (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-31074.txt.
Introduction
Tschernig and colleagues fix waveguide optics via Löwdin orthogonalization. The tight-binding model gives light motion through coupling between guided modes. Its guess that guided modes form a basis breaks down when guides are close or arrays grow. Non-orthogonal modes give a generalized eigenvalue problem with overlap, unlike the standard model and wave solutions. Their method builds a clean basis from modes, barely changing shape and keeping balance. The method brings back the standard problem and matches beam tests, capturing long-range coupling and odd hopping phases.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Konrad Tschernig, Florian H. Huber, Janik Wolters, Jasmin Meinecke |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42108 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.31074
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Preventing the Breakdown of Tight-Binding Waveguide Optics by Löwdin Orthogonalization Konrad Tschernig, Florian H. Huber, Janik Wolters, Jasmin Meinecke Abstract Many advancements in optics have relied on the tight-binding approximation, which simplifies the description and prediction of complex system behaviors. This approximation describes the dynamics of the total light field by examining the coupling between the guided modes of individual single-mode substructures – also known as coupled mode theory. However, the underlying assumption, that the guided modes of individual waveguides form an orthogonal basis, breaks down when waveguides are brought into close proximity or when larger arrays are considered. In this work, we systematically analyze the consequences of this non-orthogonality and show that it leads to a generalized eigenvalue problem involving an overlap matrix, causing a fundamental mismatch between the standard TB model and solutions of the paraxial wave equation. To resolve this issue, we introduce a modified TB framework based on the Löwdin orthogonalization, which constructs an orthonormal basis from the non-orthogonal guided modes while minimally altering their physical shape and preserving their symmetry properties. The resulting Löwdin-TB method restores the standard eigenvalue problem and yields excellent agreement with exact beam propagation simulations across a wide range of system sizes and waveguide separations. Furthermore, it captures important physical effects, such as enhanced long-range coupling and nontrivial hopping phases, that are absent in the standard approach. I Introduction The tight-binding (TB) method, as a semi-empirical approach, was introduced in the field of solid-state physics, where it is also known as the linear combination of atomic orbitals (LCAO) method, and is primarily used to calculate the electronic band structure and single-particle Bloch states of materials 28 . More precisely, the TB method is used to simplify complex interactions within a crystal lattice by considering electrons as being tightly bound to atoms, with their wavefunctions overlapping only slightly with neighboring atoms. Over the years, researchers have recognized the TB method’s wide applicability. It is now used in many areas of physics, chemistry, and even biology due to its computational efficiency and ability to provide intuitive insights into the properties of complex systems 10 . This is because the TB method simplifies the analysis of the system by mapping a continuous variable description to a discrete, manageable set of parameters and enables researchers to explore the effects of various perturbations, such as internal imperfections or external driving, with comparatively little effort. For example, nowadays, TB models are used in the study of phononic crystals 20 , Bose-Einstein condensates 29 ; 7 , meta-materials 36 , molecular interactions 25 , and protein folding 21 to name a few. In optics and photonics, the TB method – or coupled mode theory – has proven to be a powerful tool for modeling and simulating the behavior of photonic crystals 5 ; 3 , optical resonators 8 , optical cavities 17 and waveguide arrays 31 ; 6 ; 1 among others. The latter field has spawned many significant advances in photonics, such as the observation of topological states 14 ; 24 ; 11 ; 2 , Anderson localization 27 or artificial gauge fields 19 . Beyond classical light evolution, the TB method is crucial to model the behavior of few- or many-photon states in waveguide structures, leading to photonic quantum random walks 23 and applications in quantum information processing 34 ; 33 . In this study we examine the limitations of the tight-binding method, specifically focusing on the propagation of light in arrays of waveguides. The fundamental equation that governs light propagation in these systems is the paraxial wave equation, which operates in an infinite-dimensional space of complex-valued square-integrable functions 30 . To simplify this vast solution space, the key concept of the tight-binding (TB) approximation is used, which describes the dynamics in terms of a finite-dimensional subspace formed by the guided modes of the individual waveguides. As a result, the overall dynamics can be represented as a finite-dimensional matrix-vector equation, allowing for efficient solutions on computers. However, a significant and often unacknowledged assumption behind this approach is the mutual orthogonality of the guided modes. Especially in the field of discrete quantum optics, the tight-binding Hamiltonian of the optical system under study often constitutes the starting point of any analysis of quantum light state evolution and the orthogonality of the underlying modes is simply taken for granted. In reality, this assumption is only approximately valid. For instance, the guided modes of two separate waveguides can be perfectly orthogonal only when the waveguides are infinitely far apart, a scenario where no light coupling can occur between them. As the distance between the waveguides decreases, the orthogonality assumption becomes increasingly violated. Ultimately, if the waveguides are too close, the tight-binding approximation fails, and its predictions diverge from the outcomes of the paraxial wave equation. In optics, this breakdown has been recognized before in the context of coupled mode theory 12 ; 4 ; 26 . However, a systematic and pedagogical discussion of the overlap problem in paraxial waveguide optics and its solution – especially considering systems beyond 1D-waveguide arrays – is missing in the literature and here we seek to fill this gap. We will first introduce the standard TB method in detail and with an emphasis on the role of the guided mode overlap. As we will show, the dominant reason for the breakdown of the standard TB method is the non-orthogonality of the guided mode basis which induces an often overlooked overlap matrix in the tight-binding equation of motion. As a direct consequence, the eigenvectors of the tight-binding Hamiltonian matrix do not correspond to eigenmodes of the principle (paraxial) Hamiltonian. Instead, the true eigenmodes (supermodes) of the paraxial Hamiltonian correspond to a generalized eigenvalue problem formed by the TB-Hamiltonian- and the overlap-matrix 1 . The mismatch between the TB-Hamiltonian eigenvectors and the paraxial-Hamiltonian eigenmodes is then directly related to deviation of the overlap matrix from the identity matrix. Following this realization, we then introduce a straight-forward method to avoid the overlap-induced breakdown by orthogonalizing the guided mode basis using the Löwdin orthogonalization algorithm 18 . This method was originally proposed by P.-O. Löwdin in 1950 in the context of theoretical chemistry to resolve the non-orthogonality problem in the calculation of the elastic constants of the alkali halides. In the context of optics it was rediscovered decades later under the name of non-orthogonal coupled mode theory 12 ; 4 ; 26 . The Löwdin-transformation preserves the relevant symmetries of the guided mode basis and achieves the orthogonalization involving the smallest possible modifications to the original modes. Recasting the tight-binding Hamiltonian in this new Löwdin-basis renders the overlap-matrix to be the identity matrix \mathbb{1} and the generalized eigenvalue problem to be a standard one. As we will show, the modified TB method (Löwdin-TB method) leads to a closer match with the paraxial wave equation, especially when the waveguides are quite close and numerous. Finally, we will discuss the break-down of the Löwdin-TB method at even shorter distances, where the individual waveguides are no longer separate and instead form multi-mode structures. In this regime, the sub-space spanned by the guided mode basis can no longer support the multi-mode dynamics even after the application of the Löwdin transformation. II Results We